6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
An important topic but too many issues..., September 8, 2011
This review is from: The Black History of the White House (City Lights Open Media) (Paperback)
I wasn't sure what to expect when I picked up The Black History of the White House by Clarence Lusane. Although this was a very ambitious effort, I think that Lusane tried to do too much here.
I did expect that Black History would contain personal stories of those black men and women affiliated with the White House, and these stories were quite good. I enjoyed reading about Hercules and Oney (George Washington's slaves), Elizabeth Keckley (Mary Lincoln's seamstress) and Abraham Boldon (the first black Secret Service agent to see in the White House). The story of Michelle Obama's slave ancestors is fascinating. And I enjoyed reading about the building of the White House. It is here that Lusane is at his best. Lusane also talks about the black leaders who visited the White House and black entertainers who were brought in for guests. He discusses the black advisors and cabinet members who served various presidents. He runs down the list of just about every black person who ran for president, and of course, he ends with Barack Obama. In between, he relates presidential policies about blacks, segregation, discrimination, lynching, Jim Crow, Supreme Court rulings and the Civil Rights movement. The author even includes a section on fictional black presidents in arts and literature. It was as if Lusane Googled black history in America and then tried to include anything and everything that appeared.
Although I enjoyed much of Black History, I had many issues with this book. First, it is filled with errors that should have been easy to catch. George Washington lived in the President's House in Philadelphia for 7 years, not 9. And he left Philadelphia at the end of his term, 1797, and not 1799. Lusane claims that Washington tried to hide his slaves while living in Philadelphia. Ron Chernow in Washington: A Life tells of Washington's financial ledgers that show he gave money to his Philadelphia slaves for outside entertaining. I don't think he would have done so if he was trying to keep them hidden. Black History is filled with many suppositions and assumptions such as "It is quite possible that she [Elizabeth Keckley] was the closest black person to him [Lincoln] during his presidency." I'm pretty certain that Lincoln was much closer to his black barber, William H. Johnson, whom he brought with him to Washington from Springfield. Johnson also served as his valet. Lusane sees discrimination behind every door. While the history of blacks in the United States is nothing to be proud of, he finds fault and insults where he shouldn't. After John Adams' first night in the White House, he offers up a prayer: "'I pray Heaven bestow the best of blessings on this house, and on all that shall hereafter inhabit it. May none but honest and wise men ever rule under this roof.' He failed to acknowledge the black people whose years of work went into constructing the house." This was a prayer for the future and not a prayer of thanksgiving. Adams didn't acknowledge all the white people who toiled on the White House, either. Lusane goes into great detail about jazz and the history of jazz performers (black and white) who entertained in the White House. Yet, Truman's desegregating the military, a monumental event, merits only one short sentence that is not even noted in the index. Finally, Lusane gives too much information that is not necessary for the book. He tells us of Blind Tom Wiggins, the first black musician to entertain in the White House in the 1800s. But then he tells us about other black classical musicians who never set foot in the White House. This was unnecessary and made this book longer than it needed to be.
I think that The Black History of the White House is a very important topic and I was disappointed that this book wasn't better than it was. Personally, I think that Lusane should have narrowed his scope a little and tightened up his narrative. It would have made things less rambling and more organized.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
6 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A layman's viewpoint of an informative book, August 11, 2011
This review is from: The Black History of the White House (City Lights Open Media) (Paperback)
This book is an eye opener. I am a layman, not a college professor, or a huge intellect...just a person that likes to read. It is a history book about African-Americans in relation to the White House, beginning with a slave who escaped from George Washington! The reasoning was amazing in this incident. Discusses slaves who built the White House and Black people who have worked as servants, and employees. Discusses several outstanding Black people that left a mark on history, even though they were slaves! Goes thru history of United States, presidency by presidency, and their ATTITUDES and TREATMENT and LAWS during each term. Tells about first Blacks invited to White House for special occasions and for entertainment. Covers all the way to President Obama. Very readable through most of it. Very eye opening. Wrote of many incidents in recent months which I read about in the news. Not perfect, a few things dragged a bit, but I'd give it 4.5 stars. I am very glad I read it. It opened my eyes and made me very conscious of a lot that is happening during this presidency. I highly recommend it. It had to have been painful for Dr. Lusane to do the research for this book. Our country definitely has a black eye when it comes to race relations.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
6 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The Black Hisory of the Wwhite House (City Lights Open Media), June 23, 2011
This review is from: The Black History of the White House (City Lights Open Media) (Paperback)
If we had history text books like this when I was in high school and college, I would not have despised or disliked history as much as I did. This book is challenging to read and I am still reading it. I am enjoying every page of it. I hate I missed out on so much in the text books. Highly recommended!!!!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No