Most Helpful Customer Reviews
9 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Eyewitness reportage from an unusual perspective, March 11, 2007
This review is from: Black Man's Grave: Letters From Sierra Leone (Paperback)
The authors are well qualified to write on the subject of Sierra Leone, having lived in a village there as Peace Corps volunteers. They report on what the "fly-in-photograph-an-amputee-fly-out" press corps has called a "civil war," but what Sierra Leoneans more accurately call the Rebellion. Their primary sources are letters from friends, people who lived through the violence and who stayed in contact throughout the whole terrible time. The people writing the letters create a vivid picture of the physical and economic devastation they endured, and the authors place these pictures in a larger context that includes what was going on in Liberia at the time. I commend them for resisting the urge to editorialize, and for letting the facts speak for themselves.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Voices that should be heard, March 5, 2007
This review is from: Black Man's Grave: Letters From Sierra Leone (Paperback)
I finished reading Black Man's Grave recently and found it very interesting; I read it in two days, and I am notorious for prolonging or abandoning books that I don't like, to give you some idea of context here. It was a story I really had very little idea of. When civil war afflicts a country like Sierra Leone, it only tends to get into the American media every few years when there is major combat in a major city. I had never seen the issues and the personalities laid out with such clarity, let alone guessed the impact on people trying to lead ordinary lives (economic, social, family) in the community. I would imagine, not unruefully, that the reason the book did not find a major publisher is that it's in the voices of the authors' friends in Fadugu, Sierra Leone. Philip Gourevitch's We Wish to Inform You, which is also a very good book, has an edge in terms of marketability in that it is a "voice-driven" book by a Western reporter. Gourevitch relays what others tell him, just as Stewart & Amman do (he was not an eyewitness to the Rwandan genocide), but he does it as a first-person character; it's part travel book, odd as that seems. By giving people from Sierra Leone such a major voice in Black Man's Grave, having them truly speak for themselves, Stewart & Amman probably lost a potential American audience - or to be accurate, went beyond publishers' willingness to find out whether such an audience exists. I think that publishers sell their public short sometimes.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Evocatively written, carefully researched, September 15, 2009
This review is from: Black Man's Grave: Letters From Sierra Leone (Paperback)
According to urban gang expert David Kennedy it takes relatively few thugs to begin utterly terrorizing a neighborhood -- or, as Gary Stewart, John Amman, and their informants in Sierra Leone can testify, an entire country.
Black Man's Grave is contemporary African history as viewed by a journalist and an academic, professionals whose assessments are deepened by a patina of nostalgia. Both Stewart and Amman were Peace Corps volunteers in Sierra Leone, and they mourn the imperfect paradise they knew from their work in the same northern village, Fadugu (which means in Mandingo, "a town where one is well fed"), where three ethnic groups converged more than a century ago and managed to co-exist and thrive. Rounding out their insights are letters from old Fadugu friends: teachers, agricultural technicians, and other citizens who somehow, but not always, survived Sierra Leone's genocidal 1992-2002 civil war.
Evocatively written and carefully researched, Black Man's Grave can't really be done justice in a short review. Stewart and Ammans's combination of history and reportage, and the letters' poignantly matter-of-fact close-ups, take the reader from Sierra Leone's days as a refuge for former slaves through the nineteenth century, when regional chiefs cannily manipulated their British masters, into the last century of cultural progress and relative affluence. Sierra Leone was eventually devastated by greed, with the struggle to control its diamond mines resulting in mass killings and punitive mutilations, sexual violence, and the enslavement of child soldiers, a nightmare orchestrated by the country's rival leaders and neighboring Liberia's president Charles Taylor.
A number of publishers inexplicably turned down Black Man's Grave, although declaring it "remarkable" (Thomas Dunne Books), "quite compelling" (Beacon Press), and "the kind of book [we'd] love to publish here" (Basic Books). The Special Court for Sierra Leone, set up jointly by the government of Sierra Leone and the United Nations, is now underway in The Hague, mandated to try Charles Taylor and other leaders for war crimes committed in Sierra Leone since November 30, 1996. As of this writing, Mr. Taylor's case is in the defense phase, so Black Man's Grave is a particularly timely read. Fifty percent of its profits will go to projects benefiting the people of Fadugu. -- Melanie Lawrence for the FEARLESS REVIEWS
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
|