Most Helpful Customer Reviews
22 of 23 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
This is just a tender affair..., September 19, 2005
This review is from: Belle and Sebastian: Just a Modern Rock Story (Hardcover)
I am thankful to Paul Whitelaw for writing this book. The author has collected good material from right at the source, excepting that drummer Richard Colburn declined to be interviewed. He presents basic bios of the band members, and excellent detail about the blossoming period before and around "Tigermilk". Whitelaw even had access to Stuart's correspondence - he seems to have been quite a letter-writer. For the devoted fan just reading this stuff can make you remember how you felt when you first fell in love with Belle & Sebastian.
The book's weakness is the use of a journalistic style peculiar to the British music press, which might be called "NME English." In this idiom it is not a taste crime to use the word "copacetic" in public nor to affect aimlessly awful alliteration. We are treated to sub-headings culled from lyrics, another Melody Maker style-manual staple.
Along with the purple-prose-tinted spectacles of the rock journalist comes an entirely binary value-judgment system in which all that is good is inflated to perfection, all else banished to outer darkness. Everything the band did well he celebrates as a triumph, everything less successful is relegated to the discount bin of disaster. Naturally he venerates the "Tigermilk" and "Sinister" albums, but unjustly condemns the equally brilliant "Arab Strap" largely without musical evidence. Out of commendable loyalty he talks up "Dear Catastrophe Waitress" as a bold new step. This could be straight out of a press release - I was hoping for a more reflective evaluation. The events surrounding "Storytelling" get plenty of attention but the deceptively strong album itself gets short shrift and is tossed into the bargain bin with only FISHYCLAP below it. Similarly with people - attempting to be even-handed, the author still manages to forgive Stuart M. every admitted misstep. Isobel gets the opposite treatment.
However because the material is of great interest to us we can forgive such irritations. I suspect writing every week about intimately subjective experience (which is the lot of the music journo) eventually drains all meaning from everyday vocabulary and syntax, leading to train wrecks of modifiers heaped exponentially upon one-another in search of that original descriptive high. At this length it does begin to wear, but still this is a book all fans will enjoy.
So pick up the book knowing it is not rock criticism but a deservedly sentimental celebration of a beloved band. If Belle and Sebastian were an anime series, this could be fan-fiction. It's not all we want to know but it's a good start.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
8 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Dear Catastrophe Author, January 4, 2006
This review is from: Belle and Sebastian: Just a Modern Rock Story (Hardcover)
The best review was written below by Peter Arnold. While in total agreement with that reviewer, I just want to add a few things. Mainly, that reading this book feels like reading one very, very long NME review - the word play is suprisingly annoying and difficult to read when one just wants to understand a simple point. This kind of word play is fine for a one paragraph review in a rock & roll magazine, but wasteful within a book format. The little bits which are written in italics are especially wasteful and dramatic.
The author also had a tendency to portray band relationships in a gossipy way. While the dynamics of the band's friendships and romances are at first interesting and an important part of the history, the author tends to go on and on and rehash the same old thing even at the end of the book. He clearly disliked Isobel Campbell which made me wonder, was he emotionally involved with her? Did she scorn his romantic advances? Heehee, now I'm playing like the author!
In short, I would have valued more quotes from the band, none of the author's opinions, and a more straightforward manner of writing. Bottom line; Belle and Sebastian are one of my most beloved bands of all time and despite a frustratingly written book, it was still a pleasure to learn about them.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
11 of 14 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
If You're Feeling Curious, August 3, 2005
This review is from: Belle and Sebastian: Just a Modern Rock Story (Hardcover)
If, like me, you enjoy B&S's music but don't know much about them, this is an informative biography. It features capsule biographies, track-by-track details for all the albums and EPs, lots of photos, and is written with that witty flair that seems to come natural to British pop journalists. The author knows his music history, and contra PW's review above can be critical of the band when they deserve it. Finally, the book reprints the lovely liner/stories from the CD booklets, in a larger point-size for greater readability. Stuart Murdoch designed the cover, too.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
![[Start the discussion]](http://g-ecx.images-amazon.com/images/G/01/x-locale/communities/discussion_boards/start-new-discussion-sec._V192250339_.gif){kind=small}
