Bellini: La Sonnambula

Cecilia Bartoli (Artist), Juan Diego Florez (Artist), Vincenzo Bellini (Composer), Alessandro De Marchi (Conductor), Orchestra La Scintilla (Orchestra), Ildebrando D'Arcangelo (Performer) | Format: Audio CD

Product Details

• Performer: Ildebrando D'Arcangelo
• Orchestra: Orchestra La Scintilla
• Conductor: Alessandro De Marchi
• Composer: Vincenzo Bellini
• Audio CD (February 24, 2009)
• SPARS Code: DDD
• Number of Discs: 2
• Label: L'Oiseau-Lyre (Decca)
• ASIN: B001DXF73I
• In-Print Editions: MP3 Download
• Average Customer Review: 3.8 out of 5 stars  See all reviews (20 customer reviews)
• Amazon Best Sellers Rank: #153,477 in Music (See Top 100 in Music)

Editorial Reviews

About the Artist

For more than two decades, Cecilia Bartoli has undeniably been one of the leading artists in the field of classical music. All over the world, her new operatic roles, her concert programs and recording projects - in exclusivity with Decca - are expected with great eagerness and curiosity. The exceptional amount of 6 million CDs sold, more than 200 weeks ranking in the international pop charts, numerous Golden Discs, 4 Grammys (USA), 7 Echos and a Bambi (Germany), two Classical Brit Awards (UK), the Victoire de la Musique (France) and many other prestigious awards reflect the immense success of her solo albums "Vivaldi", "Gluck", "Salieri" and "Opera proibita" and that she is firmly established as today's "best selling classical artist".

Thus, Cecilia Bartoli brings Classical Music close to the hearts of millions of people throughout the world. Apart from that, she is proud that through their popularity, her projects have caused a wide-spread re-evaluation and rediscovery of the neglected composers and forgotten repertoire which she puts up for discussion.

It is not surprising that Herbert von Karajan, Daniel Barenboim and Nikolaus Harnoncourt were among the first conductors Cecilia Bartoli worked with. They noticed her talent at a very early stage when she had barely completed her vocal studies with her parents in her home-town Rome. Since then, many further conductors, pianists and orchestras of highest renown have been her regular partners. In recent years, her work has begun to focus on collaborations with the most significant period instrument orchestras (Akademie für Alte Musik, Les Arts Florissants, Concentus Musicus Wien, Freiburger Barockorchester, Il Giardino Armonico, Kammerorchester Basel, Les Musiciens du Louvre, Orchestra of the Age of Enlightenment, Orchestra La Scintilla). Projects with orchestras where Cecilia Bartoli assumes the overall artistic responsibility have become increasingly important to her and were crowned by the jointly developed and performed programmes with the Vienna Philharmonic Orchestra.

Cecilia Bartoli regularly sings in the most important concert halls in Europe, the United States and Japan. Her stage appearances include prestigious opera houses and festivals such as the Metropolitan Opera in New York, the Royal Opera House Covent Garden in London, La Scala in Milan, the Bavarian State Opera in Munich, the Salzburg Festival and the Zürich Opera House, where she has presented many of her operatic roles for the first time. Most recently, her roles have included Rossini's Fiorilla in "Il Turco in Italia" at Covent Garden and two Handelian heroines, Cleopatra (in "Giulio Cesare" with Marc Minkowski) and Semele (with William Christie) in Zurich.

In 2007/08 Cecilia Bartoli devotes her time to the early 19th century - the era of Italian Romanticism and Belcanto - and especially the legendary singer Maria Malibran. Her 200th birthday on 24th March 2008 was marked by a historical day in Malibran's birthplace Paris: Cecilia Bartoli sang 3 concerts in one day as the centre-piece of a Malibran-Marathon at Salle Pleyel - collaborating with Lang Lang, Vadim Repin, Adam Fischer and Myung-Whun Chung - while the City of Paris showed her Barcelona Concert on a big screen outside the Hôtel de Ville, where Cecilia Bartoli's mobile Malibran Museum was stationed to honour that special day. Further bicentenary events were the CD "Maria", the DVD "The Barcelona Concert/Malibran Rediscovered", extensive concert tours as well as operatic appearances as Cenerentola, Sonnambula and Halevy's Clari - in a Malibran-opera which had not been performed since 1829.

Cecilia Bartoli has been endowed with the Italian Knighthood and is an "Accademico effettivo" of Santa Cecilia, Rome, a French "Chevalier des Arts et des Lettres" and an "Honorary Member" of the Royal Academy of Music, London.

