Customer Reviews

Bilgewater

5 star:		(3)
4 star:		(1)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

Yes, this is one of the best & brainiest children's/young adult's books out there. The main characters are misfits stranded amongst "normality" in a boarding school... anyone who has been less than incredibly perfect and popular can relate to the heroine. Gardam has created very unusual, intelligent and deep characters... and she writes with compassion and skill. What begins as a story full of painful non-interaction and isolation moves toward riveting romance and self-discovery and bravery, unveiling the plot with an almost gothic mood. Complex, atmospheric, smart and strong; this is for mature young-readers and for adults who remember their own coming-of-age pangs. One of my most memorable surprise discoveries.

This is a a beautifully written, quiet and introspective novel. It is the first-person narrative of a homely and eccentric girl who, having grown up in a cloistered house on the grounds of the boys' school of which her father was headmaster, is preparing to leave for college. I often found myself either laughing or choking back tears as this bright and awkward introvert was forced by circumstance into awareness of the relationships around her. Though at times there seemed to be an awful lot of coincidence, I thought in the end that, given the insular quality of her social world, it all made psychological sense. As only happens in a good literary novel, the characters remained with me for days afterward - I thought about their quirks, qualities and failures as though they were people I knew.

This book was originally marketed as young adult fiction. For a bright adolescent, I think it would be a fantastic affirmation of individuality and an encouragement to take their interests seriously. As a widely-read 41 year-old man, however, I can vouch that it is richly rewarding for adults.

Note: I hate having to rate books with asterisks. I gave it 4 stars because it's not Moby Dick or Notes From The Underground, but it's an excellent novel, nonetheless.

This book is surely the ultimate tragic comedy. At the same time as teetering on the brink of despair, I was laughing raucously out loud (which, as an indication of Bilgewater's sheer funniness, I never do, so beware of reading this book in public places!). Bilgewater's character is a work of genius: ungainly, bookish and forlorn; insightful, intelligent and original. My favourite, favourite part is the crazy vision of Bilge climbing out of the Roses' window. If you are looking for something a bit weird, offbeat, or, in fact, just a brilliant book, I would strongly recommend this one. :o)

Has anyone else in the world read this book? I have read a lotof books, but this has to be one of my favourites. Poor Marigold (orBilge) is so ordinary it's painful. You can really relate to her. This book combines, ordinary (and somewhat monotonous) life, intrigue and romance (Terrapin & Jack- Lucky thing!) Love it! Read it NOW!