Customer Reviews

Biograph Shorts: Griffith Masterworks

5 star:		(6)
4 star:		(1)
3 star:		(2)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

This excellent KINO double-DVD Special Edition from the "Griffith Masterworks" series is, in my opinion, as entertaining to watch as any later feature-length Griffith films, and not merely an historic account of cinema's development. No doubt these 23 short films - most of them being around 15 minutes, some 30 minutes long - are invaluable in showing the pioneering spirit of DW Griffith in the early years of cinema (1909-1913) and even someone without a professional interest or knowledge of cinema's history (like me) can already see that these Shorts are a cut above the rest, and that Griffith was ahead of his time.

Apart from the technical aspects, the real highlight for me, and perhaps for most general viewers, is the variety of stories presented here. They are like good quality short stories, and as with written stories, the next most important thing after having a good plot is the way the story is told, and this is where Griffith excelled. Some of the Shorts on these discs are based on stories by Poe, Tennyson and others, as well as contemporary film writers like Anita Loos. There are some heavy subjects which make a 'social comment', which Griffith often liked to make, then some real tear-jerkers, some suspense and action, a few Westerns and other general ones to balance things out. Each Short deserves proper attention, but each is rewarding in the way it is presented. It's also interesting to see early work by the regular Biograph - and later the Griffith - cast such as Blanche Sweet, Lionel Barrymore and of course, Mary Pickford and Lillian Gish, who went on to become big stars in their own right.

Almost all Shorts have perfect picture quality, and the one that hasn't ("The Adventures of Dollie") has an explanation from KINO explaining that it is included for its historic significance, namely Griffith's directorial debut, which is so good that you can easily forgive the somewhat washed-out picture. Musical scores are also of highest standard and match each film perfectly, being arranged by Robert Israel. Far more than just history for the film student, then: more like an excellent collection of short stories to which you keep wanting to go back.

This is a review of a DVD titled D.W.GRIFFITH'S BIOGRAPH SHORT MASTERWORKS which was put out by
Kino video in 2002. The is a two disc set consisting of 23 short films made for the
Biograph Company and all but one released before the seminal feature film, THE BIRTH OF A NATION in 1915.

From 1908 until THE BIRTH OF THE NATION in 1915, D.W. Griffith filmed close to five hundred short films. This release by Kino consists of a very few of the highlights of D.W. Griffith's early output.


On Disc One:

THOSE AWFUL HATS, 1909 (3 min). Very funny comedy short with quite an ending about the common problem of bountifully behatted women blocking the vision of fellow nickleodeon patrons.
With Mack Sennett and Flora Finch.

THE SEALED ROOM,1909 (11 min). From a story by Poe about a King who builds a special room for himself and his consort. She uses the room as a love nest for herself and a minstrel until
the King comes up with an airtight solution. With Arthur V. Johnson, Marion Leonard, Henry B.
Walthall and in small parts, Mack Sennet and Mary Pickford.

CORNER IN WHEAT, 1909 (14 min). From Frank Norris's novel "The Pit." A greedy tycoon corners the market in wheat thereby doubling the price of bread and doubling the hardship on the
populace. Griffith shows the contrast between the lives of the rich and poor with innovative
intercutting between the two story narratives. With Frank Powell, Grace Henderson, James
Kirkwood, Linda Avidson and in small roles Mack Sennett and Blanche Sweet.

THE UNCHANGING SEA, 1910 (13 min). A young couple's lives are changed by the sea when the
newlywed husband is thought lost at sea. The consequences and the couple's fate are told
in a beautiful and visually poetic manner in this tragic tale inspired by Charles Kinglesy's poem.
With Arthur V. Johnson, Linda Avidson, Mary Pickford, Charles West, Dell Henderson, Gladys Egan.

HIS TRUST, 1911 (14 min). When a southern plantation owner is called to war it's up to his faithful slave, George, to save his wife and child in the devestation of the Civil War. With Wilfred Lucas, Dell Henderson, Claire Mcdowell, Edith Haldeman.

