Most Helpful Customer Reviews
5 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
An Incredbile Page Turner, September 22, 2008
This review is from: Black Rabbit Summer (Hardcover)
I came to discover this book in a truly bizarre way - I won a pre-release proof copy in a gift basket of books at a raffle. I have no idea where it came from. I will also state up-front that I am over 40 years old, and not your typical demographic for this book. While I found this book to be a very easy read, it was also incredibly suspenseful and I enjoyed it tremendously. I read it over the course of a few days rather than my typical "few weeks". The characterizations are very well done; even though there is very little descriptive prose (and TONS of dialog) you get a very good internal image of these young people. I agree with most of what the previous reviewer wrote, with a couple of exceptions: 1) The dialog is a little too realistic - characters say "What?" at least a hundred times in this book, only to have the previous line of dialog re-stated. It feels realistic, and helps drive home some points, but it is overused and becomes agonizingly tedious (unless it was changed after the pre-release copy) and 2) while it is not glamorized, these kids get drunk, smoke dope, take drugs, have sex, lie, commit strong acts of violence, and get themselves in way over their head. The "F" word is used about 100 times. A mature reader might understand the lessons found between the lines, but I'm afraid other, less mature readers, might see all these recognizable characters doing unacceptable things and somehow legitimize their behavior. None of these characters have any redeeming values, other than the friedship and loyalty between two of them, nor should any of them serve as role models. Maybe I'm an overly protective parent, but I strongly disagree with rating of "12 and older" in my advance copy. A 12 year old will have nightmares for a week. Maybe a mature 15 or 16. This is Stephen King type stuff, toned down only a *little* bit.
Despite these warnings, Black Rabbit Summer really was a wonderful surprise, and a very good story. I'd give it 4.5 stars if I could.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Listen To Your Inner Rabbit, July 11, 2008
This review is from: Black Rabbit Summer (Hardcover)
This book involves a bunch of 16 year old kids, mostly boys. And a rabbit. Three actually. Think trinity. No sense in reviewing the storyline. Look above for that. Pete and Raymond are best friends, even though Raymond is a little odd. His black rabbit passes messages to him. And one time Pete thinks he hears a message. He should have listened to the rabbit. But then there would be no book.
The story grabs your interest right away. You can't help but relate to Pete. Unless you were never a teenager. Pete's big problem is that he is constantly hiding the truth from those who need to know. He also has a problem with doing what he is told to do. Everytime he sneaks out and tries to do things his way he just gets himself deeper into trouble. If he had come completely clean from the begining his life would have gone much easier. But then if he had listened to the rabbit there would never have been anything for him to lose sleep over. He and Raymond would still be living in a world where friendship ruled. This book would be recomended for teens to read in hopes that it might impress upon them the need to not try to take things in their own hand when others are far more capable.
Okay, so we have some swearing. Some illusions about sex but no actual events discussed much. Pete fooled around some but never actually did anything with his girl. Gay activity comes up but is never described. If acknowledging that teens are sexual upsets you then don't buy this. Or if drinking and drugs perturb you go read a Hardy Boys book. None of these activities are presented in a positive light. Like in real life they just happen.
So why four stars and not five. I just didn't like the way the author wrapped up the story over the final 80 pages. Im not surre what I wanted. And I don't want to spoil it for anyone by explaining myself. Its just that I had questions. But then I guess in real life when all is said and done there are always unresolved issues.
So then what is the lesson: If a rabbit, real or porcelan, seems to be putting thoughts into your head, LISTEN.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
Courtesy of Teens Read Too, August 14, 2011
It's a rite of passage from adolescence to adulthood, leaving old friends behind for a future beckoning with invitations of bigger and better things to come. There is a reason we outgrow friendships. Sometimes things are better left behind.
Peter wasn't even thinking when he got the phone call; after all, it was summer. If he would have been, he'd have stuck with Raymond and let the others go on without them without looking back. As it was, nostalgia got the better of him, and he agreed to meet one last time in the den, their former home-away-from-home, but only if Raymond could come, too. Besides, he and Nicole had more than just a past, didn't they?
Five former friends, some booze, and a combination of drugs (some by choice, some not), add up to one night of confusion, chaos, and death. What follows in classic Brooks fashion is a mystery that continues to weave into itself more intricately rather than toward a resolution. Oh yes, certain issues are resolved involving who murdered whom along the way, but it's hard to say when we find those details out that it even matters. Who we end up caring most about is not the rich, fake, do-anything-to-be-famous Stella, but the odd, loner Raymond who talks to his black rabbit. Oh yeah, and it talks back to him.
Brooks is extraordinary at pulling us into his characters, leading us ever so slowly to answers, and then leaving much, though not all, left unsaid. If you are looking for a perfect ending, he's probably not your man. If you are looking to be challenged as a reader and not spoon-fed all the answers? Here's yet another of his works where you won't walk away being disappointed.
Reviewed by: Angie Fisher
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|