Most Helpful Customer Reviews
306 of 325 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Guess work-not science !, October 28, 2009
This review is from: BioPet DNA Breed Identification Kit (Misc.)
I have been rescueing pit bulls for about 20 years,and have been selling diagnostics(Lab equipment)for about the same time.Recently I purchased 4 of these so called breed tests from BioPet Vet Lab.There data base is only for AKC breeds,and pitbulls are not recognized by the AKC,I expected no match to be found.With the assistance of my DVM,we ran a test on a confiscated fighting dog I named "SweetPea", she is great with humans ,but like most pits she is very dog agressive,and after dealing with this breed for 20 years I assure you there is NO AKC blood here !Imagine my surprise that not only did we get back results ,but that this dog has 7 AKC breeds in it.I showed the results to my vet,which said she is a mix of Yorkshire terrier,border collie,and saint bernard to name a few.He laughed and asked if I wanted to do a little experiment,which was to run the same dogs DNA with a different name,with my vet as the owner so BioPet would not know what we were doing.The results for "doe5557"aka "sweetPea" came back as a different mix of AKC blood,this time instead of Rottweiler being in the mix,Rhodesian Ridgeback was in there, and the various levels of how much of each breed was also different.In lab speak testing accurracy is based on reproducability, with PCR (the technology used here)there is to much variability to be precise enough to tell what is in your dog! The first test result was flawed,and even though it was wrong the results of the second test should have been the same as the first.When "sweetPea" was confiscated from a local fighting ring she was pregnant,and had 8 beautiful pitbull puppies,one of which I decided should stay with us,I named him "Bubba",who with my DVM's help we decided to test.His test came up with another AKC mix,with 7 breeds that they DON'T share,when I showed the results to my vet He said; A)this was genetically impossible B)get your money back !Even though they say complete satisfaction or you can retest on them or get your money back,after 3 requests,I'm not holding my breath. My advice is to save the $60.00 and go get you dog a bunch of treats and toys!The technology they are using is outdated and Humans convicted of crimes using this type of testing have been overturned , unfortunatly there are no regulations on the claims they are making for this test as it is animal testing,not human.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
60 of 64 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Get the blood test, March 7, 2009
This review is from: BioPet DNA Breed Identification Kit (Misc.)
We rescued a puppy from NSAL in long island NY in 10/08. She was supposedly a border collie mix. As she was growing larger than a border collie we new something wasn't right. we tested with biopet and she was classified as a chow, beagle, daschund & poodle mix. this made no sense to us as we couldn't match any of her physical characteristics to these breeds. Then we took her to the vets for a $200 blood dna test. Turns out our puppy is a chow, golden retriever & siberian husky mix. This combo explained everything about her looks and personality. Of course, we love her no matter what she is .....my advice? save the $50 and apply it to the $200....
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
35 of 36 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
The results were preposterous, February 18, 2010
This review is from: BioPet DNA Breed Identification Kit (Misc.)
I gave one of these to my wife as a gift, and she sent in a sample from our rescue dog. This dog has the body of a Doberman - deep chested, sleek, muscular, standing about 27" at the wither. His head is shaped more like that of a Shepherd. He is jet black.
My wife, who teaches biology and studies genetics for fun, actually burst into laughter when she read the results of the test. Our dog was analyzed as being a mix of 5 miniature breeds (fluffy lap dogs) with some Chow thrown in. No matter how you look at it, the results were preposterous.
We understand that mix-ups sometimes happen, and attempted to contact the supplier several times. A re-test would have been a reasonable restitution, but the manufacturer never responded in any way, shape, or form. Pretty poor.
This test seems to be a hit or miss proposition. Based on our experience, I suspect that sloppy handling in the lab may be a major factor. Perhaps the kit should include two test swabs, to be analyzed separately.
I regret making this purchase, though if money were no object, I'd be tempted to test the same dog again just for the entertainment value of reading the results...
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|