Most Helpful Customer Reviews
32 of 34 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
An extraordinary book that you will not soon forget, June 15, 2009
This review is from: The Blue Notebook: A Novel (Hardcover)
Customer review from the Amazon Vine™ Program (What's this?)
What an extraordinary book, one that is unrelentingly graphic in its portrayal of the life of a child prostitute, but beautiful in its depiction of the human spirit and the will to survive. Batuk Ramasdeen is nine years old when she is sold to a sex trader by her father. Sold to the highest bidder looking for a young virgin she is then brought to an `orphanage' where she becomes trained in her new profession. Batuk lives in a small cage on the Common Street, in Mumbai, India; here she is prostituted on a daily basis in exchange for some food and a place to sleep. Using her imagination and her ability to write, a skill she learned while housed in a missionary hospital, Batuk escapes the horrors of her existence by writing and telling stories. It is here that this book shines, for Batuk's tales are beautifully written and her descriptions of her escape in her mind's eye are lyrical. The author's juxtaposition of such beauty in the midst of unrelenting horror cuts to your heart. When it seems that Batuk's life may have taken a slight turn for the better, a small flame of hope is ignited in the reader, but our heroine is not so easily fooled. She knows that to most of the people she comes in contact with she is no more than an object to be used; a whore, a bitch, a toy, a dolly, but never a human being. She has no illusions about her existence and knows her only escape will be through her stories, which give her life meaning. I believe this is the author's debut; I will certainly be looking for another book by him in the future. In many ways the story reminded me of The Kite Runner, a book that opened my eyes to a world that I know so little about. As an added incentive all proceeds for the U.S. sale of this book will be donated to the International and National Centers for Missing and Exploited Children, so by reading this phenomenal piece of fiction you will in some small way help these children.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
14 of 14 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Deeply disturbing, just as it should be, July 27, 2009
This review is from: The Blue Notebook: A Novel (Hardcover)
Customer review from the Amazon Vine™ Program (What's this?)
I am always very reluctant to read books written by men, speaking as women. This book, by a white male physician speaking as a tween/teen Indian sex slave, seemed destined for failure as a concept. To the publisher's credit, they got way out in front of that reluctance and implore you to "read it anyway, because it matters." I'm not sure that I ever completely bought the narrator's voice, but it worked well enough that I gobbled through this book in two sittings, even though it will take far longer than that to get it out of my head. The narrator is about the same age as my youngest child, and I think of that 4th grade class, and think of them being subjected, at that age, to the things described in this book.... It's all the more frustrating to read because there is no outrage, no emotion, no self-pity in the book. There is no magical resolution to the ills of the world that brings Batuk to the place she is forced to occupy, and she doesn't wait for or expect one. She suffers, she continues to exist, she survives until she can't. And yet her human value, uniqueness, and undeniable intellect are ever present. It is a very hard book to let go of, once it is done. After I finished it, I found myself waking up in the middle of the night, turning the last pages over in my head, wanting to write a different ending, wanting to ride in and rescue the character I had grown to like so much. I think that makes it a successful writing endeavor, and I have to applaud the author for taking me there.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
11 of 12 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
"You can never fully straighten bent metal; you can only make it less bent.", June 18, 2009
This review is from: The Blue Notebook: A Novel (Hardcover)
Sometimes when I read a book that is particularly affecting, I refer to it as "life altering." But when I refer to The Blue Notebook as life altering, it isn't to remark of its genius rendition, sumptuous prose, or eerily strong characterization. Simply put; The Blue Notebook by James Levine so thoroughly disturbed me, it left me haunted. I think we all know that the sickening practice of child sex slavery occurs, and we are justifiably disgusted. But only when confronted with the voice of a fifteen year old prostitute as she describes her tragic and hopeless world does one realize this is a global problem that we shouldn't ignore. Levine's purpose is to raise awareness and funds to stop child exploitation. And his method is the tortuous bombardment of atrocities that are committed against his narrator and other children. Batuk was sold into slavery by her impoverished family at nine. She is quickly "taken" after which she ends up in a cage no larger than a toilet servicing around ten men a day. Her life is colored by sadism, rape, violence, starvation, and disease. She is betrayed in some form by everyone who can use her to some purpose to further their greed or perversion. Abused in everyway imaginable, Batuk considers herself blessed because she can read and write. And so Batuk journals, and uses every opportunity to scratch out her story and observations. "I am not sure why I write but in my mind I shudder that it may be so that one day I can look back and read how I have melted into my ink and become nothing." These are her hopes to die, disappear, service only one man, or become deranged. It will suffice to say this is not an uplifting tale. Levine is relentless with horrific details, and increasingly terrible situations in which he places Batuk. His only gift to the reader is that his story is relatively brief. The ending is ambiguous, after reading it several times; I'm still not sure what happened. Such a bizarre ending and menacing tone recalls Burnside's The Glister. The Blue Notebook is an ugly story, but even if the writing was poor (instead it is excellent), I'd recommend this book. If you can manage to read it, do so, and if you can't, buy it regardless. Levine's passion is exceedingly obvious, so much so that he's donating his proceeds to the International and National Centers for Missing and Exploited Children--the only bright spot his novel offers.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|