From Publishers Weekly
Sherry's (
I'm the Biggest Thing in the Ocean) giant squid with the outsize ego is back, this time asserting his peerless artistic talents. Having shown his skill at drawing both abstractly and from life, the squid declares, I'm making my masterpiece! The book itself, however, packs less of a punch. Although the character's manic eyes, cavernous smile and irrepressible self-esteem still exude plenty of charisma (especially after he paints himself a mustache midway through), there's no compelling narrative arc or antagonist this time out; each spread is just another chance for the squid to show something else he can draw or another style he can adopt. When a double-gatefold reveals that the canvas for the squid's masterpiece—or, as he calls it, his mess-terpiece—is the whale from
Biggest Thing, it's a nice joke, but probably not a big enough one to bring down the house. Ages 3–5.
(June) Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
From School Library Journal
PreSchool-Grade 2ûThe blue giant squid introduced in IÆm the Biggest Thing in the Ocean (Dial, 2007) returns to challenge the art world. Drawing readers underwater for simple demonstrations of artistic skill, the creature happily splashes his ink across page after page of a watercolor-washed sea world. ôI can draw ANYTHING!ö he shouts to all listening ears. Changing expression with the smallest alterations in his bulbous eyes, the enormous squid has a childlike enthusiasm that encourages youngsters to follow him as he exhibits his artistic flair. HeÆs unstoppable by fish or shark, and turns a whale into a canvas for a four-page foldout of Picasso-inspired art. ThereÆs no deep plot here. A mildly threatening shark from cut paper and angry and ink-bedaubed clownfish provide all the drama, all in a lush background of purples and blues. A pleasing additional purchase.
Mary Elam, Forman Elementary School, Plano, TX Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.