110 of 110 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The BEST Guide for Learning Bird Calls!, June 7, 2005
I spend alot of time outdoors and have always been curious about identifying birds, trees and wildflowers around me. This set of CDs is the second set of bird calls I have purchased (and this does not even include all the on-line browsing and listening at the USGS Patuxent site). I have had a lot of difficulty with single bird/associated song or call types of audio (ie. name of bird-recording of call, next bird...). There are a lot of birds out there, and it is tough memory recall when you have a CD of 200 some bird calls and it is basically rote memorization to try to remember them. Not a whole lot of fun if you are a relative amateur and trying to learn to identify birds by call confidently. Those CDs will probably be useful for reference at a later time, but not now.
I then picked up the Learning By Ear CDs. Wow! This is what I should have bought a long time ago. There are 85 birds included on these 3 CDs, but they are grouped in a very intelligent fashion. Instead of just rote memorization, the birds are grouped by category. There is a really nice introduction on the first CD and then birds are presented BY GROUP (ie. Sing-Songers, Chippers and Trillers, Name-Sayers...). I cannot emphasize enough how useful this approach is to learning. Instead of just giving the sounds of, say, a Downy Woodpeckers, the CD pairs similar sounding woodpeckers so you learn that a Downy has a descending whinny and a Hairy Woodpecker has an even sounding rattle - they are compared and contrasted together it is very effective. I learned more listening to these CDs than I ever learned through rote memorization. All three CDs contain bird groupings and the last CD also includes groupings by HABITAT as well: Forest Edges, Forest Interiors, Throughout, Freshwater Wetlands, Southern Forests, Northern Forests, Hedgerows and Thickets, Old Field and Open Fields, Oak-Pine Woodlands, and Urban Parks. The informational booklet included with the CDs is also quite nice and includes summaries of the information presented on the CD along with information found in standard birding books. All together, it makes a nice, complete set if you are just starting out or want to improve your identifying skills.
To summarize, if you are interested in learning to identify birds based on their songs and calls, ignore all the other CDs out there and just pick this set up. Once you become confident and learn from these CDs, you will be better able to evaluate if you need to buy anything else. Don't forget also that these things take effort. You cannot just pop the discs in and expect to become an expert overnight. I listen on my commutes to and from work, take a lot of walks in the woods, and learn a group at a time.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
70 of 70 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Repetition & field work are the key to this CD., July 29, 2002
When I first received this CD I was disappointed & overwhelmed. I thought, how could I possibly learn any of these bird calls (I'm 50 years old). It seemed like a monumental task. Well, I kept listening over and over (thinking the mnemonics were silly) and low and behold things started to click. I made a few forays into the field and was very excited when I heard bird calls and the mnemonics made sense. I still get excited when I'm able to identify a bird by song or call. I even find myself doing it on TV commercials. This CD isn't any good if you don't include field work with it. Practice, practice, practice and one day you will be out in the field and hear a bird and know exactly what you are looking for. This CD has made me a much better birder.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
60 of 61 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Great work out CD, September 3, 2003
I listen to these CDs while working out at the gym and boy did it pay off. While on vacation last summer in Vermont I could identify almost every bird call I heard without even trying. My ears would prick up at every sound of a bird and I would know what it was. It's a great feeling to take a walk in the woods or to garden in your back yard and know who is out there with you without fumbling with your binoculars. These are excellent CDs.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
![[Start the discussion]](http://g-ecx.images-amazon.com/images/G/01/x-locale/communities/discussion_boards/start-new-discussion-sec._V192250339_.gif){kind=small}
