From School Library Journal
Gr 5-7-Set in Central Europe, this first-person narrative tells of Benno, a lightning-quick pickpocket who, along with his father and his beloved bear, has been caught as the novel opens. While his father is sentenced to prison for seven months and the bear is caged at the zoo, a kindly, childless police officer takes pity on the motherless 11-year-old boy, and brings him home to the bakery his wife runs. Benno's confusion at living with the former enemy and his reaction to having enough food, new clothes, and the opportunity to go to school are poignant. He realizes that he needn't hoard food or steal money. And, more importantly, he learns the power and wonder of reading. Wrongly accused of stealing the teacher's purse, he runs away, releases the bear, and heads for the forest. He quickly realizes that, while the animal belongs in the forest, he belongs in the city, preparing for his father's return. The bear exhibits improbable understanding and empathy about this decision. Indeed, the creature seems smarter than some of the lesser-developed secondary characters. In an ending that is just a bit too saccharine and neat, Benno decides to live with his father, work in the early mornings at the bakery, and continue his schooling. Themes of loneliness and separation are woven into questions of loyalty and of what constitutes a family. The strong message of the magic and importance of reading will warm librarians' hearts.
Connie Tyrrell Burns, Mahoney Middle School, South Portland, ME
Copyright 2001 Cahners Business Information, Inc.
*Starred Review* Gr. 4-7. Accompanied by his fierce father and beloved pet bear, Benno expertly picks pockets in the marketplace of his Central European city. When he's caught, father and bear are sent away, but Benno is taken in by a good-hearted family that owns a bakery. With them, he finds security, education, and love, until another accusation of theft sends him fleeing and forces him to reconcile his old life with a new future of hope and honesty. The powerful story flirts with fantasy and fairy tale: Benno and his bear have a profound psychic link and fantasy helps sustain Benno through his bleakest moments. But Zucker keeps the telling rooted in the basic needs, emotions, and sensory details that show Benno's disorientation and struggle and will transport readers to icy streets, dark forests, and the warm bakery. Like Joan Aiken's
The Wolves of Willoughby Chase, this deeply affecting first novel is a wonderful, nostalgic adventure story that swings from despair and abuse to delicious comfort from well-meaning adults. In the end, though, it's the child who must rescue himself.
Gillian EngbergCopyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved