Most Helpful Customer Reviews
9 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Music and restoration great, info too sparse, January 15, 2009
This review is from: The Best of Duke Ellington: 1932-1939 (Audio CD)
This new collection of Ellington's Thirties recordings is generous in that it offers 95 selections and meagre in that there is no discographical information at all (no recording dates, no personel, no matrix numbers). The liner notes give some information but leave one pining for more too. There the criticism ends.
Audio restoration by Dutchman Harry Coster (who is attached to the Dutch Jazz Archive and has an outstanding reputation for painstaking restoration of old material) is beyond reproach and the recordings never sounded so good before. And of course there is the music itself, which is formidable, both in musical content and in execution by that peerless group of proud individuals that constituted the Duke Ellington orchestra. These recordings show that Ellington, although not leading a "swing band" in the commercialized sense of the word, influenced almost any other band in those years, American, British or Continental. Which self-respecting band didn't play a (watered down) version of "Caravan" or "Sophisticated Lady"? Ellington influenced a whole generation of composers and arrangers: "Moonglow" bears an uncanny resemblance to Ellington's "Lazy Rhapsody", the opening bars of "Daybreak Express" were copied almost note for note by Jerry Gray when he penned the arrangement of "Chatanooga Choo-Choo" some nine years later, the concept of two trumpeters engaged in a high-note battle in "Tootin'Through the Roof" was adapted for a whole trumpet section by Joe Garland & Glenn Miller in "In the Mood" and copied by Sy Oliver in his arrangement of Tommy Dorsey's version of "Swing High" and so on (Billy May, when arranging for a Sixties Nat Cole album admitted that he thought Ellington "wrote the book"; his arrangements for Barnet and Miller attest to that). Hardly any band however could match the emotional depth of "In a Sentimental Mood", "Azure", "Lost in Meditation" or the relaxed swing of "I Let a Song Go Out of my Heart". Which alto player was not jeaulous of Johnny Hodges' beautiful tone and faultless technique, which trombone player didn't at least attempt to produce the eerie sound of Joe Nanton's plunger mute, which trumpet player didn't try his hand at Rex Stewart's halve-valve technique or Cootie's unique growl and plunger work? Trombonists Lawrence Brown and Juan Tizol didn't have any followers: they were too unique, too individual than that anyone could possibly try to emulate them.
You will find most of Duke Ellington's essential works here, next to the already mentioned there is also "Blue Light", "Serenade to Sweden", the swinging "The Sergeant Was Shy", "St Louis Blues" (with a vocal by Bing Crosby) a "Gypsy Without a Song", but also the (often much maligned) extended works like the four part "Reminiscing in Tempo", "Diminuendo and Crescendo in Blue", the wonderful remake of "Black and Tan Fantasy" etc. etc. While I have some reservations as to the discographical information (or rather, the lack of it), the generous amount of titles, the excellent remastering and the greatness of the music are deserving of the largest amount of stars thinkable.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Some of Ellington's Best, February 6, 2009
This review is from: The Best of Duke Ellington: 1932-1939 (Audio CD)
I own 3 disk career-spanning sets from RCA ( The Centennial Edition - Highlights From 1927-1973) and Columbia ( The Duke: The Columbia Years 1927-1962). I have always had a preference for disk 1 of each because of the 1930's sides. Subsequent reading of the (150 page!) Ellington chapter in Gunther Schuller's marvelous The Swing Era: The Development of Jazz, 1930-1945 (The History of Jazz, Vol. 2), he made the case that these recordings were not only among the Ellington band's best, but among the best in the entire "Swing" canon. After extensive listening to these 4 CDs, I would have to agree.
After Duke's first Cotton Club recordings of the 20's, he began to build the orchestra and a vocabulary for that orchestra that was never exceeded. The fresh sound of innovation fairly drips from these sides. No band ever created 95 separate tracks (no alternates or updates) that are so conisistently lively and original in just 10 years. While they are in the "swing" spirit, the arrangements are much more clever than that term usually implies. The depth of the arrangements and the expertise of the musicians guarantee you'll never tire of these efforts, ranging from the merely excellent to masterpieces.
All recordings were made from original masters, somehow RCA and Sony cooperated so we get to draw here from both sets of masters. While the remastering quality is not quite up to the aforementioned career sets, it is still leagues better than the usual European boxed set standard (Quadromania, ASV, Proper Box). At 4CD's for the price of one, there is simply no reason any Ellington or Swing Music fan should be without this set.
