Most Helpful Customer Reviews
15 of 15 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Independant ex-cop finds heart, November 29, 1998
Destined to become a classic of the genre. This is a rip-roaring, unputdownable, cracking page turner. A stunningly well paced narrative, building from a slow burn start to an ending that delivers a devastating blow. Aud Torvingen - 6ft Norwegian Uberbabe. Ex-cop, and now bodyguard, self-defence expert, freefall skydiver, master carpenter, glacier climber and top horticulturist to boot(!!). A lethal killer. Super-cool, confident and in control. But becomes fallible as soon as she falls in love with Julia Lyons-Bennet, the woman whom Aud has been hired by, to protect. This is a bitter-sweet love story, with a strong central character that you care deeply about. In Aud Torvingen, Nicola Griffith has created the quintessential Lesbian Icon. Intriguing, complex and believable. By the very nature of the genre you know a tragedy is just waiting to happen. And the bad guy is screamingly obvious. But this doesn't matter. It is the journey that counts. The narrative takes you to places you don't usually come across in this genre, and has a beautiful sence of time and place. Very evocative of the Norwegian landscape, mixing as it does myth and fable, the fjells, local cuisine, character and temperament. The novel itself is reminiscent of David Lindsey's 'Requiem for a Glass Heart' in it's central Lesbian relationship, breakneck narrative thrust and killer ending. Like all great novels 'The Blue Place' leaves you desperate for more. But how can any future installments ever hope to compare with such an astonishing and accomplished work - and one that is so obviously a one off. A pleasure to read this outstanding novel. Extremely Highly Recommended.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
12 of 12 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
kind of a dud, May 2, 2002
By A Customer
This review is from: The Blue Place (Paperback)
I love Amazon for offering the ability to see other readers' opinions of a book, but now I'm going to think twice before believing everything I read here. I feel a little like I was tricked into buying this book by the numerous positive reviews, so now I'm taking the time to warn other hopeful searchers: turn back while you still can - it wasn't that great. After reading the book, I was far from impressed. In a word, it was: underdeveloped. The characters had little or no depth, the plot was overall pretty boring, and the writing very basic. It didn't take me anywhere, and I couldn't even care one wit about the ending or what happened to the characters. When trying to relate to the narrator and/or her story, I only ever felt like I was reading some anti-climactic manifestation/fantasy of the author's own identity. And about the "steam" factor, suspense, or sexual tension: Griffith must've left it with the rest of the character/plot development. It's like the author can't quite bring herself to fall into the romance of the world/characters she's created (like she doesn't want it to be another cliche lesbian romance novel with the usual stereotype characters) so instead, her book suffers from technical hang-ups, a cheesy array of writing techniques, and two-dimensional characters that, ironically enough, all lend themselves to exactly what she's trying to avoid. In the beginning, I was really looking forward to liking the main character and wanting to read the sequel, but by the end I found myself wondering what all the hype was about and wishing I'd never spent the money in the first place. If you're looking for anything as remotely interesting as, say, a Sarah Waters or Jeanette Winterson or even a John Irving or Stephen King novel, look elsewhere. I've read worse (hence the 2 star rating), but I've also read far far better, so I just HAD to speak up and say that the book was not nearly as good as its reviews suggest. Even some of the truly cliche, predictable xena/gabrielle-type romances I've read (see: Lucifer Rising) were eons more satisfying than this.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Great language, spotty plot, January 26, 2000
This review is from: The Blue Place (Paperback)
I loved Griffith's _Ammonite_... beautiful rich characters, detailed setting and intricate plot. I was hoping for an equal treatment of the detective novel format. Griffith's language in _The Blue Place_ is still incredible, especially the first time Julia and Aud spar <purrr>. However, the plot development is significantly weaker, with many logical gaps and hanging threads. For example, near the beginning, she references Aud's 60-year-old handmade quilt, which no one else has ever seen. It would have been nice to at least mention it near then end as a point of loss. The bad guy (I won't mention who) isn't a clear picture, despite his importance in Aud's life. It's a good read, tho! Enjoy!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
