Most Helpful Customer Reviews
17 of 17 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Like an encylopedia, touches on interesting ideas, but..., October 2, 2001
This review is from: Beyond Prozac: Antidotes for Modern Times (Paperback)
Beyond Prozac was first published in 1995. In today's fast-moving world of psychopharmacology, one might think that would make Beyond Prozac completely outdated. Yet, in reading Norden's book, I did find some information related to depression that was new and interesting to me. For example, his discussion of the role of prostaglandins, essential fats, positive ions, and heat in creating depression/low serotonin levels I found informative. Norden also gave much interesting information on Seasonal Affective Disorder and light therapy, which I wasn't very familiar with (being a San Diegan) and is one of his specialties (being a Seattle-ite). That being said, I found a great deal of Beyond Prozac too general and not in depth enough. Most chapters are quite short (10 pages) and give an encyclopedic-like explanation of the various "Natural Prozacs," to use Norden's words. This encyclopedia-like approach was not really satisfying to me. The chapter on diet and depression is a good example of this general, encyclopedia approach: Norden discusses the benefits of a "Zone"-like diet (a/la Barry Sears) but only has a very brief three page list of randomly chosen foods to help you follow this diet. I guess you need to buy one of Barry Sears' Zone books if you want to follow such a diet. Likewise, in the antidepressant medication section, while Norden does cover all the SSRIs, SRIs, MAO inhibitors, and tricyclics, he gives most (except for Prozac) a page discussion at best. I felt that much of this information could have been gotten from reading the drug companies' description of the drug itself, I'm sorry to say. I would have liked to see Norden give a more critical analysis of each drug and its side effects, especially the newer SSRIs. And Norden doesn't really delve into many of the more effective alternative supplements, such as St. John's wort or SAM-e (which is understandable since Beyond Prozac was published in 1995, before these supplements flooded the US market). He does discuss tryptophan and 5-HTP though, but only briefly. All in all, as someone who has experimented a bit with antidepressant treatments for the past few years, I found this book to be somewhat, but not very informative. I guess it's a good introduction to psychopharmacological ways of dealing with depression if you haven't read anything else. But Beyond Prozac didn't really tell me much I hadn't heard before.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Being clinically depressed myself, this is wise reading., November 19, 1997
By A Customer
This review is from: Beyond Prozac: Antidotes for Modern Times (Paperback)
Well written for the laymen, the context of Dr. Norden's revised edition enlightened me in a technical and clinical way. Evey page held something of interest that pertained to me and my illness, and gives insight into causes, treatments, and cures. What few passages, written beyond my understanding (technical jargon), do not distract from the understanding of the principles and knowledge that he is presenting. If you are suffering this illness, as I am, you will find that he has written about you, your illness, and the cures for your illness. In addition, the appendixes and index allow me to frequently return to the book as a reference while continuing my research of my illness. Updated with the latest information on depression and detailed with many clinical study findings, "Beyond Prozac" is a must for my home library!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
12 of 14 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Eclectic, enthusiastic, exceptional!, February 19, 2000
This review is from: Beyond Prozac: Antidotes for Modern Times (Paperback)
I first read this book soon after my first book on depression came out in 1995. I was very impressed. Norden not only writes very well and accessibly (even when he gets into quite technical territories, which he digs into with obvious relish), but he very admirably combines the best traits one could hope for from a mainstream health professional and academic: disciplined review of the evidence and an exuberantly open mind. The result is a book that is much wider in scope than most books on depression (from pills to supplements, to diet, to exercise, and so on), especially for "its time" - just a couple years before the St. John's wort revolution, 5-HTP, and most recently SAM-e made it increasingly acceptable for "mainstream types" to write approvingly about these natural alternatives and adjuncts to antidepressant drugs. Although I've only browsed through this 1995 effort as a research source for my own writings since I first read it back then, I believe Beyond Prozac would still hold up very well among the more recent crops of books in the genre, which tend to be "skin deep" (chew them up, spit them out, and move on). It contains the kinds of unique and engaging ideas and insights that have a shelf life.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|