21 of 22 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
MAGNUM OPUS!, April 11, 2002
By A Customer
Everyone who thinks cavers are crazy will be very happy to know that Jim
Borden and Roger Brucker prove it in their magnum opus BEYOND
MAMMOTH CAVE. In it Borden documents every complaint he ever had against
the elderly dictatorial rulers (I blush in embarrassed pride) of the Cave
Research Foundation and tells how he ran roughshod, young, and innocent
over the entire caving establishment to find a new cave--Roppel Cave--and
explore it. But then past-president of the Cave Research
Foundation and senior citizen Roger Brucker, exhibiting his wizardry in
conning deception, came slogging up a deep river in Mammoth Cave to make
THE BIG CONNECTION with Roppel Cave and thus incorporate Borden's baby into
the Mammoth Cave System. Borden squealed like a pig, but eventually made a
deal with Brucker, alienated half his friends in his rival organization, the
Central Kentucky Karst Coalition, and roared in from the Roppel side to
meet Brucker (they had their lieutenants with clubs along with them just in
case) and at the point of connection each held his nose with one hand and
shook the other's hand with his other hand, and then they roared on past
one another with the Roppel crowd exiting on the Mammoth side and the Mammoth
crowd exiting on the Roppel side (without guides) just to show the idiots
that they knew where the dreaded connection was all along.
Buy this great book. You won't be able to stop reading it once you
start, even if you want to (and many might).
Give this book to everyone who thinks people are idiots for going caving.
As I remark above, once they read it, no longer will they be in doubt.
Now if you really want to bomb people out, you should give them all three
volumes of the AMERICAN CLASSIC CAVE TRIOLOGY;
THE CAVES BEYOND by Joe Lawrence, Jr. & Roger W. Brucker
(St. Louis: Cave Books, 1975 in print), in which the
famous fruitless Floyd Collins' Crystal Cave Expedition
is documented. Sixty people spent a week underground
and discovered exactly 13 yards of new cave, but even
so, several of them got lost.
THE LONGEST CAVE by Roger W. Brucker and Richard A. Watson
(Carbondale: Southern Illinois University Press, 1987, in print)
in which strong men quail as wire muscled Patricia Crowther
squeezes through the Tight Spot to nail the connection of the
Flint Ridge Cave System to Mammoth Cave, and John Wilcox utters
those immortal words, "I see a tourist trail!"
BEYOND MAMMOTH CAVE by James D. Borden and Roger W. Brucker
(Carbondale: Southern Illinois University Press, 2000, in print).
Buy it now before the last remaining copies go to the shredders.
--Red Watson, past-president of the Cave Research Foundation
and co-author of THE LONGEST CAVE
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
11 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Hungry Soul, Weak Body, December 8, 2000
The book is a well-written page turner written in an informal and approachable style. The two authors, who experienced much of the story first-hand, achieve an exciting dynamic by alternating chapters back and forth; each chapter dealing with similar events and topics but from the distinct perspectives of the two authors. Some may criticize the opinionated tone, but I think few will disagree that it is poignant and clear. The book is important because it will have general appeal and edification to the caver populace, most of whom are recreational-cavers not involved in project-surveying. Hopefully it will create empathy and understanding of the project caver experience among the general caver community. Moreover the book may, as much as is tenable, make caving vicariously comprehensible to non-cavers. The authors have accurately portrayed the ingloriousness of caving and avoided romanticizing caving to noncavers. The book honestly portrays the frequently unbalanced mixture of hardships, and joys that go into long-term project caving: the personal conflicts, the bouts of frustration, the physical exhaustion, the incredible ego-inflation, the tedious agonizing work of surveying, the costs to other aspects of the caver's life, work, and relationships, and the occasional elation of an accomplishment. The book strikes a balance between humility and open-mindedness. There is recognition that project-caving, in the grand scheme of human-experience, is irrational and insignificant. At the same time, the book does not short-change the power of the personal experience of obsession with project-surveying, and the potential significance of this liminal experience as a study in the best and worst in human nature.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
12 of 13 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Too much Borden, Not enough Brucker, November 14, 2000
Having been a casual follower of the progress in the Flint Ridge/Mammoth Cave system since the late 70s, I was very eager to read this book. Not nearly enough information makes its way into mainstream publications to keep me happy. I am pleased to say that this book describes much of the work that has occurred since the big connection in 72. There is adventure and intrigue and the old Flint Ridge con on almost every page.
One thing that is lacking, however, is the sense of history that was so evident in The Longest Cave. Other than a few references, the great cavers of the 50s and 60s are pretty much ignored, as are their efforts. You are left with the impression, however accurate or inaccurate, that the CKKC cavers are much more interested in their own accomplishments and bravado. At times it appears that this personal grandeur is achieved at the expense of the cave system and caving in general.
As notable as the lack of historical perspective is the overabundance of James Borden. Although Borden and Brucker share authorship, the majority of the story reflects Borden and his ideas regarding caving. This is not such a bad thing from at least one perspective, as Borden can be a remarkable caver and storyteller. Unfortunately, we also get to witness his questionable personal behavior and caving ethics. Conspiracy and secrecy have always been a part of Kentucky caving, and no one should be surprised that these things continue. However, having to read over and again the manner in which Borden deceives, hurts, and steals from his "friends" and "heroes" makes one wonder why anyone still wants to go underground with this man.
Despite the weakness briefly presented above, I can recommend this book to all readers interested in Mammoth Cave. For the reader who is somewhat a novice to caving, I would add these comments:
1. Read The Longest Cave first. It is a wonderful book and will increase your appreciating of this book.
2. Avoid the impression that all cavers are reckless in their caving and share a fascination for dynamiting their way through a cave.
3. Do not believe that all, or even most, cavers share Borden's antisocial tendencies and self-serving rationalizations.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
