Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
10 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
One of the BEST Sci-Fi novels of all time !, August 10, 2001
Delighted to find this work available in hardback; I've got my old Penquin copy from the 60's (it cost less than a buck back then) and it's falling apart, as I read this book once a year whether I need to or not. I first heard of British scientist Fred Hoyle back in my freshman physics class at Wheaton College, Ill, in the early 60's re: his "steady state" theory; Shortly thereafter I came across "The Black Cloud." Hoyle is a terrific writer and brings to bear his expertise as a scientist in producing a novel that is engrossing, with the dialogue delightfully flavored with his subtle British sense of humor. I particulary enjoy the interaction between the dignified 'Astronomer Royal' and the chief character and maverick & rather unstable Professor Kingsly. The book begins with a description of a cold wintry January morning on the prime meridian in England, with the natives huddled around their fireplaces moaning about the weather, and quickly moves to Mt. Palomar above the California orange groves, where an underpaid Norwegian grad assistant finds that certain photographic plates (didn't have CDC's back then) taken of the Orion region of the sky show that an entire circle of stars is blinking on and off when compared with the plate taken somewhat earlier….a condition that shouldn't exist…and the action starts from there….of course the culprit is the "Black Cloud" heading straight for the solar system. I'm a fan of Heinlein, Asimov, Arthur C. Clark, et. al…but I gotta say this is my number one favorite of all time. Anybody who likes sci-fi within the realm of what actually could happen as told by a writer grounded in science…and who's got a flare for SETI will love this book. And the way he writes, I find myself visualizing being right there on the scene., whether at Mt. Palomar, Pasadena, or Nortonstowe out in the English countryside (where they all end up). Always felt it was too bad Hoyle wasn't a more prolific writer of novels....
|
|
|
15 of 17 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Every Thinking Person Should Know This Book, December 6, 1999
Every bright adolescent and teenager --not to mention adult-- should read this book and ponder its subject, which is nothing less than the provenance and place of thinking beings in the Universe. Full of stimulating, exciting ideas and speculations, with an engrossing and intelligent storyline, it engages the reader in addressing the problems presented. I say every teenager should read this book because no matter what your religious or philosophical bent or direction, that's the time in life when you really start considering these important topics in a mature fashion. The book was a thrill to me as a 12 year old in the late sixties; I read it again and again, along with The Martian Chronicles, the Odyssey, A Wrinkle in Time, the Robot books of Asimov, A Canticle for Leibowitz, Huck Finn, White Fang, and all the other high-quality fiction that insidiously teaches the reader to take seriously such questions as: what constitutes a soul (or conciousness)?; to what extent is there a place for compassion in nature; even if the universe is blind and uncaring, do I still have duties and obligations?; when may, and when must, I act even when my actions harm others?; and where did we come from, is there a reason for our being, is there a reason for everything, is there a reason for anything? This may seem pretty dry but the book, like the others mentioned, is not. It's exciting to come upon these questions, to treat them seriously especially for the first time, and it's important to learn to do this humanely (history is too full of people who get the Answer to these questions and then apply it vigorously to everyone in reach). And the cosmology is fascinating, too. The actual science is a little dated, but that won't hurt--the important stuff is still valid. I'm glad to see it back in print, even at so high a price--I want my daughters to read it. Someone ought to issue it in paperback. Compared to some of the books being read today in middle and high school (and many of these are good books), this work stands out. If you read the book and you AREN'T fascinated by the questions it raises, then either (a) you incapable of curiousity and wonderment, or (b) you have been mind-wiped by a culture of triviality and appetitive gratification--the Math is hard Barbie syndrome. I should note for those (parents) who are religiously inclined and concerned about this: The book does not preach amorality or a soulless universe. Neither is it, like the (wonderful) books of CS Lewis, a religious vehicle. It lies outside of these constraints. There is no magic or witchcraft, no something for nothing; the cloud's universe is our own, and displayed from a scientist's perspective. But it is not a perspective incompatible with views from other directions.
|
|
|
13 of 15 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Astonishingly Prescient, February 18, 2005
In this slender tale (190 pages) from 1957 -- the year of Sputnik and tailfins -- renowned astronomer Fred Hoyle managed to foretell AI (artificial intelligence), OCR (optical character recognition), TTS (text-to-speech converters), digital burst communications and a whole host of other technologies which didn't become commonplace until 40 years later.
Perhaps his most famous innovation in this story, however, is one very few other writers or thinkers have been able to contemplate, even today: non-organic intelligence. Most science fiction assumes "little green men" with bilateral symmetry and carbon-based morphology (think "Twilight Zone" with bad rubber masks). Hoyle was one of the few to theorize information-processing as the hallmark of life and/or intelligence, rather than some biological definition. In this, he is still ahead of us, nearly half a century later.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|
by Richard Dawkins
by Christopher Hitchens
by Jerry A. Coyne
by Christopher Hitchens
See all 100 books citing this book