THE NEW YORK HAT, 1912 (16 mn). In this story by Anita Loos, a teenage girl whose mother had just died receives a fancy gift from her pastor, a very stylish New York hat which she has been admiring in a shop window. Little does she know that it was bought with money her late mother gave the pastor nor does she realize the firestorm of gossip and ill will she faces from the local busybodies. With Mary Pickford. Lionel Barrymore, Charles Hill Mailes, Kate Bruce, Mae Marsh, Lillian Gish.

AN UNSEEN ENEMY, 1912 (15 min). Two recently orphaned sisters face danger when the house is burglarized and their inheritance is about to be stolen. With Lillian and Dorothy Gish, Elmer
Booth, Robert Herron, Harry Carey.

THE MOTHERING HEART, 1913 (23 min). A struggling young man climgs the ladder of suces with the
unstinting support of his wife. When the husband goes for another woman, the wife quietly moves back to her mothers home to have their baby. Eventually the husband gets his come uppance from the worldly woman and crawls back to his family. With Walter Miller, Dorothy Gish, Kate Bruce, Viola Berry, Charles West.

THE ADVENTURES OF DOLLIE, 1908 (12 min). A mother and father take their young daughter Dollie out for a day of fun and relaxation when they run into a couple of dangerous gypsies. This is
the first film directed by D.W. Griffith and already some of his trademark characteristics
are present. With Arthur V. Johnson, Linda Avidson, Gladys Egan, Charles Insley, Madeliene West.

THE USURER,1910 (18 min). A wealthy moneylender clamps down on his debtors and decides to collect all that is owed him just to enhance his bottom line. With Mack Sennett, George Nichols, Grace
Henderson, Edward Dillon, Mary Pickford.

ENOCH ARDEN, 1915 (35 min). dby Christy Cabanne, written by Griffith. A seaman, after a long period marooned on a desert island, returns home only to find his wife has remarried. A terrific movie. With Alfred Paget, Lillian Gish, Wallace Reid,

THE MISER'S HEART, 1911 (16 MIN). A miser at first refuses to open his safe to theives until they threaten the life of a little neighbor girl. With Linda Avidson, Lionel Barrymore, William J. Butler, Donald Crisp, Edward Dillon.


DISC TWO HAS:

THE MUSKETEERS OF PIG ALLEY, 1912 (18 min). A couple living in an NYC tenement becoome involved with a gang led by "The Snapper Kid," and in the gang war that follows. Fascinating early gangster film starring a Cagney- like Booth With Elmer Booth, Lillian Gish, Clara T. Bracy, walter Miller, alfred Paget, Harry Carey.

THE BURGLAR'S DILEMMA, 1912 (15 min). A young burglar takes the fall for a domestic murder commited
by a jealous brother. With Lioonel Barymore, Henry B. Walthall, Adolph Lestina, Harry Carey, The Gish Sisters.

THE SUNBEAM, 1912 (15 min). A bachelor and spinster live their lonely lives across the
boardinghouse hall from each other when a bright little neighbor girl helps them defrost their
cool relationship. With Ynez Seabury, Kate Bruce, Claire McDowell, Dell Henderson, Cristy Cabanne.

THE PAINTED LADY, 1912 (12 min). A lonely young woman strikes up a friendship with a young man, who she finds one night burglarizing her father's office in their home. With Blanche Sweet, Madge Kirby, Charles Hill Mailes, Kate Bruce, Joesph Graybill, Lionel Barrymore, Elmer Booth.

ONE IS BUSINESS, THE OTHER CRIME, 1912 (15 min). Griffith intercuts the stories of two couples to illustrate that each one, rich or poor, has their temptations and downfalls. With Charles West, Dorothy Barnard, Edwin August, Blanche Sweet, Frank Evans.

DEATH'S MARATHON, 1913 (15 min) A woman being courted by two business partners marries (unbeknownst to her) the irresponsible one who squanders the company money on gambling. When he decides to end it all with suicide she sends the responsible partner to try and save him before he pulls the trigger. With Blanche Sweet, Henry B. Walthal, Walter Miller, Lionel Barrymore, Kate Bruce.

