Customer Reviews

Billy Bragg & Wilco - Man in the Sand (The Making of "Mermaid Avenue")

5 star:		(0)
4 star:		(3)
3 star:		(3)
2 star:		(1)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

No doubt this disc is going to be positioned in the bins as a documentary on the making of the two Billy Bragg & Wilco "Mermaid Avenue" records. I think there's a bit more to it. In a grand sense, this is a road movie. We have a person on a quest (of sorts). Billy Bragg comes to the United States to get a handle/perspective on his project: The creation and recording of some new songs, built on 40+ year old lyrics from Woody Guthrie that have been barely seen and never heard.

"Man In The Sand" has a few rough spots. As Bragg does his "Driveabout" in OK and TX, it's both funny and tragic watching him behave like he's on safari in the 1890s, rather than traveling to a not so foreign country in the 1990s. While trying to pay respect to Guthrie, Bragg's cultural/class snobbery is both intact and palpable (along with the irony). The filmmakers get a pat on the back for showing that bit.

The filmmakers do get it wrong in places. Frankly, I could have done without Bragg's home life, and instead used the time for delving into three areas/topics. First, show more of the music making process. Second, more explanation of how and why Wilco and Natalie Merchant were brought into the project. Third, if you are going to introduce the idea of creative strife at all, lay it all out. Don't dance around it, then suggest the reason you're going low key is that you don't want to overshadow the music. All of this can be easily attributed to being a BBC production. Meaning, we don't know the original intent of the documentary. On the other hand, I've come to expect nothing but top drawer from the Beeb. "Man In The Sand" falls short.

But, we were talking about a road movie. A road movie needs the participants to be in love with something elusive, and this movie has got it to spare. It is so obvious that Bragg, Wilco, and Merchant are totally in love with making the music. It's also wonderful to watch Nora (Woody's daughter) fall in love with her father, despite all of his shortcomings, on a level that she never could if he were alive.

This movie is about the search in (of) making music, and, what everybody finds. Not only do we get a glimpse of where the muse led Guthrie yesterday, but we see several people courting the muse today. By the end of the movie, the context Bragg was searching for begins to sink in. Perhaps more important, we see it's because of Nora and her stories, not Bragg following his road map and waiting for lightning to strike.

The disc looks and sounds wonderful. The five extra tracks (Bragg's demos for "Birds And Ships," "She Came Along To See," "I Guess I Planted," "Eisler On The Go," and "The Unwelcome Guest.") are certainly worth a spin. Fans of Bragg's may wince a bit, and Wilco worshippers are going to feel cheated. Those interested in the process of making music, period, are going to be the ones who come out ahead.

This documentary resembles a crazy, patchwork quilt, thus, more so than usual, your reactions to it are likely to be shaped by what interests and expectations you bring with you. On the surface, it is a documentary on the making of the two `Mermaid Ave' albums - a project initiated by Nora Guthrie to resurrect a portion of the thousands of lyrics that her father, Woody, had left behind, sans music, and put them before the public. She asked Billy Bragg to take on the project because she felt that his passion and politics was a match to those of her late father. At some point, (left unexplained by the documentary) the band Wilco came into the project as collaborators with Bragg. The film, therefore, has an overabundance of strong characters, all with devoted followings, that it has to try to blend into the mix - Bragg, Wilco, and the ghost of Woody Guthrie as personified through his daughter.
Fans of Wilco are most likely to be disappointed with `Man in the Sand'. As already mentioned, it neglects even to mention how they came into the project, and Bragg gets much more screen time, even though the musical collaboration between them seems to have been fairly evenly split. Still, what we do see of them here shines, both in their studio work and their witty banter with Bragg in discussing the project. Bragg is covered more extensively, and he has an awkward charm that works well in the film, as the personal imperfections that it exposes give a great air of honesty and authenticy.
My primary interest in `Man in the Sand' was neither Billy Bragg nor Wilco, but rather Woody Guthrie and his music. Woody's ghost is the real star here. Throughout the film, Nora Guthrie tells the tales of Woody's life, both in conversations with Bragg, and directly to the microphone, as she explores the legacy of her famous father whom she knows more through his work and legend than she ever did from life. There is nothing new in these stories for most of Woody's fans, but the mix of pride, tenderness, and sorrow in Nora's evocative performance is so raw, honest, and touching as not to be missed. And the power of Woody's writing, to reach down through generations and inspire artists like Bragg and Wilco to create such powerful music in collaboration with his ghost is stunning, and a true tribute to the man.
`Man in the Sand' is an imperfect documentary, but still more than worth your time. Ultimately, it is both Nora Guthrie's evocation of her legendary father's ghost and the peek at the process of two strong willed collaborators with that ghost creating dynamic songs that speak across generations that make `Man in the Sand' worth a look. If that process interests you, then I recommend that you check it out.

