Customer Reviews

Betrayals (Babylon 5, Book 6)

5 star:		(0)
4 star:		(5)
3 star:		(2)
2 star:		(1)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

As the station prepares for a peace conference between the Narn and Centauri, trouble starts to boil. A race known as T'll arrive looking for help but are turned down by everyone. G'kar is very worried by their presence beacuse the Narn are holding their planet captive, which could ruin the peace conference. Meanwhile Ivanova is recieving data cyrstals which show footage of her brother being a spy for an alien race during the war. She also has the trouble with dealing with a new member of the traffic control team who is an awful worker but has a glowing record. How will Babylon 5 survive the peace conference when there is blood involved? By Victoria Carr

This books starts with three distinct threads and moves them with no hurry to their logical conclusions. I expected a cunning plan which would ultimately tie the threads together before the end, but did not get my wish. Well, in fact two of the three threads crossed each other somewhat in the beginning, but it was not fully exploited. In retrospect, the main plot (T'llin) seems the least interesting, with its 'too easy', behave-better-than-your-enemy resolution that you would expect from a Voyager episode, although the ending had its share of humor and tragedy also. The characters were quite themselves, especially Na'Toth had her temperament intact.

The events take place after "The Coming of Shadows" and before "The Long, Twilight Struggle".

The sixth book in the Babylon 5 series, titled Betrayals, continues the generally high quality of the novel line. The book reads much like a two-part episode, with a handful of subplots and one main plot (admittedly somewhat cliched), involving a peace conference between the Narns and the Centauri which may be disrupted by terrorists. Unlike previous novels that focussed mainly on a couple of characters, each of the cast members gets several scenes and their personalities and dialogue fit well with what's presented in the show. In terms of larger significance, the novel doesn't drastically expand our understanding of the Babylon 5 universe, but it does add a little more background into Ivanova and Na'Toth. Now, I wouldn't call the novel line an "electrifying series of original, breathtaking outer-space adventures" like the back cover does, but on the whole I've been happy with the B5 books and Betrayals is no exception.

The first chapter was slow reading, but I guess I can say that about every book I read?

To the point. This book was an 8 out of 10. Stirling did a wonderful job. The author convinced me that an alien race in the novel was NOT guilty of all the crimes they committed because of how the Narn had exploited them. I guess you could say that I "felt" and sympathized for the aliens :)

Stirling also did well in exhibiting the relationship between G'kar and Londo; however, I found a minor, yet quite irritating writing habit Stirling has. The author pretty much _always_ would describe the Doctor as "dark" - almost every time Franklin was brought into the story, we might see the author writing, "And the doctor's dark face began to sweat" or "Franklin crossed his dark arms." Stuff like that. Okay, well, its a minor thing, but just a wee bit annoying that sometimes takes away from the author's credibility as a first class writer.

On the whole, I recommend the book to the reader. The endings were clean and nice. Unlike a typical Babylon 5 episode which only gets around 40 minutes to tell a plot, the story went into depth on character analysis and detail. But more importantly, I was quite on the edge of my seat (or for this matter, on the edge of my couch as I laid down to read the book). Page after page I wanted to know what was going to happen next in all of the little tinyplots that were developing in the story.

Once again, its rated high by myself, with a big fat curvy 8. And my friends know me not to be a nice "rater" :)

This is the second book about a culture the Narn have treated badly. Again, rebels are trying to make trouble and succeed. A fun subplot has Londo and Jkar trying for the same prize. The interaction between them is handled well, exploiting the corruptable character of both. Ivanova is at odds with a subordinate who seems to know something bad about everyone. The final crisis/resolution is a nice suprise. This book might have made a good show, but would not have contributed to the arch JWS has mastered the show on. Stirling did a fine job of capturing the characters in context with the show, not trying to add a "hidden side" that distracts from the story arch as a whole. I felt technically that one context of the aliens causing the problems in the story was not well handled. Bad aliens always seem to have that one special characteristic that lets them do bad things without discovery. Babalon 5 fans will all enjoy the book. Readers without knowledge of the show would be confused at times. But that's the trade off every writer faces when using the characters and story line of a series. It's a good read. Buy the book!

Betrayals is the sixth of the original nine novels, nevertheless it deals with events that took place prior to Clark's Law and The Touch of Your Shadow, the Whisper of Your Name (i.e. the fourth and fifth original novels respectively). The book is set in 2259 during the Narn-Centauri War and the two rival powers have decided to utilize the station for the main purpose for which it was built and which is none other than to serve as a means for promoting peace. As Earthforce plays host to the two warring sides, a group of refugees escorted by members of the planet's armed resistance (all from the Narn-occupied planet T'll) sneak unto the station hoping to capitalize on the high profile event and make a case for their cause. As one after another their efforts fail and the T'llin find themselves gaining nothing more than sympathy (at best), they decide to activate plan B...
On the positive side: S.M. Stirling provides for an accurate description of Babylon 5's main characters which is no small feat. Specifically, throughout the book, the author brings to the forefront most of the characters that we have come to know and love in a way that does not compromise or sacrifice accuracy.
Moreover, on page 126, the author presents a very good description of Narn abuses on T'll, and overall succeeds in presenting an all-too-familiar trend where all-too-often victims become the aggressors at the first given opportunity and/or once the tables the turned.
In addition, the amount of information regarding the B5 universe included in the book is satisfactory and there is no shortage of plots and subplots, which are things that we have come to expect from the show, both on and off screen.
On the downside, although the characters are true to themselves, this novel's writing style is not the best and neither are the plots and subplots, thus the feeling one gets is that the story is "stale," lacking that "something" that will bring it to life and get the reader to not be able to put the book down. In truth, the book starts off rather numb and continues so until the very end.
Moreover, Betrayals is to a certain extent too similar to the plot found in Clark's Law where instead of the Tuchanq delegation arriving on Babylon 5 seeking assistance in rebuilding their homeworld after years of brutal Narn occupation, it is the T'llin who come to Babylon 5 in order to shame the Narn and find allies in their quest to free their home planet.
Finally, there was a silly and wholly unnecessary mistake in that S.M. Stirling kept referring to Susan's brother as "Vanya Ivanova," which is incorrect as he should have used the male form: Vanya Ivanov.
Regardless of its flaws, the book does make the reader feel that they are watching another B5 episode albeit not one of the best ones. 3 Stars
Let's see some more novels!

A book with a plot is good, but too many plots is bad. This book has so many plots that none of them is written in enough depth. The main plot is supposed to be the Narn- Centauri peace conference, but it only begins at the end of the book, and the preperations for it become a useless sub-plot. The T'llin plot is very boring, and reminds of the Tuchanq, which also suffered from the hands of the Narn, in "Clark's Law". That story was much better, since there was much more suspense there.
In closing, this is the worst book of the Babylon 5 novel series I've read.

Pot, kettle, black.

The Centauri and the Narn hate each other, the whole birds and
lizards thing. The Centauri oppress the Narn, so the Narn learn a few
tricks.

The Narn uses this knowledge to oppress and exploit other races. This all ends up being no good for anyone.