|
|
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Good, but not the same as a school, August 13, 2008
In east Asian martial arts circles it has long been known that some people have a "genius" for martial arts. People who can interpret and learn book information, and apply it well against untrained or poorly trained opponents. Thing is, against properly trained opponents it is also known, they were almost always defeated. In east Asia, martial arts manuals have historically been used to preserve knowledge, more than anything else.
It is not impossible to learn martial arts from a book; some people are intelligent, and some just have way too much time on their hands, so it isn't impossible. However, constantly using applications against flesh and blood human beings is the only way to sharpen skill. I took the time to eye this book at a book store not far from here, and as far as the basics are concerned this work is pretty complete. I have taken Karate before, and, there were training methods in this book some of which I had never even heard of. Then again I did Goju Ryu, not Shotokan.
Case in point though; it is not impossible, but since statistically speaking, and even by east Asian tradition, martial arts geniuses are only one in a million, it is better to learn from a school, or, to pick up a book title if you have already studied Karate before under formal instruction. Myself personally I study Katas as an "emergency" measure before I can find a school again. However, a word of warning, it would have been impossible for me to understand ANY of the Kata manual I own, if it hadn't been for the instruction I received prior to the fact, that is me owning the text. If you are one of those people whose school closed down, who has taken Karate before, and wants to continue by all means use manuals. If you have studied the art before then manuals are easy to understand; pugilism is not the same as grappling, in all things pugilistic, you can easily learn proper form from manuals if you train hard enough.
However for people who have never had a formal class, or even made it as far as yellow belt, this book is not for you. Myself I was about to test for green before the place I studied at closed. If you're like me, then by all means; get this primer. It is easily the most comprehensive work on basics made, the one problem being it lacks crucial movement arrows, hence the reason why you need instruction prior to owning this and hope you have a good memory. If you want a "complete" self taught training course you will need to purchase this book in conjunction with Sugiyama's work "25 Shotokan Kata," which I will say, is excellent.
However, sooner or later, you will have to sharpen your skills with a flesh and blood human being, and because Karate is not completely pugilistic in nature, you will need a well trained instructor to teach you the grappling techniques. The truth is the Shotokan style actually has almost as many grappling techniques as the likes of Brazilian Jiu Jitsu, only, the emphasis is defense against strikes, tripping, locking, and almost all of it is "stand up." Indeed, skillful Karateka have, in the past, outgrappled Judoka and Catch Wrestlers; that is how comprehensive the stand up grappling training in Karate can be. However, genius or no, while I disagree if its with regards to the pugilistic nature of Karate, regarding the grappling moves I agree 100%; it is impossible, genius or no, to learn grappling from a book. And Karate, has quite an extensive library of throws, locks, trips and escapes. The Shotokan style, has some from Judo, some from Shaolin Chin Na, and some from indigenous wrestling forms of Okinawa. That much grappling, even if its only "stand up," you can not learn from a book.
However this title should be in the shelves of all instructors, students, or people whose schools closed on them. Good luck.
|