Theo Logos

OK, perhaps the British have a hard time suppressing their contempt for Americans, but isn't it disingenuous to let it show through in a documentary centering around Woody Guthrie?

I enjoyed much of this documentary in spite of the limited talents of the filmmakers, as Mr. Bragg, Mr. Guthrie, and Wilco were all compelling enough to hold my attention.

But it is rather ignorant of the filmmakers to assume that those wishing to see such a document would have little to no interest in Wilco, who were more than minor participants in the project. Instead, they attempt to present typical British tabloid journalism, trying to recreate "Let It Be" by fomenting a minor dispute between the songwriters.

The best parts of this, for me, were the tidbits of Jeff Tweedy singing Guthrie's words, but they were scarce. The filmmakers never even said anything about how Wilco were brought into the project to begin with.

I am a long time fan of the band Uncle Tupelo which was fronted by Jeffy Tweedy (Wilco) and Jay Farrar (Son Volt, now doing ... solo material). That was my reason for initially watching this DVD as well as the fact that I happen to like Billy Bragg. If you are a fan of either one of them you'll love this DVD.... and unless you have no sense of the history of American music, you'll learn to appreciate Guthry as well. I particularly liked the on location stuff where they were hunting down Woody's past... a real slice of life. The most interesting part was Tweedy's personal digs on both Bragg and Farrar as collaborators..... seems there is not enough room for himself, his ego and another front man to be happily on stage at the same time....bottom line, great video.

Man in the Sand should sit beside The Last Waltz, Let it Be and Ladies and Gentlemen the Rolling Stones. Not Since Rattle and Hum has there been a movie that captures the true craftsmenship that Bragg and Wilco bring to this project. Bragg spoke: "I'm on a quest. I'm searching for the spirit of Woody Guthrie", and that's where they (Wilco/Bragg) take us. So sit back and enjoy two of todays gretest songwriters as they take us on a musical journy towards the spirt hope and love that was brought forth by non other then Woody Guthrie.

the premise of "man in the sand," namely the making of the two mermaid avenue sessions, could have been a really interesting rock documentary, like "gimme shelter," "don't look back," or "meeting people is easy," to name a few. what is great about this picture are the bits of rehearsals and footages of recording sessions. jeff tweedy of wilco is just breathtaking in these brief moments. but the attempt at fusing a documentary about woodie guthrie & the trials, tribulations, and inspirations of making the two stunning albums just doesn't work. i would have preferred a telling of woodie guthrie through these live recording and collaborative moments alone: to let the tremendous creative energy and the tensions that arose in the meeting of two great artists (wilco and billy) speak for woodie. there are many allusions here to the strife behind the scenes, of different views on what the big picture of woodie guthrie's music should be. this movie fails to articulate what these conflicts were. how did we get such gems through such an overwhelming process?

to end with some good observations: the performances here are tremendous and well worth keeping in your library if you are a fan of wilco or billy. again: jeff tweedy is breathtaking.

I've been a Billy Bragg fan since 1987 which was the first time that I heard "Back to Basics." I also like Wilco quite a bit and enjoyed the interplay of these musicians on the "Mermaid Avenue" CDs. That being said, seeing Billy close up and personal was a serious disappointment. Bragg's devotion to Woody Guthrie was certainly inspired by the man's music but it was also due to his politics, and his politics were as glossy and superficial as Billy's are today. It's what I would call "pseudo-intellect with soundbytes."

It is rather comical to hear Bragg rationalize Guthrie's irresponsibility and rampant womanizing through the selection of sympathetic and isolated lyrics suggesting that he was really all about equality and social justice. That's another strong thing about this documentary as it does not sugarcoat Woody Guthrie. It provides us with an unvarnished depiction of his life; a life that is far less appealing when seen under the microscope. Jeff Tweedy, of Wilco, has a great line about Bragg in the film. He says something to the effect of, "I think if Woody were here, he would have wanted us to record the best songs and not have worried about the message." Quite right.

The use of Guthrie's daughter as narrator was foolish. She does not appear to be "all there" and most of her speech is drenched in cliches [example: "dad's life was spinning out of control"]. She's a bit of a freak and it have been best to cut her from many of the sequences I think.

The documentary really is a wonderful gaze at what some of our favorite performers are really like in person. Natalie Merchant comes off as being eccentric to say the least. She also will not be appearing in any glamour exposes anytime soon. What was most valuable about this film are its recording room sequences where it is difficult not to recognize how gifted these musicians are. They took verse and added beautiful rythym to it, just as was done with Van Morrison's "Astral Weeks." This is an enjoyable film but filled with flawed characters and perceptions.