Most Helpful Customer Reviews
5 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
An Excellent Read, November 26, 2006
This review is from: Black Ice (Paperback)
Some of what others here have written is true, but I quite vehemently disagree with the person who typified the book as "too sexist for belief." That couldn't be more wrong. Lauren, the FEMALE protagonist, is the proverbial Rock that kept the entire station together through any and all amounts of adversity. She was The Leader from beginning to end! Yes, she made one particularly frustrating decision, but not ALL the men are perfect either -- many are weak, shallow and, considering Fitzgerald, the MALE antagonist, much worse. I found Dickinson's book to be engrossing and quite realistic. He clearly has the Cold Adventure Chops to write about this kind of thing, considering his 1996 venture up Mt. Everest which resulted in his 2000 book "The Other Side Of Everest" -- already well reviewed here at Amazon. In fact, I just ordered his non-fiction book whilst writing this review. And no, I'm not a Dickinson Shill. I simply purchase what pleases me and what looks good. I'll not be a Plot Spoiler here; simply suffice to say that, if you're looking for a realistic portrayal of Antarctic adventure, this is your book. The book isn't sexist or racist or ageist or iceist or any other kind of "ist" you can imagine. Someone had an agenda in that review and, for whatever reason, a good read wasn't on it. Bottom line? You can't beat an excellent adventure like this for $6.99. Just a HAIR dissatisfying? Fitzgerald's future. On the other hand, one could say that Dickinson took the superior stance and avoided going for the obvious in terms of retribution and revenge.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Great Artic Adventure, March 29, 2007
This review is from: Black Ice (Paperback)
Very entertaining book on survival in the Artic. Brings out the excitement of survival from both the extreme elements and a murderous adventurer. Enjoyed it very much.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Awesome Antarctic Adventure, December 27, 2006
This review is from: Black Ice (Paperback)
Lauren Burgess is fulfilling the dream of a lifetime running Capricorn Base, a scientific research station in the Antarctic interior. Three hundred miles away, an expedition consisting of famous explorer Julian Fitzgerald and his companion, Carl Norland, has run into trouble. The two men would have been the first to cross Antarctica on foot at its widest point if they hadn't run out of supplies and begun starving to death 80 miles from the goal. The rescue plane they summon crashes, so Lauren and one of her four teammates, Sean, ride to the rescue, taking the two explorers and Richard, a journalist who survived the crash, back to Capricorn to wait out the winter. It is soon apparent that Julian Fitzgerald is not the hero the media has made him out to be; rather he is dangerously reckless with resources and lives, and Lauren and Sean believe he kept food supplies to himself while leaving Carl and Richard to starve while awaiting rescue. When he announces his plans to finish his trek, demanding a ride back to the crash site to resume his journey, Lauren refuses, and his behavior really gets out of control. Suffice it to say, the team at Capricorn Base finds themselves on the run with almost no resources, in a race to find rescue in the most inhospitable place on earth. While the story is intriguing and compelling, there were a few minor weak points. Julian Fitzgerald vacillates between being paranoid and just a spoiled brat in a way that lacks consistency. Also, while I liked the outcome, the ending left me feeling cheated. We had been with these characters through an entire Antarctic winter, suffered every step with them on their arduous journey, felt all their hunger and pain, and in the end, though we know their fate, they fade into the background instead of having the book show us their triumph. The same number of pages in the postscript that focused elsewhere would have been better spent with our team of six hardy heroes, and delivering comeuppance to the villain. That was an event I DESERVED to see after all I vicariously went through at his expense, but it didn't happen. While it is a black mark against it, the ending does not ruin the book because I did like the outcome, and overall it was very well written. Though it contained the clichéd scene of the good guy being too good to finish the villain when she had the chance, thereby needlessly further endangering her team before belatedly growing the spine needed to try to fix things when it was already too late, it was still nonetheless a very good Antarctic thriller. I don't think I've ever read a book with better descriptions of that continent and its frozen landscape. The heroes were also a likeable lot, and the villain deliciously detestable, as they should be in a good adventure tale. In all, Black Ice is a satisfying page-turner.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|