Teased for so long, Gary Clark Jr., thank you for finally issuing this album. I have played the Bright Lights CD over so many times, waiting for this album to be released. And then it arrives and oh darn it; this is a mangled mess of an album. There are songs on here that make me want to tear my ears out and never listen to music again, and then there are masterpieces that I can listen to a million times. To me, this should have been two albums - a beautiful hard-core rock / blues album that drives hard, and an over produced pop album (and throw in maybe a little nod to the 50's Rock Around The Clock crowd).
This album is a download, not buy. If your tastes run the same direction as his Bright Lights EP, the preview clips do an excellent job showing which tracks are in that same direction and which are the pop tracks to avoid. On the other hand, if pop music is something you love, well avoid those harder tracks and enjoy funk, rock, and 50's music.
The album is a mystery of contrasts and not necessarily put together to listen from track one to thirteen. Yes, 80's funk and urban music has their roots in the blues. But putting John Legend style smooth next to the hard-edged blues song Bright Lights just makes no sense at all. And I will forever scratch my head over how somebody could put a hard-core Delta Blues song on this album. Maybe it will introduce this blues style to new fans.
Ain't Messin Around will probably get radio play. What I've loved about the original EP and Gary's live performances are his amazing guitar playing and clean mixes. Ain't Messin Around is heavily produced with many backing tracks and just too much of everything compared to his other songs. This is just one of those almost pop songs that I hope he makes a pile of money with. There are a lot of reasons to compare Gary to The Black Keys - they are both first and foremost blues bands (yes I know, Dan and Patrick don't want to be called a blues band, because nobody buys blues records). This song does essentially the same thing The Black Keys did with Brothers, they moved to a more accessible style of music. Gary went the 80's funk route with less rock and roll edge on this song.
When My Train Pulls In - This is the Gary Clark Jr. I love. Exactly in the same tone as Bright Lights, he reminds me that he is an amazing guitar player. This is the reason I love this guy. Studio version of what was an excellent live track on The Bright Lights EP.
Blak and Blu - Written by Gary Clark Jr., Gil Scott-Heron, Brian Jackson, and Don Robey. This sounds a bit like John Legend, oh how did Gary let his voice move toward that smooth funk, way over produced style of music?
Bright Lights is the final release of the song Gary has been playing for well over a year. It is the big song from his EP.
Travis County - Johnny B. Goode, channeling. I'm sure he had fun making this song. My tastes don't run toward the Rock Around The Clock rock and roll. Gary almost makes this a good song, for me it falls a bit short. I hate to admit it but I picture Fonzie jumping over the shark with this song.
The Life. Oh no, autotune, Gary no no no you can't do this. Where in the world did this come from? Eric Clapton hates you for this song. This is one of those cute pop songs about getting high. Foster The People would be very proud of this song - hide something in a catchy silly pop hook. And it is even worse; the engineer added fake record LP snaps a pops to the intro and close of the song.
Glitter Ain't Gold - Another good follow up to Bright Lights. Doyle Bramhall II collaborated on writing this song with Gary. I would have liked less backing vocals that cover up the music and Gary's voice. Another song where his guitar playing is front and center.
Numb - Yes, finally a real blues song. Hard driving, and painful about his woman doing him wrong. Guitar, drums, and bass - exactly the instruments that make Gary sound the best. Finally, Eric Clapton, and Buddy Guy would be proud of Gary.
Please Come Home - oh please, 50's Frankie Valley crooning. Oh no, this is just plain painful. Fully loaded with the trumpets, violins, and silly background music. And then Gary does a great guitar solo in the middle with all the doo whop music playing at the same time. If I wanted 50's music, I'd buy a greatest hits album.
Things Are Changin' - studio version of the excellent live track from Bright Lights EP. I do kind of like this even though it still has John Legend floating in it. The difference with the other songs, there is a harder edge to his voice, the rhythm is infectious, and works with his voice. I do prefer the live version.
Third Stone From The Sun / If You Love Me Like You Say - Jimi Hendrix song. Gary slowed this song down from the way Hendrix originally performed the song. Where Hendrix cuts words off for emphasis, Gary runs them out a bit longer. They threw in a little organ and scratching for good measure. Gary isn't quite Hendrix on the guitar, but man he is ever so close. This is not a great version of the song, but I still like it.
You Saved Me - nasty gritty fuzzed guitar opens this song. But then his voice comes in a little too perfect, a little too smooth. But the contrast is good in this case. I'm not a huge fan of the rhythm guitar hook, a little too simple compared to the gritty lead guitar. Overall, this one pulls those differences off.
Next Door Neighbor Blues - Delta Blues!!! Gary on the slide guitar and a ratty old blues microphone, life is fabulous. Hubert Sumlin, and Honeboy Edwards would be proud of this song. I have no idea how anybody could possibly put this song and the opening track the same album. They are just so different and appeal to such a different audience.
One big omission from the EP - You Don't Owe Me A Thang is not on this album. I love that song. He could have easily gotten rid of one of those over produced pop pieces of trash and published this song.
In the end, download this album, pick and choose tracks carefully. Gary Clark Jr. is an amazing singer, songwriter, and guitarist. He works darn hard and deserves a huge paycheck. I hope he was paid very well for this album. I also hope that his next album goes to what he knows how to do so well, write great music, play an incredibly guitar, and sing his heart out. Leave the engineers and corporate marketing people out of the music.
The Bright Lights EP