27 of 29 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
The Perils of Editing Memory, December 15, 2010
This review is from: Betrayer of Worlds (Fleet of Worlds) (Hardcover)
Lerner and Niven continue to expand their "Worlds" franchise, in this, the fourth book. There will obviously be more. But I fear that they may have gone too far in their effort to wrap all of their old and new plot lines together. For any fan of Niven, the scene a the start of
Ringworld, in which Nessus the Puppeteer recruits Louis Wu to the Ringworld expedition is one of the great episodes in the Known Space series. Now it turns out that wasn't the first time Louis Wu and Nessus met. In fact, they worked together 60 or so years earlier, when Nessus rescued Wu from the Wunderland civil war.
Wu doesn't remember that because Carlos Wu's Amazing Autodoc, which has already reconstructed Beowulf Schaeffer from just his head in
Crashlander, and saved Sigmund Ausfaller several times in the "Fleets" stories, can edit memories themselves, removing chunks of a patient's memory at a Puppeteer's whim, such as knowledge of where Known Space might actually be. A thinking reader has to ask himself why Carlos Wu would have built an advanced autodoc that would permit selective editing of memories? After all, Calros might crawl in the thing some day. But that's not the biggest problem a reader is expected to ignore. Now every reader of Known Space stories has to assume that a character's memories may have selectively edited.
There's more. One of the central premises of the entire Fleets series is that no one except Puppeteers - excuse me, Citizens - knows the whereabouts of Known Space. It's central to the dilemma of the New Terra colonists, to Sigmund Ausfaller's cooperation and to Louis Wu's behavior. But a high school physics student could find known space: extrapolate backwards along the line of flight of the Fleet of Worlds for the 200 years since Puppeteers abandoned Known Space. It's not like a Kempler Rosette of planets can turn corners. Navigate there. Turn on radio equipment and listen for old episodes of "I Love Lucy."
And then there's the current crisis, the Gw'oth colony in the path of the Fleet of Worlds. What motivation did the extremely intelligent Gw'oth - the brightest characters Niven or Lerner have invented yet - to place their colony in the path of disaster?
But if you can accept the permanent loss of reliable narrators, and the suspect premise that Known Space is somehow undiscoverable, the Gw'oth colony location and that thermonuclear reactions can be suppressed by signals transmitted on radio or hyperwave; if you can buy all that, this is a pretty good yarn. I had some trouble with those premises, which is why I give the story only three stars.
And the ending is a bit of a cliffhanger, with bad guys in charge of the Fleet of Worlds, the Ringworld on the virtual horizon, Nessus in exile and the Puppeteers puppets themselves.
Something of a let down after the long-anticipated Pak battle in
Destroyer of Worlds, but even a bad Niven is a treat and this is by no means a bad Niven. Just not as good as the earlier "Fleet" novels.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
18 of 20 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A very good addition to an amazing series, October 16, 2010
This review is from: Betrayer of Worlds (Fleet of Worlds) (Hardcover)
Not the very best of the series (needs more Ausfaller!), but still definitely well worth the read for Known Space or hard sci-fi fans.
Classic Niven (and par for the course on this overall excellent series w/ Lerner): intelligent characters, very nifty uses of the given science and technology, and a good amount of "action" driving the plot forward.
Since Louis Wu is the main protagonist in this volume and the story is set before "Ringworld", the story runs into some of the hazards of writing prequels in a widely read (and well explored) history: requirements of continuity w/ "Ringworld" forces the authors hands in some places.
That's a small complaint, only noteworthy because I've been otherwise enjoying the series immensely.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Hints at what happened to ringworld before the ringworld novel began, September 11, 2011
.....A nice finish leading up to the Ringworld novel.
.....I enjoyed the book and and the prior ones. This one lacked the PaK showdown that still seemed to be hanging as a threat in the prior novel but was well worth the viewing as it tied up loose ends.
.....One has to wonder whatever happened to the Gwoth in later known space books as they are never mentioned.
.....We all know Louis Wu eventually gets addicted to The Wire from the early scenes in Ringworld but with a prior addiction, a bad end to his first encounter with the Puppeteers and shodowy memories, its not surprising he went back to addictive behaviors.
.....Spoiler Alert: At the end of this book there is a data file deletion by nessus that hints at some dark prior event by the puppeteers against ringworld that had to be hidden from the Gwoth. This is prior to the original ringworld novel.
.....The puppeteers are a crazy, paranoid, jumpy herd bunch and we know that ringworld scared the hell out of them so we can guess what they did in "self defense".
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No