Most Helpful Customer Reviews
9 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
There is no escape..., December 26, 2007
"Every time I try to get out, they suck me back in"----paraphrase of Al Pacino's lament in "Godfather" part three about attempts to take the family mob racket into legitimate businesses. I have been reading Fr. Greeley's books for about thirty years, with quite a bit of enjoyment. His novels, however, do fall into certain formulas, and he is so prolific I do get a bit tired every now and then. Just how many affluent, talented but dysfunctional Chicago Irish families will have locked room murders or attempted ones in any given decade? Especially if the family is connected in some manner to Fr. Blackie, the assistant to the Cardinal in charge in the Windy City? I try to quit Greeley, with varying degrees of success. For instance, I have totally avoided the seven novel series about the O'Malley family in the 20th century. But I have read every Blackie Ryan mystery, six or more now, every Nuala McGrail book, ten of those, and at least ten of his other works, fiction and non-fiction. Fr. Greeley's plots are often unrealistic, his characters' dialogue and emotions either idealized or demonized to a fault, his happy endings welcome but predictable. Still, he creates a world of families with as much to be envied as to be lamented. His heroes and heroines are people you wish you knew, and for whom you root without reservation. In this latest Blackie mystery, to my surprise, I really was not certain of the villain until the end. Therefore, it counts as quite a success. I found it a slow start, and after a chapter or two I was not sure I would finish it. Then, however, some twists occurred and I became reluctant to put the book down at all. If you like Greeley's past work, this is more of the same but well-done.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
I've long been a fan of Fr. Greeley's novels . . ., July 17, 2009
This review is from: The Bishop at the Lake: A Bishop Blackie Ryan Novel (Blackie Ryan Novels) (Mass Market Paperback)
. . . even when I find myself profoundly out of sympathy with some of his views. This is the first "Blackie Ryan" novel I've read in awhile (though I really enjoyed many of his "Beatitude" novels) and I wanted to enjoy it. I really did. And it was okay, but in the opinion of this reviewer, nothing particularly special. We have a (predictable) dysfunctional family, a (predictable) locked-room mystery, and a (predictable -- but in this case, delightful) Irish heroine. What we DON'T have -- is a reasonable or (to my mind) believable mystery. Without providing plot spoilers (this is, after all, a mystery!) I found the motive for the crime to be lacking in realistic believability; the perpetrator weakly portrayed; and the accomplice little more than a "flat" character. Do I have any doubt that we'll see the heroine and her erstwhile beau in later novels? Nope! I just hope that they are placed in a better plot line! If you're into the "Blackie Ryan" mysteries -- this is good for a summer afternoon. But not much more.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Clean Up The Mess, November 8, 2007
It is with great expectation when a new Blackie Ryan mystery arrives to join my must read pile. Father Andrew M. Greeley doesn't disappoint his fans with the current THE BISHOP AT THE LAKE. Bishop Blackie is sent to vacation with his family while sleuthing out the designs of Archbishop Malachi Nolan who has his sights set on replacing Cardinal Sean Cronin. Before Malachi Nolan can cause Blackie's boss any problems he is the victim of an attack by hornets, which for him is a life-threatening allergy known to his entire family. Who would want to kill an ineffectual member of the church in the home of his parents and family? A must read that flows quickly to the final pages. Greeley interweaves ambition, greed, malice and romance into a satisfying read. Nash Black, author of TRAVELERS and SINS OF THE FATHERS.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|