Most Helpful Customer Reviews
18 of 19 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Karloff's great, but Lugosi's role is a minor one, September 23, 2003
This review is from: Black Friday [VHS] (VHS Tape)
It's hard not to get excited when you come across a film featuring both Bela Lugosi and Boris Karloff, but 1940's Black Friday features a somewhat disappointing and certainly unusual pairing of the two legendary stars. Not once do the two men appear in the same scene, and Lugosi's character is actually a rather minor one. As for Karloff, you won't find him hidden behind a mummy's shroud or dressed up as Frankenstein in this one (and it's always nice to actually see Karloff's own true face). Rather than playing a monster, Karloff gets to try his hand at creating a monster this time around. As the film opens, we meet Dr. Ernst Sovac (Karloff) on his way to the electric chair, and the notes he gives to a reporter tell the story of his downfall. Sovac's best friend was George Kingsley (Stanley Ridges), a mild-mannered college professor of English literature, who was critically injured when a group of mobsters tried to kill their former partner Red Cannon. Kingsley had serious brain damage and could not survive; knowing that Red Cannon had a spinal injury and was nothing but a low-down dirty criminal to begin with, Dr. Sovac made the decision to transplant part of Red's brain into Kingsley's. He saved his friend's life, but Kingsley soon began to act strangely. About this time, the good doctor found out that Red had half a million dollars hidden somewhere, and he took Kingsley to Red's old stomping grounds in New York hoping that the vestiges of Red in his friend's brain would lead him to the money. Unfortunately, Red actually began taking full control of his new body at times and set about systematically killing his old partners. Kingsley had no consciousness of the things Cannon had done when his persona reemerged, but events soon began to catch up with the dishonorable Dr. Sovac, making his bid for the loot all the more desperate. The real horror of this movie is Sovac's increasingly criminal ambitions and disregard for his best friend's life and sanity. Lugosi's role as a gangster is something of a bit part for him to be playing, and even Karloff is somewhat overshadowed by the performance of Stanley Ridges as Kingsley/Cannon. The casting of this movie does have an air of controversy around it which does much to explain Lugosi's throwaway role. Reportedly, Lugosi was originally to play Dr. Sovac, with Karloff taking the role of Kingsley. Some say Lugosi couldn't pull the part of Sovac off, which I don't buy for a second; the truth of the matter, it seems to me, is that Karloff wanted the part of Sovac for himself. Thus did Lugosi end up with a minor part in the movie, and there may have been some lasting resentment on his part as a result. There is one very interesting aspect to Lugosi's otherwise forgettable performance, however. The trailer to the film claims that Lugosi, in order to make the scene more realistic, was hypnotized to actually believe he was suffocating when his character is shut up inside a small room; I have not found any corroboration for this claim as of yet, but the scene itself lost some of its luster when Lugosi's character began suffocating after only a couple of minutes in what was basically just a closet. The whole brain transplantation idea is left rather vague, but the main flaw of Black Friday is the fact that some striking physical changes are wrought in conjunction with the transformations of Kingsley to and from Cannon. I can run with the transplant idea, but the notion that Kingsley's gray hair and wrinkles disappear when Cannon takes over is just a little much. Other than that, I was actually quite impressed with this film. In its own way, it does feature something of a novel twist to the whole Jekyll and Hyde motif, the action is compelling, and the cast is especially good for what could be considered a B-movie.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
10 of 12 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Bland Horrors; A Waste Of Talent, February 24, 2006
This review is from: Black Friday [VHS] (VHS Tape)
The horror dream team of Bela Lugosi and Boris Karloff produced erratic efforts in their numerous on-screen parings. With The Black Cat (1934) and The Raven (1935), the two men actually created a new genre of horror film; one which, it could be said, has never been equaled. Unfortunately, these two films went too far for 30's audiences, as The Raven led to a British ban on horror movies.
Panicking, Universal began the sterilization of their future efforts. The first signs came with The Invisible Ray (1936). A rather polite and straight forward science fiction tale, it at least gave Lugosi and Karloff the opportunity to have a protagonist/antagonist relationship similar to that of the earlier films.
But with Black Friday (1940), the results are so watery and uninspired that all sense of mood or lurking danger have been completely eliminated. As a surgeon who transplants the brain of a dead gangster into an English professor, Karloff's character is no longer a villain, barely an antagonist even, while Lugosi's role as a rival gangster is definitively thankless.
With a strong first billing, Karloff phones it in here. Compare his performance in this to those in The Body Snatcher or The Black Cat to see how much better he is when he respects the material.
Bela Lugosi has a great death scene, and that's it. He can't be on camera more than 10 minutes, tops. At least he has more dialog than in The Body Snatcher.
In the dual role, Stanley Ridges has to be given an A for effort, but he's the victim of a bad script. The character of the professor is so flaky and whimsical that you have no reason to care about him, while the gangster is so unpleasant and ugly that you have no reason to root for him.
One is only frustrated more when thinking how much better this film would have all been had they stuck with the original casting of Lugosi as the surgeon and Karloff as the gangster/professor. (It is well known that Karloff insisted on this role switch, though it is left for question whether he did it due to insecurities over the part or perhaps to get back at Lugosi, who had bragged about stealing Son Of Frankenstien (1938) from him.)With Karloff's quiet menace and Lugosi's zeal, this could have been the topper to their screen parings.
But as it stands, Black Friday is not worthy of the talent in it, and, by the looks of it, they felt the same way.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Mad Scientist Boris Gets Greedy!, November 22, 2009
This review is from: Black Friday [VHS] (VHS Tape)
Karloff plays Dr. Sovac, a doctor with high ambitions. Both his friend and a criminal gangster are hurt and lie in a hospital. As Dr. Sovac examines them he finds that the gangster has a half a mill hidden somewhere. Hey, I got an idea. Why not put part of the gangster's brain into my best friend's head. The friend no longer has brain damage and I have a half a mill "for research" *wink-wink*.
The movie is basically a gangster picture with some horror/sci-fi elements. Lugosi is disappointing in his gangster role, trying to snarl it up with his Hungarian accent.
Karloff tries to keep control over Kingsley. He takes him to the same hang-outs as the gangster in hopes the gangster part comes out and then Sovac can get the money. Unfortunately things get a little out of control.
The whole film is a flashback sequence. We start out with the Karloff character being led to the electric chair and the audience follows the diary left behind. The diary idea is pretty neat, reading the pages and watching the action.
The actor who plays Kingsley (Stanley Ridges) plays a dual role -- the kind professor and the evil gangster, complete with guns and dames. When Kingsley turns into "Red Cannon", his hair turns black and has a nice combed part, and his wrinkles disappear. Pretty weird how that happens, huh? Bit of a Jekyll/Hyde motif.
See this on DVD through the Bela Lugosi collection. Odd choice since Lugosi played a minor role.
The Bela Lugosi Collection (Murders in the Rue Morgue / The Black Cat / The Raven / The Invisible Ray / Black Friday)
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