THE BATTLE OF ELDERBUSH GULCH, 1913 (29 min). Drunken Indians disturb the peace of a nearby white settelement while searching for dogs to eat. The settlers shoot back, thereby touching off an
embittered war. With Mae Marsh, Leslie Loveridge, Alfred Paget,Robert Heron, Lillian Gish.

THE LAST DROP OF WATER, 1911 (13 min). A western bound wagon train is attacked by Indians and runs out of water. The settlers' fate rests on one man who goes for water. with Blanche Sweet, Robert Harron, Robert West, Dell Henderson., Alfred Paget, W.Chrystie Miller.

FRIENDS, 1912 (13 min). Dandy Jack is a miner who decides that it's time to move to a new claim but he also decides to leave his girlfriend, Dora, behind. Later, a new miner begins to date Dora but she never forgets Dandy Jack. With Mary Pickford, Henry B. Walthall, Lionel Barrymore, Harry Carey, Charles Hill Mailes, Elmer Booth.

THE LESSER EVIL, 1912 (13 min). A young woman stumbles across a boat crew who are smugglers and
they decide to kidnap her. She fights the crew who want to assault her all before
the local fisherman can come to her aid. With Blanche Sweet, Edwin August, Mae Marsh, Alfred Paget.

THE MASSACRE, 1912 (30 min). A romance with the backdrop of the Indian wars. The cavalry brutally attacks an Indian village and the Indians retaliate with a bloody raid on a wagon train. With Wilfred Lucas, Blanche Sweet, Charles West,
Alfred Paget, Lionel Barrymore.


All of these short films have the appropriate musical accompanyment and all of the films are in
top condition. If only other companies marketing older films could issue this kind of quality product there would be very little complaining among silent film buffs. Kudos to Kino.

I rate this two disc , 23 film package D.W. GRIFFITH'S BIOGRAPH SHORT MASTERWORKS an enthusiastic five stars, with pleasure.

I have numerous issues with D.W. Griffith and so was prepared to have less than an enthusiastic reaction to this set, but I ended up really really liking it. A lot of the issues I have with most of his features were either not present or less overwhelming in these shorts. It also helped that I love films from this early period of the cinema, when all movies were shorts and constantly evolving as an artform. So much happens in these short films (the longest only about a half-hour), packing so much plot into such a limited timeframe. And films from this early era seem to have such a natural charm and magic to them, evoking a long-gone era. There were only a couple of shorts that I didn't really care for (foremost among them the ridiculous 'His Trust,' although at least the racism in it is more of a paternalistic nature instead of the type of racism in BOAN).

The shorts cover such a wide variety of genres, such as Westerns, social justice issues (esp. how the other half lives and how they're treated and exploited by the ruling class), adaptations of poems and plays, crime drama, and melodrama. I definitely prefer Griffith's early shorts over his later grandiose overwrought morality plays. He almost seems like an entirely different director. Perhaps the short form was just more effective for delivering his messages without overdoing it, whereas in his features it often seems like the viewer is getting hit over the head with a preachy moral message and cloying sentimentality. These shorts are also a priceless look at some of the early work of big-name stars like Mary Pickford, Lillian and Dorothy Gish, and Lionel Barrymore, as well as actors in Griffith's stock company who are now largely forgotten by all but silent film buffs, such as Bobby Harron, Blanche Sweet, Henry B. Walthall, and Mae Marsh. Biograph had a lot of really talented people working for it.

I'd definitely recommend this set to anyone interested in American film shorts from the late Aughts and early Teens. They present such a vivid multifaceted picture of not only what the fledgling film industry was like but also what life was like for many people. The only thing that would have made this set even more enjoyable would have been some bonus material, such as background information on Biograph and the people involved with it, commentaries on some of the more interesting shorts, or an introductory overview.

