Customer Reviews

Berlin Journal, 1989-1990

5 star:		(0)
4 star:		(0)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

Robert Darnton, am 18th century historian was on sabbatacal in Berlin during the momentous changes of 1989 - 1990. His observations, thoughts and eyewitness accounts of the "change" are contained in his _Berlin Journal_. It is tepid at best.

My primary issue is with Darnton in the role of "historian" as journalist - neither should meddle in the affairs of the other. I also have issues with his lack of perspective and understanding of comtemporary German culture, politics and society. This lack of understanding is a major obstacle in putting the events in their proper perspective. Furthermore, very little attention is given to the slow groundswell of anti-Communist sentiment and the frequency of demonstrations in cities other than Berlin and Leipzig - like Chemnitz (aka "Karl-Marx Stadt" in DDR times), Schwerein and Rostock. Darnton also misses the importance of the "middle classes" and "middle aged" in making the "revolution" happen (it certainly would have failed were it only a "youth movement.")

While it is an interesting read of a magical time, it really lacks the depth and perspective a better informed witness could have brought the book.