Most Helpful Customer Reviews
11 of 12 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Thoughtful, Easy to Understand Introduction to Prejudice, December 3, 2000
This review is from: The Berenstain Bears' New Neighbors (Paperback)
This Berenstain book introduces the issues of bigotry and prejudice very well. Pandas move across the street, and Papa Bear is immediately suspicious and a bit miffed by their arrival. He misunderstands the new bears gestures such as planting bamboo sticks for food, and assumes it is an insulting fence. One really delightful thing about this book is the calm easy accuracy about prejudice. Children will relate to Papa's fears and concerns, but they will also understand how incorrect his feelings are when the children bears befriend each other. It shows how easy it is too make an untrue and unfair assumption about another individual. (Interestingly enough, unlike the Arthur books by Marc Brown, this is one of the very few Berenstain Bear books with different looking animals!) The book really works!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 12 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Not that great., September 1, 2008
This review is from: The Berenstain Bears' New Neighbors (Paperback)
Berenstain Bear books are cheap, and cover nearly every issue, but they sometimes have problems with them.
Take this one.
Papa Bear is often the foil to Mama's wisdom. Unfortunately, that means in this book he's stuck being the bigot, disliking their neighbors for being different... even though he's never been presented like that before.
His objections are settled miraculously - and unbelievably - quickly as well.
The whole book comes across as very unrealistic, really.
One point of interest - the Bears host a neighborhood potluck, but they use the term "covered dish dinner" instead.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 21 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Mixed Feelings About This Book, July 11, 2007
This review is from: The Berenstain Bears' New Neighbors (Paperback)
This particular Berenstain Bear book tackles the subject of new neighbors and interacting with others who are "different" from you.
A family who lives near the Bears have moved away to the city and the house is for sale. Who will move in? What will they be like?
Well, it turns out that a group of Pandas have moved in. Papa asks grumpily "What do you suppose they're doing here?" Mama Bear folds her arms and replies matter-of-factly "...I suppose they're doing the same thing we are--living here."
Papa keeps making petty objections and he admits that he's grumpy because they're "different". In fact, he misinterprets a row of bamboo they're planting as a "spite fence". Papa Bear explains that "spite fences" are fences "bad neighbors put up just for spite. They do it just to be mean and keep decent folks from seeing what they're up to."
This irks me because guess what we just bought this weekend? A FENCE. Do you know why? Because OUR new neighbors had a family gathering during the 4th of July and while we're in our back yard, we witnessed them hit their children while the grandfather threatens them with the belt--all the while using the "F" word like there's no tomorrow and screaming at one another. So unfortunately, we can't do anything about the actions of these scum bags...but we CAN put up a fence to at least block our view of their animalistic behavior and dumpy backyard (that used to be lovely, but is now trashed as they use it for storing crap!).
And Papa Bear's assertions are never challenged in the book (although they DO find out that the bamboo "fence" wasn't a fence at all...but plantings because bamboo is their favorite food). This is teaching kids that if people put up fences, THEY'RE the bad neighbors--and are not only mean, but are ALSO hiding some kind of sordid behavior from "decent" neighbors.
So while it's great that this book explores prejudice and how assumptions about people can be far different from reality, I don't like the fact that Papa Bear acts like a bigot--castigating those who build fences as "bad neighbors".
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|