I enjoyed this dvd very much. It is a very high quality compilation of some of Griffith's splendid short films for the Biograph company. I am a Griffith fan and the print qualities on these shorts is very good for the most part. The films are pre 1915 so that means most of them are single reel. There are a couple double reelers (and maybe three, although I don't think so) which run up to about a half an hour.

The subjects run the entire gambit. Many of them are moralistic. "One business the other crime" is about a starving man who steals from a rich "honorable" guy who has just taken a bribe. Another "the painted lady" is about the bad effect of women wearing makeup has on society. Still others are about war bravery and courage (or lack thereof). The dvd includes a very early gangster movie (some credit it with being the first) called "Musketeers of Pig Alley." Lillian Gish and Elmer Booth star. There are even some nice seaside action movies like "The Lesser Evil."

Well know (for the time!) and lesser known actors and actresses are in these movies. The etheareal Lillian Gish and her shorter sister Dorothy are in a couple. Donal Crisp and Lionel Barrymore are in a bunch. Mary Pickford is featured in a couple as well, including the tearjerker "The New York hat," which is still my favorite Pickford movie, even though its a short. Her mother's dying wish, given to the local pastor, is to guy something nice for her daughter (Pickford) as her husband was always a pennypincher and never allowed her to get anything for her. The story is about the evils of gossip, as Lillian Gish and Mae Marsh can be seen as some of the biddies who gossip when the pastor inexplicably gives Mary a beautiful new hat from new York that she had wanted. Eventually things get back to the father who in a fit of "grouchy old man" rage; tears up the hat in front of Mary who is left with palms open and a trembling lip. Is all made right in the end? Well you gotta see it.

In addition, my favorite silent film actress, Blanche Sweet is featured in many of these films. She was quite famous in her day, although not many today have heard of her. Dubbed "The Biograph Blonde" for her viking blond hair, she was a very natural sensitive actress who is always a joy to watch. Edwin August is also a very good actor, although not as well known as Sweet was, who is almost COMPLETELY forgotten today. He features prominantly in "One Business the other Crime" (as the rich guy) with Sweet and Charles West (as the poor guy) and also in "The Lesser Evil", again along the side of Sweet. The other actor who is generally a joy to watch is Henry Walthall. He features prominantly in "Death's Marathon" a story about a couple who get married, but the husband gets bored with her and turns to gambling, loses some company money, and then thinks about suicide. Does Blanche Sweet save him? You have to see.

The scoring is wonderful. At times it is so beautiful that you wonder what's the use of modern sound movies, when these silents are so beautiful alone with the music scores. They are delightfully varied, as well; with strings in some movies and piano in others, etc.

The only problem I had with this dvd was that the beautiful introductory menus to each film often had the wrong actors and actresses mentioned. This is especially annoying if you want to watch a particular movie for the actors/tresses in them. Of particular annoying note is Musketeers of Pig Alley, which loudly proclaims Dorothy Gish and Elmer Booth as being the leads. It wasn't Dorothy at all (although she can be seen as one of the extras on the street) but her sister Lillian who played "The little lady." Cute names Griffith thought up, eh? :) This was not isolated either. Many of the other movies had these errors in the menu titles.

One other thing is that some of the menus (especially the first main one) takes forever to go to the next after you click on an option. Same beef I had with the LOTR sets. You'd click on an option and after 10 seconds of useless animation and CGI you'd finally get to the next screen. This is subjective, so I'm not angry at all. Its just something I wanted to mention.

All in all, this is a wonderful set. 2 dvds packed with great Griffith shorts. They include his first short as director (Adventures of Dollie) and reach til the near end of his short days when he was doing double reelers (The Massacre, which is an indirect paraphrase of Custer's last stand through the eyes of innocent bystanders and one scout). Enjoy; it is worth the money.

