9 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Very nice., January 3, 2008
This review is from: Beowulf (Hardcover)
James Rumford, Beowulf: A Hero's Tale Retold (Houghton Mifflin, 2007)
James Rumford's challenge in writing this short adaptation of Beowulf was to do it using only words that would have been present in its original language. He found that he couldn't do it-- Old English lacked indefinite articles, for one thing, and Old English already had some cognates he couldn't get around ("dragon", for example)-- but that he managed to come as close as he did, and still manage to adapt the story in such a way as to make it suitable for young readers, is quite a feat. Some parents might find the resultant text a bit strong for their youngsters, but let's face it, you can't tell the story of Beowulf and his epic battles against various monsters without a bit of nastiness. And, to be fair, the kiddies are going to love it. There's nothing here any more violent than one finds in the Roadrunner cartoons. The diction is clipped and precise, though fast-paced, and the drawings are exquisite, if a bit crude (one assumes, given the subject matter, this was by design). Well worth it, especially if you're using it as part of a larger plot to introduce your kids to the classics. ****
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Amazing - Beowulf for young kids!, May 15, 2009
This review is from: Beowulf (Hardcover)
I was amazed to stumble across this at the library. It presents a reasonably authentic Beowulf to a very young audience, in a way the kids will love. Or at least boys anyway.
I read it tonight to my oldest two, ages 5 and 3; both boys. They were fascinated and the older one had several questions that led to interesting discussions about what life and people were like in the time and place depicted. Knowing them, they'll probably ask to have it read to them again.
The fact that the language was (mostly) limited to words that already existed in the language at the time, before the big influence of the French language began in 1066, is fascinating, if too cerebral to expect my 5 year old to understand.
I'd give it more than 5 stars if I could. This book transcends Amazon's star system. Taking such an old classic and making it so engaging and exciting for such young children today is a very special achievement.
I'd like to see this kind of treatment for other very old classics.
UPDATE:
We've now had the book for about a month. The boys love it, and have chosen it several times for bedtime reading. My wife complains that it takes me almost half an hour to read, and that is a bit long for bedtime reading for their ages, but it's so worth it.
The library will want it back soon. We'll need to get a copy of our own.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Rich language. Transcends age categories., March 16, 2011
This review is from: Beowulf (Hardcover)
Someone at Houghton Mifflin deserves a lot of credit for discovering Rumford. As others note, he uses the gimmick of only English words having Germanic roots, but there's much more to this triumph than that.
Now, I'm a decidedly amateur poetry reader, so bear with me while I struggle to put this into words... his sentences scan; they have rhythm, and meter. He did not go out of his way to recreate the original alliterative verse like Sullivan and Murphy's sublime
Beowulf, A Longman Cultural Edition (better than Heaney, imho); he uses no overt rhyming or alliteration. And yet, reading these out loud, you will hear the strong beats, the stresses that just keep coming and coming, pounding and pounding, until you feel almost as though you are chanting a poem. I spend 45 minutes a night reading to my three and five year old, and, trust me, this one reads well. I'll try to give a few examples, chosen more or less at random.
Here is a sentence from the first page, "I will speak of ogres and dragons and faraway lands." The rhythm runs like this: "da da da da DAda da DAda da DAdada dum". That DAdada DAdada DAdada dum really rolls off the tongue. If that makes no sense, try this, I'll rewrite it with strong syllables in all-caps. i will speak of O-gres and DRA-gons and FAR-a-way Lands. If you say it out loud you'll hear the beat.
Another example, "Soon the hall was filled with talk of the coming fight." Soon the HALL was FILLED with TALK of the COM-ing FIGHT. Dum da DA da DA da DA da da DA da DA.
Another, "When those on the bank saw the reddening waters they feared the worst." when THOSE on the BANK saw the RED-den-ing WAT-ers they FEARED the Worst". da DA da da DA da da DA da da DA da da DA da dum. That last word, worst, has a sort of medium stress, but when reading out loud it naturally falls a little lower than usual to preserve the rhythm.
Enough, already. You see my point. I suppose it's possible that his choice of germanic-root words just created a superabundance of stresses, and by pure random coincidence some of them fell into occassional patterns. But I doubt it; I prefer to think Rumsford is simply brilliant.
About the age-recommendation. I strongly disagree with Amazon.com's stated age of "9-12". I am reading it to my 3 and 5 year olds, and they adore it. I find that good writing is easier to understand. The rear cover itself says "Ages: Strong-hearted and up." I get a kick out of that.
About the artwork: it's good, more "artsy" than "comic book". But you can judge for yourself with Amazon.com's look-inside feature. You should know that there is an illustration on every page. My children enjoyed pointing out little details to me: a raven here, a dragon tail there. I'm sure that helps them appreciate it more, even if they don't always follow the language. There are about 100 words on an average page, some more, some less. This takes just a minute or two to read, and then it's on to the next page and a new illustration.
As I keep saying, when it comes to children's books, they get read, and read, and read, and read, and so it matters a lot that daddy can stand to read them. There has to be some overlap between what children enjoy and what daddy can tolerate. This one is a pleasure. A gift.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No