Product Description

No Description Available.
Genre: Classical Music
Media Format: Compact Disk
Rating:
Release Date: 24-FEB-2009

Customer Reviews

Most Helpful Customer Reviews

18 of 19 people found the following review helpful:

5.0 out of 5 stars IT'S CERTAINLY DIFFERENT!, March 10, 2009

By 

L. Mitnick (Chicago, Illinois United States) - See all my reviews
(REAL NAME)   

This review is from: Bellini: La Sonnambula (Audio CD)

I initially wrote another review of this recording which I have since deleted because I've learned a lot from some of the positive and negative reactions to this recording. Major critics of music periodicals from around the world have been equally divided in their opinions ---- ranging from severe admonishment to euphoric ecstasy. The fact that there has been so much controversy about it would seem to me to bode well for it's remaining in the catalogue for a good length of time. The issue of Cecilia Bartoli singing Amina is not all that surprising to me.Frederica von Stade, a lyric mezzo, performed this role with great success, I believe in Dallas, Texas, as well in some other places. I myself years ago heard Marilyn Horne, a much heavier mezzo, perform the final aria and cabaletta at a concert in Chicago. Moreover, I've read in books that mezzos frequently appeared in the role of Amina during and after Bellini's time. Lastly, it is a fact that there are virtually no E flat written in Bellini's score. These top E flats were later added by really high coloratura sopranos like Sembrich, Galli-Curci, Pons, etc. Then, of course, came Callas, who, while retaining the top E flats, interpolated some downward Malibran type of cadenzas that went down to low A flat bellow middle C - one can hear this very distinctly on the Bernstein La Scala performance of 1955. In her performances at La Scala and Cologne in 1957, she eliminated these downward dips. Then of course, came Sutherland, who sang everything high and upward. So -- it is probable that there are many people who are so used to hearing "Sonnambula" peppered with high E flats, that they are bound to be "let down" when they don't hear them.

I realize that we all hear different things differently, and I respect all opinions, except for artist bashers who are fanatics anyway. Bartoli has performed the music of "Sonnambula" in public for years (there are several You Tube videos) utilizing her particular vocal means, which are certainly not inconsiderable. While I love what Callas (and to a lesser extent, Sutherland) does to make this opera such magic, I must admit that I find Bartoli's approach valid and highly listenable. It's something we haven't heard before, and many are not going to get used to it. I find her to be a unique Amina, and I find her singing to be imaginative, impressive, and full of command and authority. I find the coloratura embellishments in "Ah, non guinge" on the solo recital "Maria" to be more spectacular than on that presented on this recording, but the one here is certainly worth listening to. There is little sense at this point to rave about Florez ---- he's the greatest Elvino ever recorded and any other tenor pales next to him. I'm a little sorry that he transposed downwards his beautiful cabaletta in Act II because he could certainly have sung it in the original higher key.

The period instruments don't bother me at all, and I find no problem with either the supporting cast or the conductor, But keep in mind that this is a very different interpretation of the opera, and we must try to keep an open mind. I'm rating it five stars because it has brought me much joy and I've listened to it repeatedly.

No ---- I don't expect everyone to like it. In bel canto opera, there are many musical and vocal possibilities, and those singers who dare attempt it are to be commended. And finally, please remember that Bellini wrote "Sonnambula" for the great Pasta, for whom he also wrote Norma. She sang both operas consistently, and unfortunately, we have no idea of what kind of a voice SHE had. I find all of this controversy wonderful and interesting, and I value everything everyone has to say. No one sees or hears art in the same way. WE must be respectful of that in order for art to be art.

39 of 48 people found the following review helpful:

3.0 out of 5 stars Not up to the competition, February 25, 2009

By 

S. Wells (California) - See all my reviews
(REAL NAME)   

This review is from: Bellini: La Sonnambula (Audio CD)

The fact that the price for this set on Amazon has fallen from over $60 last autumn to less than $20 now speaks eloquently for the quality of this recording. I purchased this some months ago from Amazon UK. Here is my review from the UK web site:

I greatly admire Miss Bartoli and have most of her recordings. In this one she isn't up to her usual standard. She's usually such a thoughtful and intelligent artist that she may have simply spent too much time thinking about this role. To say that it is studied would be kind. "Contrived" would be a more accurate term. I've not heard so many gasps and gulps on a recording since the last time I listened to Richard Tucker. (Sorry, Tucker fans.) Miss Bartoli's singing here is overtly, and overly, emotive. The result is a porcelain-doll preciousness that I find distasteful.