It's no secret that DW Griffith was a pioneer who discovered the power the new medium had in story telling, and invented the basic techniques used by all who came after him. In a year's time we see the rapid transformation from "The Sealed Room", basically a filmed stage scene, through the less stagebound "Corner in Wheat" and finally the outdoor and boundless "Unchanging Sea". Griffith had quickly mastered this new craft, which then allowed him to loose his imagination for his flickered tales. These things are now nearly a century old, and there's no guarantee that you're going to find six hours of the stuff as easy- going entertainment. He's damn good though, and his tendency towards emotional manipulation seems much more appropriate in some of these shorts, than when he builds it over a couple of hours in his undeniably brilliant features that followed. Anyway, if you're a student, you've got an excuse to treat yourself.

(At least some of them!) As we are informed, DW Griffith was an actor in early films then with The Adventures of Dollie, became quite a prolific director, averaging 2-3 shorts per week. The films are quite good and quite interesting. As we know from DW Griffith, his films have a high moral tone to them and are almost exclusively about good vs. evil. Many have high adventures such as Dollie getting trapped in a barrel and surviving going over some waterfalls or an attack by Indians in the Battle of Elderbush Gulch. All that practice must have inspired DW Griffith to try the first American feature film over an hour, A Birth of a Nation based on The Klansman. The movies here are well restored and extreme care was taken in putting this contemplation together. I really enjoyed the musical scores. I have stereo speakers above my TV and the music is just beautiful and perfect for the films presented. Very nice.

The Griffith Biograph shorts have long been written about as the touchstone body of work that saw the development of cinema from an early sideshow novelty to an art form in its own right. This DVD set from Kino (also included as part of the "Griffith Masterworks" set) is a great way to see about 25 of these landmark films from director D.W. Griffith.

I give the set four stars only because I would like to have seen more included. We do have Griffith's first film here, presented as an extra feature (since the print quality is below the standards of Kino's usual presentation). Such seminal works as "A Corner in Wheat", "An Unseen Enemy", "Musketeers of Pig Alley" and "Battle of Elderbrush Gulch" are included.

The print quality is excellent throughout, as are the musical scores. David Shepard deserves much credit for issuing these splendid editions of these truly important works. For viewers unfamiliar with these films, it would probably be a good idea to familiarize yourself with some of the historical background to fully appreciate what Griffith was up to here, as the set contains no commentaries or other documentary materials.

I've only had a chance to watch of few of the shorts in this set. What I've watched has been enjoyable (though, contrary to what another reviewer wrote, picture quality isn't always pristine.

The main reason for the 3 star rating is that, while the films are great, there isn't anything else. The 'extras' on the discs are simply some additional shorts. There is no background information; no enclosed pamphlets, no introductions or special features on the discs themselves. I might have liked to have learned more about Griffith, about Biograph, and about the shorts.

Most of the films such as "Those Awful Hats" look more like practice films. They each tell a quick story but show none of the brilliance associated with his epics.

They are worth watching just to be aware of them. However they are not worth a second viewing. Because the films speak for their selves there really is not need for DVD extras. Yet the extras may have pointed out what the why these short stories are significant.

Disc One:
Those Awful Hats, 1909 (3 min)
The Sealed Room, 1909 (11 min)
Corner in Wheat, 1909 (14 min)
The Unchanging Sea, 1910 (13 min)
The New York Hat, 1912 (16 min)
An Unseen Enemy, 1912 (15 min)
The Mothering Heart, 1913 (23 min)
The Adventures of Dollie, 1908 (12 min)
The Usurer, 1910 (18 min)
Enoch Arden, 1915 (35 min)
The Miser's Heart, 1911 (16 MIN)

Disc Two:
The Musketeers of Pig Alley, 1912 (18 min)
The Burglar's Dilemma, 1912 (15 min)
The Sunbeam, 1912 (15 min)
The Painted Lady, 1912 (12 min)
One is Business, The Other Crime, 1912 (15 min)
Death's Marathon, 1913 (15 min)
The Battle of Elderbush Gulch, 1913 (29 min)
The Last Drop of Water, 1911 (13 min)
Friends, 1912 (13 min)
The Lesser Evil, 1912 (13 min)
The Massacre, 1912 (30 min)

D.W. Griffith - Years of Discovery 1909-1913