Customer Reviews

Black Dog of Fate: A Memoir

5 star:		(33)
4 star:		(17)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(2)
1 star:		(1)

 

 

This is a beautifully written book-- a lyrical nostalgia for 1950s suburb life haunted by the invisible presence of an Armenian family's violent past. Balakian has worked magic with this mingling of personal and historical narrative. He does falter a bit in the last couple of chapters, getting a tad preachy when the narrative speaks perfectly well for itself, but that's forgivable.

Read it because it's a lovely memoir. Read it because it's a slice of history your social studies curriculum probably left out. Or just read it.

This book is about the Turkish slaughter of the Armenian Turks during World War I. It is also about an Armenian-American's search for his family's past, and his present identity as viewed through one of the most horrific events of world history, an event made even more unimaginable by the fact that it occurred during the twentieth century.

Mr. Balakian's prose overwhelms without being self-pitying or maudlin. I can still smell and taste of walnut and lemon in an Amenian-American household in the 1950's, juxtaposed with the life of a boy who is living under the cloud of the horror of what happened to his ancestor in Turkey in 1917, before he became conscious of what actually occurred.

This book left me reeling and depressed for days. It is a book that must be read.

David W. Lee leelawok@mmcable.com

My boyfriend is Armenian and once mentioned the genocide that took place in April, 1915. I had no idea what he was referring to and was embarrassed at my lack of education...

Since America has decided to ignore the Armenian tragedy in all of its history books, I took it upon myself to become more educated on these events and share what happened with everyone I know. I bought this book to learn more about the Armenian culture through the eyes of someone who was also just beginning to learn about his own culture as he grew up in America. I found that Peter Balakian's book was one of the most eye-opening, identifiable stories of Armenian history. Even his descriptions of the various Armenian foods made my mouth water and my stomach ache with hunger.

My mother and father (who are German and Filipino) are now reading this story as well. We often comment on how shocked and amazed we are at how such tragic events happened to the Armenian people and which went totally unpunished, much less acknowledged, by world leaders and historians to date. It's absolutely shameless that Turkey would go on the record as having denied that such a genocide even took place. The resulting evil effects of the Armenian massacre have been felt worldwide throughout many generations. Hitler himself once stated in a speech on August 22, 1939, "Who after all is today speaking of the destruction of the Armenians..." He said this in preparation for the invasion of Poland and he subsequently planned to use the Armenian genocide as a model for his Jewish concentration camps, expecting that the world would ignore his actions just as it ignored the massacre against the Armenians.

Buy this book and educate yourself about a large piece of history that must never be forgotten. You won't be disappointed.

After I finished this book, I remembered a quote I had read upon leaving the Holocaust Museum in Washington, D.C. (writer unknown), "Many thoughts go through my mind, though I remain speechless." This is how I felt after I finished "Black Dog of Fate." The horrors of the Armenian genocide were introduced to me by reading this book, and Balakian made them personal. I felt like I knew his family, like I had adopted them as my own.

I think Balakian intertwined the personal and political beautifully -- I love how he uses the English language! This book moved me, changed me, and educated me in many ways.

The beauty of "Black Dog of Fate" is that anyone who has the good fortune of picking up the book will immediately relate to the author's childhood and sentiments. Balakian's writing is poignant and eloquent, as he enocovers the tragic history of his family and the entire Armenian people who faced Genocide at the hands of the Turkish government.

Even through his journey of probing his Armenian roots, Balakian remains the all-American kid. His evolution from a child to adult and the experiences he has along the way, are brilliantly familiar. I often found myself touched by his language and style, which capture the inquisitiveness, happiness and pain of coming of age.

However, the underlying theme is the complexity of discovering one's true identity, and the often piecemeal nature of this task. Balakian's discovery does not happen overnight, as we see glimpses of his family's painful secret even in his early years. His full appreciation comes at adulthood, when we see the beautiful blossoming of his self as an Armenian-American, or just a complete individual of any identity.

Balakian embodies the universal struggle to understand human nature and the spectrum of beauty and horror that it is capable of producing.

A definite must-read for everyone!!

This book is beautifully written. It does a marvelous job of portraying the growing pains of a teenage boy in his all-too-normal clashes with his parents; this boy's clashes, however, also have to do with his family's Armenian background. As a child, Balakian took for granted or failed to notice many of the hints and signs that his family had a very different history from the other families around them. As an adult, he grows curious, investigates and discovers the tragic events in his family's past. The book does a beautiful job of weaving these two stories together.

A true literary memoir, Balakian peppers his prose with poetry, legal documents, etc. etc. etc. A fascinating and heart wrenching look at one of the 20th Century's tragedies. At once intensely personal and heatedly political, it is a book which shows how important it is to learn about one's history, not just as an individual but also as a society.

Peter Balakian is an elitist in the best sense of the word. Being a memoir written by a son of a physician it is intricately interwoven with the past of the Armenian tragic history. It is a dynamite of revelations for those unfamiliar with the history and others seeking esthetic indulgence. Some "sub stories" in the novel are themselves plots for separate novels. Mr. Balakian generously and meticulously has opened up his heart and wisdom to those still remembering and honoring their past and present as humankind.

Black Dog of Fate is an extraordinary book: enormously skillful and revelatory as literature, downright potent as polemic. The consciousiness-changing part for me was seeing (smelling, tasting...) Balakian's processes of exploration, discovery and synthesis of meaning via mere images. Images, at the same time vistas for the individual psyche and universally comprehensible, are ground zero for both identity and communication. There is so much more one can say about Balakian's accomplishment...

I think this book was extremely informative. It was an eye openerto what had happened in the Genocide. And to correct what another review said, 1.5 million Armenians were massacred by the Turks. The worst part about this is that the Turkish government strongly denies that this ever happened. They spread lies about it and make sure that it never reaches any form of upper education. This is very wrong, as there are many people who can tell what happened, from their first person experience.

Another review had stated that the way it was written was very uninformative. This is correct, to some extent, as that reviewer wasn't Armenian. As an Armenian myself, I can relate to a lot of the things written in this story.

To wrap up my review, I think that everyone should read this book. It is about "The Genocide the world has chosen to ignore", as stated on the back cover. It is an important part of the world's history, and it is important that it is not lost.