Most Helpful Customer Reviews
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Not his best work!, July 31, 2010
This review is from: Betrayers (Nameless Detective Novels) (Hardcover)
Far be if from me to want to give a less-than-rave review to one of my all-time favorite authors. But if I'm honest, I'd have to say this truly was not his best effort. It's almost as if he had a deadline he had to meet, and didn't have time for an intricate plot, well developed characters, or an interwoven connection to the whole. While this series has produced some of the finest material of any writer in this genre, I do believe the character may be played out. After such intricate and refreshing works such as "The Crimes of Jordan Wise" and "The Other Side of Silence" it's difficult to not see the nameless series as becoming somewhat stale. Even the description "nameless" no longer applies. Perhaps it's just that we've come to expect so much from Pronzini. He's so extremely talented, that anything less than his best is more noticeable than it is with other authors. Regardless, the story lines in his latest novel are pretty predictable and ordinary. Personally, I'm waiting for his next departure from the nameless series into something fresh and intriguing again.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Three Cases, August 24, 2010
This review is from: Betrayers (Nameless Detective Novels) (Hardcover)
The three partners in the detective agency founded by the Nameless Detective undertake three separate cases, each exhibiting a common characteristic: betrayal. In alternating chapters, each case is developed until solved, whether the driving force is personal (in the case of Tamara), involves a child (Runyon) or the elderly (Nameless). Tamara's case begins as something personal, but evolves into something deeper as she learns more about a sometime lover. It appears he and his mother are con artists bilking gullible marks for phony charities. Runyon's assignment is to find a bail jumper, which leads to finding a different kind of betrayal, pitting brother against brother and husband against wife. Nameless takes on a pro bono case in which an old woman is being harassed, possibly to force her out of her home so her relative can gain access to funds from its sale, and. more importantly, when Nameless returns home to discover his adopted daughter has a secret which leads him to yet another ugly situation. The Nameless Detective series began in 1966 and now constitutes 34 novels and three short story collections, and is said to be the longest running of its kind. This novel easily could have been three separate short stories, comprising equally entertaining, classic private eye fiction, but is well-written and splendid in its present form nonetheless. Recommended.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
My favorite author - not my favorite of his books, August 3, 2010
This review is from: Betrayers (Nameless Detective Novels) (Hardcover)
Let me start by saying that a 'bad' Pronzini Nameless detective book is already head and shoulders above the work of lesser authors. That said, this book was definitely not one of my favorites. I love, love, love Pronzini, and look forward to his books as the treat they are. This one left me a little bored at times, and only somewhat interested. I actually was kind of anxious for it to be over, to be totally and painfully honest. (and it does indeed pain me to write such negative words about such an outstanding author). The plots were pretty boring, and I had a hard time caring what happened (except to his daughter, although even that story seemed to be reaching a bit). I read these books in particular because I love following 'Nameless/Bill' around as he works, and it bums me out that he was less than a third of the book. Tamara is just fine - as a supporting character, but that storyline just left me cold. I don't think her character is strong enough to carry so much of a book. Or maybe it is just that I have stayed loyal to this series because Bill's character intrigues me and if I wanted a Tamara-like character to follow I would pick a series that featured one. Jake is a little easier to care about, as he reads like a younger 'Nameless', although his lady friend and her issues are beginning to be annoying and add little (nothing?) to the story. One last comment regarding this outstanding husband and wife (Marcia Muller) writing duo. I have been a faithful reader since the very beginning of each of their wonderful, well-written series. But each of their most recent books left me lukewarm at best. My message to them would be- your books and characters are just wonderful as they are. You do not need to try to be creative and make changes to try to make them better. One, it is not working and two, it is not needed. Sometimes change is good; sometimes change is just change.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|