I'll also level some criticism at the erratic conducting of maestro de Marchi. His tempi at times have a lugubrious slowness that ill fits the gentle pathos of this opera. At other places there are sudden accelerations that almost jar the teeth out of one's head. The first act chorus "In Elvezia non v'ha rosa" starts at a pleasant pace but the speed nearly doubles at the words "e innocente tortorella." Granted, I'm looking at the standard Ricordi score, not the critical edition on which this recording is based, and there's no presto subito, or even accelerando, instruction here.

These points are too bad given the otherwise high quality of this recording. I agree with the other American reviewer that Juan Diego Florez is probably the best Elvino on record. But, who buys a recording of "Sonnambula" for the Elvino? Like another reviewer, I agree that Miss Bartoli and Mr. Florez don't blend well together. It sounds almost as if they recorded their duets at different times and in different places and a sound engineer spliced them together. (The booklet indicates that both duets are transposed, as are other scenes which feature both Amina and Elvino.) When individual tracks are available for download, I'd suggested getting Elvino's Act II scene and skipping the rest of this set.

However, I don't mean to say that the contributions of the basso and seconda donna are negligible. Ildebrando D'Arcangelo is splendid as Count Rodolfo, as is Gemma Bertagnolli as Lisa. Mr. D'Arcangelo has a rolling basso cantante voice that's beautifully suited to this role. The role of Lisa is given to a proper seconda donna in this performance rather than relegated to a squeaky soubrette. Actually, when available, you may also want to get the Act II quartet "Lisa mendace anch'essa!" Even the comprimarios cover themselves with glory. It really is too bad that the leading lady and the conductor let down the rest of the show.

For, make no mistake about it, this is Miss Bartoli's show. The "special edition" book is full of portraits of Miss Bartoli that are just as contrived and precious as her singing. The cover photo is a good example. There are many more. There are also the usual portraits of all the rest of the singers with the notable exception of the tenor. The last page of the book has the only photo of Mr. Florez, with Miss Bartoli, and even his pose shows he's second fiddle to the female.

I truly wish that I could give this recording an enthusiastic recommendation. I regret that I can't. With so many other fine recordings of this opera available, this one simply isn't up to the competition. My favourite studio recording remains Joan Sutherland's first take, now available at a budget price. Similarly budget priced and highly enjoyable are the recordings on the Naxos and Arts labels. If you don't mind dated sound and traditional cuts, you can't do better than the live 1957 Callas performance from Cologne.

15 of 19 people found the following review helpful:

3.0 out of 5 stars "A Disappointment", February 26, 2009

By 

Stanley H. Nemeth (Garden Grove, CA United States) - See all my reviews
(REAL NAME)   

This review is from: Bellini: La Sonnambula (Audio CD)

The two preceding reviewers are spot on in singling out the usually wonderful Bartoli - here in the title role of Bellini's sleepwalker Amina - as a major disappointment. Glaringly absent from her performance is the least hint of spontaneity, of any "fine carelessness," of what one of her great predecessors in the role, Joan Sutherland, dubbed a necessary "recklessness." All of Bartoli's phrasings sound far too pre-planned, with odd pauses, gulps, and frequently aspirated fiorature. In short, her performance is sadly both undersung and overacted.

Juan Diego Florez, as Elvino, is the recording's standout, far fresher voiced than Bartoli here, and probably unmatched in this role these days.
Unfortunately, his bright timbre to my ear does not blend nicely with Bartoli's huskier one, with the result that their duets are not especially memorable. On the other hand, as another reviewer's already indicated, in passages where Florez sings largely solo, the recording has its moments of greatest distinction.

D'Arcangelo is a notable Count Rodolfo, but Gemma Bertagnolli as Lisa is lackluster, in no way approaching, say, the astonishingly high standard for this part set by the soprano Dilber in the 1992 Amsterdam Concertgebouw recording.

The special interest of Bartoli's performance lies in its being the first one recorded by a mezzo-soprano, thus calling to mind such famous 19th century predecessors in the role as Pasta and Malibran. The recording's value, though, is more that of just an attempted "historical" reconstruction rather than a grand achievement in its own right. Admirers of Bellini's music lacking such "historical" curiosity would do better listening to the Callas, Sutherland, or Dessay versions of the opera.