Most Helpful Customer Reviews
59 of 61 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Now this is Scrapbooking, September 14, 2005
This review is from: The Bob Dylan Scrapbook, 1956-1966 (Hardcover)
Bob Dylan scrapbook.
This is a wonderful trip down memory lane.
The text of the book
The book basically a narrative of the years from 1956 to 1966. It provides a nice insight to Bob Dylan before the fame up to Blonde on Blonde. Most of it the true Dylan aficionado would already know, but it is very well written. The book is only 64 pages in length and can be read in a couple hours if you don't stop to examine the scraps.
The Scraps.
These are special. The book is heavily laced with reproductions of memorabilia from advertisements for Zimmerman furniture and electric,concert tickets, photos, newspaper clippings taped to the pages to advertisments for shows. My favorite scraps are the reproductions of hand written lyrics for Talking New York, Blowin in the wind, It ain't me babe, Chimes of freedom, Gates of Eden, Like a rolling stone and She's your lover now.
The CD.
This contains about 45 minutes of interviews that are chopped up into short segments. Sometimes you get to hear the interviewers question and sometimes you don't but you can usually figure out what the question might have been based Dylan's answer. On the CD Dylan will ramble on a little but it is all good. During some of the interviews when he speaks it seems like it is the same cadence as Like a rolling stone and other times more in the cadence of MR Tambourine man which is something I never realized until I listened to this CD. Some of the interviews are actual interviews from that time period and some are newer and are of Dylan reflecting on that time period.
Summary:
This is a really interesting to read, look at and listen to. A nice ride on Dylan's magic swirling ship. You will not be disapointed, a five star book all the way.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
17 of 19 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Great fun -- even if you're not a Dylan fan!, September 21, 2005
This review is from: The Bob Dylan Scrapbook, 1956-1966 (Hardcover)
The Bob Dylan Scrapbook is a gas, a hoot and an adventure to boot. You don't just read this volume -- you experience it. It's like stumbling across Bob's private memento box or riffling through his attic. Amazing stuff indeed.
When I went to the bookstore this week to ask about it, three excited store clerks stormed out from behind the information desk and escorted me to the display. "You've GOT to see this!," they shouted. "It is JUST SO COOL."
The Bob Dylan Scrapbook is just that -- a scrapbook with actual (authentic-looking) bits of memorabilia tucked inside little compartments and taped (by hand) to many of the pages. We're talking newspaper clippings, handwritten lyrics, advertisements, concert tickets, promo flyers, little bits and pieces of every day life -- starting way back in Hibbing, Minnesota, and continuing right up through Bob's explosive rise on the world music scene. What a classy bit of history -- all bound up in hard cover with its own special slipbox and a CD full of condensed radio interviews (plus movie notes about Martin Scorsese new flick, "No Direction Home.").
The text by Robert Santelli, whom I believe worked on the exhibit called "Bob Dylan's American Journey" at the Experience Music Project in Seattle, is mostly straightforward narrative without a lot of deep insights or analysis. That's OK -- there's plenty of complicated Dylanology out there for those who want it.
Bottom Line -- Even if you don't particularly like Bob Dylan, or don't "get" the whole fuss about his music and lyrics, you'll really enjoy reading this new book, if only as a cultural experience. Only one thing is missing: Winter photos of northern Minnesota (Duluth and Hibbing), where 18 inches of new snow is called "a light dusting." (I lived there for a while.)For a hint of that blizzardy childhood, listen to Bob's wonderful song "Winterlude" from his 1970 "New Morning" album.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
11 of 12 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Great coffeetable book for the holiday., September 23, 2005
This review is from: The Bob Dylan Scrapbook, 1956-1966 (Hardcover)
Because Scorsese's documentary stops at 1966, this is not the comprehensive Dylan book (even Dylan's own book isn't THE comprehensive Dylan book, but I think out of respect for his kids he's kept that story via song), but this is great for the people who have gotten into Bob's more recent CDs and want to know about the early days, but more so for the people who remember him as the folkie turned rocker whose motorcycle accident is still surrounded by myth.
The book isn't out to dispel myth, but is what it is, a scrapbook with stories. I had an Elvis book similar to this, and this one seemed to be filled with more "scraps", reproductions of concert tickets, articles, album covers, lyrics, concert programmes, and promotional photos as well as a store promo and an interview CD. I was surprised that the book was not more expensive the way the layout is.
The downside (which there really is none)is that there seems to be a bit too much promotional material surrounding the documentary, between the Gaslight CD, the 6 song concert EP that some stores are selling, the soundtrack, the DVD, and that's without even mentioning the PBS broadcast.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|