Most Helpful Customer Reviews
44 of 48 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A mixed bag, July 2, 2007
I'm having a hard time coalescing my thoughts on this one. On the one hand, my first thought midway through the book was that someone ought to get on the job of making "13" tee shirts. On completing the book, I wanted to go get that tee shirt, wear it to the mall and stare down anyone who questioned me - just because. In fact, just as Fight Club spawned imitation clubs around the nation, I thought that there are still Thirteen personality types running about, and they might start to form informal networks to combat the influence of the Cudlips (as incongruous as that might sound). I conclude in some respects, the book is extremely compelling.
In other respects, although a huge fan of Mr. Morgan's earlier work (Altered Carbon is one for the ages) I think Market Forces was kind of a miss, and Thirteen, although a compelling read, didn't quite take it over the edge either. There were several stylistic problems - names too close to each other, different characters referenced by the same name - which didn't appear in his earlier works, and a lot of the promised and implied consideration of race, gender, identity and even species didn't seem fully developed. A lot of the characters have seemingly identical experiences (illegal pregnancy - with a child of a Thirteen; waking up early on the Mars flight) but whether this was deliberate or intended to draw comparisons or contrasts seemed unresolved. Marsalis could have been Kovacs' spiritual great-great grandfather when it comes to choices of weapons and problem-solving techniques, but given those tendencies, the plot developments seemed predictable. There is still an interesting murder-mystery underlying everything, but since the protagonist's approach to investigation is reminiscent of a pinball smacking into various bumpers and being flung about, there is little subtlety.
On balance, Thirteen is worth reading and it will leave you with a bit to think about at the end. I'd recommend it for anyone who hasn't read Altered Carbon already as a sort of primer, but it's a slight step down, hence one star less.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
36 of 42 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Ambitious new novel by Morgan is flawed but enjoyable 3 1/2 stars, July 31, 2007
First I have to give credit to writer Richard K. Morgan for his latest novel THIRTEEN; Morgan's latest novel is an ambitious affair tackling a lot of major themes with some of his most complex characters to date. Morgan's latest is very good a lot of the time but some of the subplots don't gel and actually slow down the main narrative without adding much substance to it. Even if THIRTEEN isn't a perfect novel, it demonstrates that Morgan's skills as a writer are continuing to grow.
A summary of the plot follows:
When a shuttle between Mars and Earth crash lands in the Pacific Ocean with body partsfrom the passengers strewn throughout the ship, COLONY Executives Sevgi Eretkin and senior partner Tom Norton are called in to investigate and find out which passenger woke up prematurely, used the autosurgeon to cut up and eat all the sleeping passengers. They discover that a Thirteen a genetically enhanced soldier that had been banished to Mars (or to a resettlement area)after they were no longer useful and deemed a threat was behind the murders eating the crew because his sleeping chamber opened prematurely. Now he is on a killing spree and they aren't sure why.
They partner up with Carl Marsalis another Thirteen who makes a living hunting other Thirteens and either bringing them in for resettlement or killing them. Seen as a traitor to his own kind and never accepted by humanity, Marsalis is a bruised outcast who tries to do the right thing while surviving in a world where he's not welcome. When it comes to light that the escaped Thirteen Alan Merrin had help in escaping and that he's part of a far larger plan, Marsalis and Ertekin feel compelled to track him down and find out the larger truth behind his escape.
End of summary:
At over 500 pages Morgan attempts to create a character as compelling as his protagonist Takeshi Kovacs the anti-hero of three of Morgan's five novels. While Carl Marsalis is, indeed, an interesting character equally as flawed as Kovacs, the story that Morgan has here careens out of control at time. The convoluted story takes a little too long to get going and once it does the shifting from one subplot to another isn't as smooth as some of his other novels. Morgan's world here is just as brutal and uncompromising as the world(s)that Kovacs inhabits with its noirish touches. The mystery at the heart of the novel just isn't quite as compelling and the plot strands don't hold together quite as well as his previous books.
THIRTEEN is still an enjoyable novel and worthwhile for those patient enough to follow Morgan's ambitious novel to its conclusion. The main drawback to the novel is that Morgan's many supporting characters aren't quite as compelling as his anti-hero Marsalis and we spent too much time with them. THI1RTE3N is a flawed but very good book that Morgan fans will enjoy. I'd suggest ALTERED CARBON or BROKEN ANGELS as a first read before this. I continue to look forward to Morgan's other efforts. Once he's able to create a cohesive novel with the power of his Kovacs novels (particularly BROKEN ANGELS the best of the series)and with as many plot strands as this novel, we'll be in for a rare, rich treat.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
7 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Can't call it spellbinding..., October 30, 2008
The only thing spellbinding about this book was that someone reviewed it as "spellbinding". Someone at the bindery must have accidently put the wrong cover on a Takeshi Kovacs novel for the reviewer.
To begin with the book is only a fair read. Some action, some sci-fi, nothing groundbreaking. I read it through, only finishing because I came three quarters through when it stalls out hopelessly. I am a fan of Morgan's earlier Kovacs novels. If you like those books then you will quickly realize that the tone is pretty similar minus the sleeving technology. The book goes off the rails when he starts painting the future in pretty simplistic political terms. Jesusland.. Really? The concept of the THIRTEEN is a good one but somewhere in the middle of the book there is a full blown seminar on Anthropological societal development that sounds like he wrote it right out of his research notebook when he got off the phone with whatever college professor he uses. Then there's Peru... The author must have wanted to vacation somewhere and write it off as work expense. The whole book is weak on plot. All the female characters are interchangeable. Same personality, same dialog just paper cut outs. BUT BY FAR the most unforgivable aspect is the main character is english... Say it with me English. Yet he is written with no location specific speech, vernacular cadence... nothing. He makes no real English references, has no cultural differences whatsoever. Of course none of the characters have except the ignorant southerners.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|