Customer Reviews

Blood Matters: From Inherited Illness to Designer Babies, How the World and I Found Ourselves in the Future of the Gene

5 star:		(2)
4 star:		(2)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(1)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

This book is one of the few books on genetic screening that gives you a feel for the topic. It does this through personal journey as well as investigative journalism blending the two so as to explore the implications and inevitable consequences of genetic screening. It covers cancer, huntingtons and other rare hereditary conditions and illuminates the burdens and reliefs the current knowledges can provide. It is easy to read, compelling and wise. My only criticism would be the chapter on prenatal screening - this was not as well thought through and lacked the wisdom of the rest of the book. All in all it is a considerable achievement and I would highly recommend it to the general reader as well as those with a particular interest in medicine.

BLOOD MATTERS: FROM INHERITED ILLNESS TO DESIGNER BABIES, HOW THE WORLD AND I FOUND OURSELVES IN THE FUTURE OF THE GENE tells of genetics using the author's foundation of experience as the starting point. In 2004 she was told she had a mutation that predisposed her to ovarian and breast cancer: the problem proved what to do with this knowledge. BLOOD MATTERS explores how genetic information is reshaping the decision-making process - and how these new decisions are reshaping knowledge of self. Any general interest lending library strong in health references will find this an excellent lend - as well as college-level collections strong in genetic health books.

Diane C. Donovan
California Bookwatch

I took to Masha Gessen's writing immediately. Smart and inquisitive, she asks interesting questions and she displays both genuineness and insight over the course of her journey to make and justify her decision to undergo prophylactic mastectomies. She reveals moments when her professional facade breaks down and she finds herself reduced to a scared woman hoping the experts she consults can give her the wisdom she seeks. All through her story, however, she maintains an honesty and human sense of connection that makes this book an engaging read. Her search through the medical system, through economics (as the science of decision-making), through psychology and aesthetics, and through applied genetics makes fascinating reading. Anyone interested in locating the right questions to ask about genetic science and in considering the opinions of some of today's leading-edge thinkers and practitioners in this area will enjoy this book.

Sometimes it is difficult to fathom that one's fate may be predestined at the moment of conception. A predisposition to disease, addiction or even a behavioral pattern is stored in an embryo in an instant. Masha Gessen received a devastating call early in the year 2004 that changed her life and way of thinking. "In the BRCA1 gene, there is a deleterious mutation . . . I'm sorry." Her BRCA gene, or breast cancer gene, was now a harbinger of possible disease and death. It wasn't simply the luck of the draw, it was her genetic inheritance. Masha, well-known journalist and author, ponders her fate and those of others in her intensely riveting book, Blood Matters: From Inherited Illness to Designer Babies, How the World and I Found Ourselves in the Future of the Gene.

As a midlife Ashkenazim Jew Masha's decision to opt for genetic testing was the beginning of a life altering search for the gene, its hidden agenda and impact on her life. She'd have to think long and hard before she allowed any surgeon to slash into her body to remove her breasts and yank out her life-giving ovaries. Although Jews were well known as genetic guinea pigs and she began to think not only of her genetic inheritance, but of others in similar circumstances.

Susie was a young Amish woman who loved children and most likely wanted a lot of them in her life. When her first child was born, nothing was amiss, yet when the others came along there was something terribly wrong. Levi, Sylvain and Steve were born and soon became seriously disabled. Sylvain died very suddenly in the back of the carriage. Later Levi died and then more babies came along. What would be their lot in life? Then there are the children with Maple Syrup Disease, Tay-Sachs, cystic fibrosis, Niemann-Pick and numerous other devastating diseases. What will happen to them in the future? What will happen to those yet unborn? Gessen ponders and discusses our collective genetic whack with both alacrity and well-informed solemnity.

Seldom I find any work of nonfiction that proves to be a page turner, but Masha Gessen's Blood Matters proved to be the exception to the rule. There didn't appear to be any rhyme or reason to her choice of stories as she hopped from one genetic topic to the next, but I was utterly fascinated. Most of the focus was on the Ashkenazim Jewish genetic legacy or Jews in general, but it made no difference in my high level of interest. From her short treatise on designer babies to her own personal quarrel with her genetic makeup I kept turning those pages. This book is a definite "must have" for anyone interested in taking closer look at themselves and all humanity.

The book describes the journey of the author who is diagnosed with a genetic mutation that predisposes her to ovarian and breast cancer. As she fights personal battle, she also tries to explore the field of genetic testing, its implications as well as ethical considerations.

The jacket cover of the book claims it is "a much needed field guide to this unfamiliar and unsettling territory." Well, it is not. It is more a rambling journey across a difficult terrain by a pioneer, discovering trails and gathering knowledge during the process. The lack of a science background and the inability to explain the fundamentals in a clear and structured way weakens the book. Explaining a complex science to the laymen is tough but has been mastered by authors like Carl Sagan, Brian Greene and Richard Dawkins. This book fails to reach that level.

However, it does capture well the agony of an individual who goes through a challenging situation created by new knowledge provided by science. This will definitely be something more of us go through in future as we will be forced to grapple with the information provided by genetic testing.

The book provides interesting information on Asheknazi Jews as well as organizations like Dor Yeshorim which collect genetic data to provide predictive information. In spite of her jewish heritage, the author covers the Nazi efforts on eugenics with equanimity. A number of genetic diseases and their current research status are covered in the book through many interviews with experts across the world. Nevertheless the lack of a clear structure, direction and focus wastes the author's efforts to a large extent.