Most Helpful Customer Reviews
28 of 28 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Artful Photo Tribute, October 7, 2009
This review is from: Bette Davis: Larger than Life (Hardcover)
This newest book about Bette Davis is recommended for the many superior photos included, and for the good layout of her films, presented, generally in sequence. There are several factual errors, and the text of the two authors more than occasionally contradicts what the other has written. The errors include actor David Keith being called Brian Keith,by co-author Richard Schickel, and the surprisingly naive statement by the main author, George Perry, that Davis successfully imitated Joan Crawford in telephone scenes in 'Baby Jane' when Crawford had in fact agreed to dub in her own voice while Davis 'lip-synched' her imitation (this information is covered in the 2 disc 'Baby Jane' dvds, and also, in my opinion, is fairly obvious).
Running Press, the publisher, also gave the public the very enjoyable oversized books about Lucille Ball ('Lucy At The Movies') and the excellent (and best of the three) Lana Turner book, 'Lana' The Memories, The Myths, The Movies' which greatly benefitted from having Cheryl Crane's insight and her dedication to having her mother's memory being preserved. The 3 very attractive-looking Running Press books all are worth buying, and are great conversation pieces for those interested in classic films and/or classic stars of an era long-gone.
Of the 2 authors of "Bette Davis: Larger Than Life", George Perry does the better job; Richard Schickel editorializes all over the place and some of his highly subjective observations just don't ring true, to this reader. As I read on, Schickel's opinions became irrelevant and tiresome. He writes from the perspective of his experience of enjoying the work of Davis as being of more import than the films or performances Davis gave in them.
The photos in the book are incredible, and the quality of paper used and photo resolution may make some fans want to buy two copies, one for the coffee-table, and the other for high-quality frameable rare photographs of the greatest film star of the 1940s.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
12 of 13 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
SOMEWHAT ENJOYABLE BUT NO GREAT SHAKES!!, December 29, 2009
This review is from: Bette Davis: Larger than Life (Hardcover)
By far the best thing about this book are the photographs. Although many of the pictures are the same as those seen through the years in other Bette Davis bios - there are a significant number I have not seen elsewhere before. Also, all the photographs are magnificently reproduced - crystal clear with great detail and depth.
The text of the book contains absolutely no new information (except for a few careless factual errors) regarding Ms. Davis' personal life, career or movies. However it is an enjoyable,
easy, quick read - a sort of "Cliff Notes" of Ms. Davis' life and movies.
Somewhat offensive is the author's (Schickel) need to rationalize his interest in Ms. Davis in the "Introduction" chapter - which he writes "doesn't make sense". He lets the reader know that his interests are strictly the "regular" man ones -- in movie genres (war, adventure) as well as in other hobbies (football, baseball, etc.). In the next few paragraphs he clumsily describes/apologizes what it could possibly be about Ms. Davis and her movies that would appeal to a person like him. It reminded me of when I was a teenager and a straight friend of mine embarassingly confided in me (and later denied to others) that he watched a movie musical on television the night before rather than an 'important' ball game. I guess some things never change!! Rest easy Mr. Schickel - you can feel free to enjoy Bette Davis without fearing people will think you are gay.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
8 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Poor Writing Wrecks Book, January 13, 2010
This review is from: Bette Davis: Larger than Life (Hardcover)
I really can't understand why this book was published. Its glorious, glossy cover and format leads one to believe that it will be a photo-heavy "movie star" tribute. Unfortunately, its author, George Perry (Richard Schickel wrote only the preface) doesn't seem to be any fan of Bette Davis, which would seem to be crucial to what presents itself as a tribute book. His writing is poor in the extreme; confusing, humorless, overweening, and sour. He seems to believe that being critical is the best way to display his superiority. I mean, do we really need to hear someone else complain that Bette Davis smoked? I literally slammed the book shut when Perry began complaining that George Brent's character in "The Great Lie," after having been lost in the jungle, didn't discuss his probate will when he returned (!). Mr. Perry, dear, it's the same reason we didn't see him go to the bathroom. We're talking about a MOVIE here. And Perry doesn't seem to like very many of Bette Davis'.
I hope Running Press continues this lavish series. The Lana Turner entry (penned by her daughter, Cheryl Crane) is absolutely terrific. And I'll probably buy the Lucille Ball book in the series. But this book, sadly, is a DUD, despite the fine photographs inside (few of which seem to be very rare) I can not recommend it.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|