Customer Reviews

Beyond the Pale: The Jewish Encounter with Late Imperial Russia (Studies on the History of Society and Culture)

5 star:		(3)
4 star:		(1)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

This is a fascinating study of the Jews in Russia. The book description is accurate... it is a highly detailed and first rate work of scholarship. The only concern is that it is not casual reading-- it is an in-depth and comprehensive study that rewards the devoted reader.

Beyond the Pale: The Jewish Encounter with Late Imperial Russia won the 2003 Wayne S. Vucinich book prize awarded annually by the American Association for the Advancement of Slavic Studies (AAASS) for the most outstanding monograph in Russian, Eurasian, or East European studies in any discipline of the humanities.

The book prize selection committee wrote the following about this volume:

Benjamin Nathans' masterful study provides a fresh look at an age old problem, the entry and integration of Jews into larger territorial, cultural and political communities. The book takes us, literally and figuratively, "beyond the pale" of Jewish life in late imperial Russia to the encounter of Jewish professionals and intellectuals with Russian civil institutions.

Through exhaustive and innovative research, from newly available archives to private family memoirs, Nathans brings to life key personalities and social interactions that redefine the Jewish presence in St. Petersburg, and in turn reshape ties to the other subjects of the empire and to Russian Jewry. Through these vibrant portraits of the Jewish-Russian encounter, the author paints a much larger canvas tracing a cultural world of understandings and misconceptions, a social existence beset by advances and setbacks, and a political discourse of emancipation and reaction.

This exemplary, insightful book, argued with balance and nuance and written with flair, provides an original interpretation of a central problem in Russian history and politics. More, the intellectual journey goes well beyond Russia to recast our understanding of broader, ever-present issues of identity, integration, and conflict.

Russia came to the Jews; the Jews did not come to Russia. As the tsarist regime expanded westward, it annexed large portions of Poland between 1772 and 1795, inheriting approximately half a million Jews in the process. Divided into four parts, Nathans's book traces what he terms the selective integration into Russian society of colonized Jewish people from the Pale of Settlement in late imperial Russia. Focusing on a range of demographic, cultural, and political issues, Nathans analyzes the geographic and social mobility of the Jews during this period, and the impact they had on the transformation of Russian society in the modern age.

Part I frames the monograph by looking at the attempt to adapt European-style emancipation to a tsarist autocracy still emerging as a hierarchy of culturally and juridically distinct estates. As a result, a policy of what Nathans calls "selective integration" evolved where certain categories of "useful" Jews were granted rights and privileges similar to those enjoyed by their Gentile counterparts according to social estate, including the right to reside outside the Pale. Nathans situates the selective integration of the Jews in the context of Alexander II's Great Reforms. Part II examines the privileged Jews who, taking advantage of residential freedom offered by the policy of selective integration, moved to St. Petersburg, which became the largest and most prominent Jewish community in Russia, and the politics that arose within the Jewish community itself, as St. Petersburg's Jewish elite asserted a self-appointed leadership role over Russian Jewry as a whole.

The second half of the book looks at Jewish integration into two specific social institutions. Part III traces the experience of Jewish men and women who enrolled in Russia's institutions of higher education. Taking advantage of a decree in 1861 guaranteeing Jews with university degrees the right to live outside the Pale, Jews, with the aid of new forms of Jewish philanthropy, flocked to the universities in such disproportionate numbers to their Gentile counterparts that official quotas were enacted in 1887 to stem the tide. Nathans also examines the role Jewish students played in the failed 1905 Revolution. Part IV examines the Russian-Jewish encounter in terms of the newly reformed Russian court system. The Judicial Reform of 1864 created a modern judiciary, and is especially significant in that it broke with the tradition of officially sanctioned discrimination against the Jews. Barred from employment in academia and civil service, Jews flocked to the bar and became private practitioners. By the twenty-fifth anniversary of judicial reform, in 1889, Jews constituted 14% of the empire's certified lawyers and an astounding 43% of apprentice lawyers, the primary pool from which future lawyers would be drawn. Unwilling to tolerate the dominance of Jews in the legal profession, Tsar Alexander III enacted a so-called temporary degree (which remained in effect until the October Revolution-nothing was more permanent in late imperial Russia than a temporary decree) requiring the personal approval of the Minister of Justice for the admission of any non-Christian to the bar. The impact on the Jews of this decree was felt immediately. Half a century after the creation of an open, semi-independent legal system in Russia, Jews were completely barred from it. Interestingly, the impetus for state protection came not only from the state but also from within the ranks of the bar itself. Fear of competition was the clear motivation.

Nathans concludes this excellent piece of scholarship with a comparison of the policy of selective integration to the experience of Jews elsewhere in Europe and the experience of other Russian minorities within late imperial Russia. Although sharing many similarities with its Western European counterparts, the Russian-Jewish encounter was distinct in that it unfolded at a time when Russia's hereditary estates remained the predominant source of social identity and the means through which the tsarist regime sought to manage its residents. The tsarist autocracy attempted to use these estates as a conduit for Jewish integration, all but ensuring a stratifying effect on the Russian Jewish population as a whole, which in Nathans view prepared the ground for the significant role played by Jews in the Russian Revolution and development of Soviet society.

You should know that having been selected a Slavic Studies award it was not going to be all plot and laughs. Though if you read it with the right mindset, some of it looks like it was made-up by Myron Cohen. Probably the most interesting part of the scholarship brought up by Nathans was that once Russian Jews were allowed into law schools, they turned out to be recognized as the most expert in the law.

Anyone who has studied under a talmudic system will know that you must learn not only the law itself, but learn to read between the lines as to it's intent. Even the non-Jewish lawyers admitted that the Jewish lawyers were much more committed to their clients and their clients welfare. Many non-Jews hired Jews as apprentice lawyers because of their attention to detail.


From the American Association for the Advancement of Slavic Studies (AAASS) awards committee:

Benjamin Nathans' masterful study provides a fresh look at an age old problem, the entry and integration of Jews into larger territorial, cultural and political communities. The book takes us, literally and figuratively, "beyond the pale" of Jewish life in late imperial Russia to the encounter of Jewish professionals and intellectuals with Russian civil institutions.

Through exhaustive and innovative research, from newly available archives to private family memoirs, Nathans brings to life key personalities and social interactions that redefine the Jewish presence in St. Petersburg, and in turn reshape ties to the other subjects of the empire and to Russian Jewry. Through these vibrant portraits of the Jewish-Russian encounter, the author paints a much larger canvas tracing a cultural world of understandings and misconceptions, a social existence beset by advances and setbacks, and a political discourse of emancipation and reaction.