While Never No Lament: The Blanton-Webster Band is generally regarded as The Pinnacle of the Ellington legacy, I actually find these sides more intriguing because (a) there's more stylistic variety and (b) the Blanton/Webster sides are marred by some recording difficulties and many bland vocals.
Update 11/2010: Looks like it's gone. Given the differences noted above in the Columbia mastering vs this one, and the lack of any track info, you have to wonder if this project had truly been sanctified by Sony (Columbia) and RCA.
A lot of this material is still available on the Naxos label with decent remastering and reasonable a price. But if you'd like to secure arguably the best big band music ever recorded with the best fidelity transfers they've ever had or ever will have, hock the family jewels and get the awesome new 11 CD boxed set from the (justifiably) famous Mosaic Records.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
MISSING ELLINGTONIA BACK IN CIRCULATION, April 16, 2009
This review is from: The Best of Duke Ellington: 1932-1939 (Audio CD)
For all Ellington admirers the release of this CD box set is a major event - and at this price an incredible "gift" too. However many CD's of Duke's early and late music one might own there was always one huge gap - his 30's period. And although Sony may have lavished great care in reissuing nearly all his later concept albums (with extra tracks and great research) where the 30's were concerned they've never offered much more than dribs and drabs from their huge catalogue of Columbia recordings he made (only for them) from 1932-39.
Many of us knew what we were missing. In the 70's French CBS issued ALL his Columbia 78's on 15 double LP's. But the limitations of vinyl - and skipping alternate tracks - made fully enjoying these gems a frustrating process. Now with this huge CD release we can understand why so many experts consider he led an even better "swinging band" just prior to making his early 40's Victor classics - which are so small in number eventually one knows every note far too well.
Whereas this box contains a cornucopia of much less familiar but just as important treasures. The chief bonus of course is to hear all this rare music in the clarity of digital sound. And to realize the Columbia engineers did Ellington a big favor in NOT highlighting his individual solists or sections. Providing a constant sensation this band was a justly proud homogenious unit (hand-picked by Duke). Which also reflects the band member's involvement in helping Duke create these complex perfectly executed arrangements. Bar his written composition "Reminiscing in Tempo" none of these 30's tunes sound repetitive or mechanical. With constantly varying patterns between his "star" solists and super-smooth ensemble background work today's listeners can only sit back and marvel at the seemingly effortless intricacy of each one of these 3-minute masterpeices.
Based on the fast tracks on Disc 3 & 4 was this the greatest swing band of them all? The litle known "Bouncing Buoyancy" being a typical example of their abiity to suggest perpetual motion. In this case propelled by the greatest sax section in the history of jazz. Due to the time limitations of 78 shellac this and many other numbers seem to come to a rather abrupt close. But to be left wanting more is in not criticism. Just the reverse.
What more can one ask for? Well, to be honest a few more similar CD's from Sony/BMG. Victor has only 3 tracks in this box - from the 15 they recorded in 33/34. My Italian catalogue shows at least 19 equally valuable Columbia rarities - for those buffs who need to hear every Johnny Hodges solo in digital sound. Victor recordings with a V.
Dinah V
Bugle Call Rag V
Rose Room
Any Time, Any Day, Anywhere
Down a Carolina Lane
Stormy Weather
In the shade of the Old Apple Tree
Rude Interlude
Dallas Doings
Dear Old Southland
Delta Serenade V
Stompy Jones V
Blue Feeling V
Love and Live Tonight V
Moonglow
Sump'n Bout Rhythm
Tough Trucking
Indigo Echoes
Accent on Youth
No Greater Love
A Blues Serenade
Lambeth Walk
Mighty Like the Blues
Little Posey
Weely
25 top draw Duke - with no fillers. No vocals either - as all Ivie Anderson's were issued on 2 English HEP CD's. But it would be sad not to include her infectious "Alabamy Home" - to hear the Ellington sax section "buzzing" at its insouciant best.
It's true this box's sleeve notes don't include the minutia one finds on most CD re-issues. But for the newly intrigued they could do no better than buy Mark Tucker's book "The Duke Ellington Reader" to discover what was being written about Duke - at the same time his band was constantly evolving.
Aptly this collection closes with the miraculous "Country Girl". His greatest ever recording? As his music was always descriptive the title suggests he and the band are saying more about the opposite sex in 3 minutes than any classical composer could - with 30 minutes and a full orchestra at his disposal.
In conclusion these are incredibly welcome digital transfers from his great 30's Columbia years. Hopefully Sony will now release many more. For instance a carefully selected "Best of the Small Groups". Cootie's "Delta Mood" and Johnny's "Wanderlust" the cream of the crop. But of course a thousand other fans will beg to differ!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
