Most Helpful Customer Reviews
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Exemplary influences, wit and character, November 1, 1998
This review is from: Big Backyard Beat Show (Audio CD)
The best introduction to BR5-49 is their live show but this comes close. It's a good cross section of what to expect from the band with a contemporary take on classic 50s style that is joyful, witty and sometimes touching. The playing is excellent, from Chuck Mead's rockabilly guitar to Don Herron's authentic country sounds on fiddle, steel and more. The band are blessed with two distinctive singing/songwriting voices in Chuck Mead and Gary Bennett. It's no coincidence that Bennett takes "Hurtin' Song" (one of five covers). He has the crack in the voice that goes with heartbreak territory. His "Pain Pain Go Away" continues the theme while "Storybook Endings (If you stop believin')" , a beautiful teardrenched ballad, is the closest the band get to mainstream country. You can imagine someone else covering this. Elsewhere, it's hard to see the join between covers and originals. Bennett's fun swing number "You flew the coop" could be a sequel to "Ain't nobody here but us chickens". There is plenty of humour, with a link to tradition: the band walk the thin line between melodrama and black comedy that has always been there in country. Mead's accordian-driven "Goodbye, Maria" is tragedy with a laugh; his "My name is Mudd" comes with irony attached. It's not all country. In "Wild One" and "18 Wheels and a crowbar" they rock too. The band have an exemplary set of influences: what's more important they have the character to make them their own and the enthusiasm to infect any listener.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Sophomore isn't a slump..big improvement over debut, April 26, 2005
This review is from: Big Backyard Beat Show (Audio CD)
BR5-49 returns for their sophomore effort with more honky-tonk tradition, a sprinkling of rockabilly, and a Western swing number. Unlike Amazon's reviewer, I feel the originals from Gary Bennett and Chuck Mead (with an assist from Shaw Wilson on "18 Wheels...") are STRONGER this time out, making for a better CD than the debut.
HIGHLIGHTS:
A cover of Buck Owens' "There Goes my Love" gets things off to a good start. A cover of the Killer follows with "Wild One" and it's nice, though not as manic as Lewis himself. "Out of Habit", written by the band's Chuck Mead, toasts bar hopping. ("I can't be held responsible/it helps me unwind/She said it was another bad habit of mine") Gary Bennett's "Storybook Endings" is a wonderfully bittersweet portrayal of a divorcee determined to keep looking for 'happy ever after'. ("Storybook endings and white picket fences/Castles and tales where the prince finds the princess ain't real/if you stop believin'"). "18 Wheels and a Crowbar" is a trucker's fantasy revenge on cellphone totin' yuppie scum. Love and pain intertwine in Bennett's "You are Never Nice to Me" while accordion lends a Tejano flavor to Mead's "Goodbye, Maria". "Seven Nights to Rock" is solid rockabilly. "You Flew the Coop" is a novelty Western swing number.
LOWS:
"Pain, Pain Go Away" isn't awful but it's less compelling than most of the material here. "Georgia on a Fast Train" isn't bad, but Shaver's original is better. "change the Way I look" is somewhat tepid.
BOTTOM LINE:
14 cuts here...11 of them are at least good. This is where I'd start if you're trying to find out why people hype this band.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
If you're just gettin here..., October 29, 1999
By A Customer
This review is from: Big Backyard Beat Show (Audio CD)
...you've missed a lot. This is the best band in the world today. Anyone who has seen them live knows that Chuck Mead is probably one of the ten best guitarists in the world right now. He plays so effortlessly, though, you might miss it. Donnie Herron is an inspired musician, someone who has been blessed with amazing talent. Shaw and Jay are the best rhythm section since Watts and Wyman. Gary is just the ghost of every true honky tonk singer that has ever lived and died pouring his heart out. If you don't buy all three CD's right now, you'll be missing a great deal from your musical collection. If they come to your town, and you don't go see them, you will have missed a golden opportunity. I pray to God that they never break up.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|