From School Library Journal
Grade 1-2-This book is more of an esteem-booster and a nudge of encouragement for self-expression than a strong story. Natalie loves writing poems but is nervous about sharing them out loud. When she attends a reading with her poetry teacher, she listens to the adults who are gathered there and is given the opportunity to take the spotlight. But stage fright overcomes her, and her words remain unspoken. Feeling sad on the bus ride home, she is inspired by the view from the window and, finding her voice at last, she begins to recite her poem out loud. The adult poets are among the passengers, and they offer rousing applause. The scant story ends with Natalie's affirmation, "I am a poet, too!" The subdued gouache art captures the child's changing feelings; the stylized characters are all people of color and several scenes are reminiscent of the beat generation of the '50s. The print is bold and dark against the soft pictures, and Natalie's poem is scattered across the illustrations. One of the wise poets at the reading had predicted "When the time is right, the bird begins to sing," and the delicately colored birds that grace several of the pages carry that metaphor throughout the book. Teachers may find this a helpful introduction to creative writing. A supplemental purchase.
Beth Tegart, Oneida City Schools, NYCopyright 2003 Reed Business Information, Inc.
Gr. 1-3. Natalie is a natural poet, but when she's asked to read her poetry out loud, she's as silent as a cloud. Natalie's teacher Monica tries to encourage her by taking her downtown to a poetry reading. Gunther reads his poems with a booming voice; Katerina, with a little squeak; and Edgar dances his words. When it's Natalie's turn, however, she freezes yet again: "And suddenly I feel like a bird / who's lost its voice, and like a bird / I wish to fly far, far away / to the top of the tallest tree." Despite her stage fright, the poets are kind to her. One of them tells her, "When the time is right, / the bird begins to sing." And sing she does, on the bus back home--reading her poem to Monica and to everyone else! The surreal, stylized paintings of a fascinating cast of multicultural characters are awash in lovely, warm color. Shy birds and budding poets alike may be emboldened by this picture book about both the private and public nature of creativity.
Karin SnelsonCopyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved