Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
19 of 22 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A time of shame and sorrow, December 3, 2006
Robert F. Kennedy was adored by the masses when he won the primary for the Democratic party, on his way to becoming the president. Then, like his presidential brother, he was gunned down in public. (That was WAY before I was born, so much of what I know comes from books)
Emilio Estevez doesn't exactly focus on that in "Bobby." Instead, he creates an elaborate "Grand Hotel"-style plot, focusing on the people who surrounded Kennedy on the last day of his life. The movie is a little scattered throughout the first parts, but Estevez yanks it together in time for the inevitable, tragic denouement.
The entire movie takes place on one day: June 4, 1968. The place: Los Angeles' Ambassador Hotel. And there's as much drama out of the campaign as in it: For example, the manager (William H. Macy) is cheating on his smart beautician wife (Sharon Stone) with the switchboard girl (Heather Graham), but takes some time out to fire a racist supervisor (Christian Slater) because the guy won't let the black and Latin employees vote.
The doorman (Anthony Hopkins) and his pal (Harry Belafonte) play chess and talk. A lounge singer (Demi Moore) is struggling with alcoholism, a young girl (Lindsay Lohan) is marrying a guy she doesn't love (Elijah Wood) to keep him from going to Vietnam, and campaign workers drop acid. Their stories are only loosely intwertwined -- until Sirhan Sirhan arrives.
Estevez has created a movie that Tries To Have It All. It tackles racism, war, love, voting, women's rights, and the adored icons of an era. It also stars just about every kind of actor: veterans, Bratpackers, ex-sexpots, MTV stars, party girls and accomplished young actors.
In fact, "Bobby" spills over with plot and characters, and for the first two thirds, it seems that there is almost too much of EVERYTHING. But Estevez captures the you-are-there ambience, with crisp suits and longer dresses, neat hair, period music and the occasional baseball reference. For a day, you ARE in Los Angeles in 1968.
And he has a knack for creating a sense of foreboding and sadness, which hangs independently of the characters. Yet in some scenes where Kennedy is supposed to be speaking, the shining eagerness that you see in the audience's faces is enough to bowl you over. It captures the hope that was present during that era, and afterwards died quickly, as hope usually does.
The enormous cast makes it hard to single out one, but there are several good ones: Laurence Fishborne and Freddy Rodriguez as cooks who discuss the racism they struggle with, Macy as the manager who struggles to regain his lost youth by an affair, Stone as his faded beauty of a wife, and Wood's bittersweet, ironic portrayal of the young groom.
Kennedy himself is a nebulous figure -- most of what we see are archival clips, which show the young candidate's charisma and power. Although "Bobby's" take on him is rather naive, it does leave you wondering how he might have changed the US, had he lived.
"Bobby" is high on ambition, and Estevez manages to create a truly poignant, thought-provoking film. It has its flaws, but it also captures a shocking moment in American history.
|
|
|
11 of 13 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
An Important Day In A Hopeful Era, November 23, 2006
This movie was much different and even better than I expected. It really wasn't so much about Bobby Kennedy the man but more about what he represented to America in 1968. The film follows various people throughout their day at the Ambassador Hotel as they awaited Kennedy's arrival the night of his assassination. The huge ensemble cast includes William H. Macy as Paul the hotel manager, Demi Moore as alcoholic night club singer Virgina Fallon and Martin Sheen as Jack, a rich guy who is in psychotherapy for depression and beginning to question the materialistic and superficial lifestyle of he and his wife. Some other significant story lines involve two young Kennedy aides taking their first LSD trip, a humble and thoughtful young Latino kitchen worker and a couple about to get married so that the guy will be sent to Germany rather than Vietnam.
The movie also skillfully mixes in a substanial amount of archival footage from the Kennedy campaign that shows the enthuiastic, almost euphoric, crowds that flocked to meet him. Portions of several Kennedy speeches are also played back and they demonstrate the optimism and power of Kennedy's message. His words reminded me most of the great poet Walt Whitman in their call for America to realize it's highest potential as a true "land of the free" for all its people. It's the sort of idealism you don't hear too often nowadays and that's a shame.
The characters are brought to life by some tremendous acting and their stories are all quite interesting. But, more than any single individual, this movie is really about capturing what America and its people were like on June the 6th, 1968. The public was divided and in turmoil over the war in Vietnam, race relations were strained to the point of violence and gender roles were changing, as both women and men began to question the status quo. At this time Bobby Kennedy represented a change for the better to millions of Americans, especially racial and ethnic minorites, the poor, women and others who weren't being given an equal opportunity.
I am too realistic about politics to believe that Bobby Kennedy was a saint or that America would be a perfect place if he had been elected president. But there is no doubt that RFK still stands as an important symbol for hope, justice and a brighter future for all Americans.
|
|
|
11 of 14 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A Glimpse Into What Could Have Been, February 11, 2007
A pivotal moment in the history of the world has been captured by writer/director Emilio Estevez in his brilliant film, "Bobby," a chronicle of the day Senator and Presidential hopeful Robert F. Kennedy was murdered in the kitchen of the Ambassador Hotel in Los Angeles in June, 1968.
On June 6, 1968, when RFK died, the hope of a nation died along with him. It was the day that began a downward spiral of true democracy in the United States of America, which has taken us, finally, as a country, into the darkness of corporate corruption and political despotism.
Which is why this film is so important.
With this film, Estevez, rather than put together just another filmed biography, has reignited the light that was Bobby Kennedy. Rather than throw facts, figures and debate at you, he instead resurrects the spirit of the man, and in doing so captures the very essence of who Robert Kennedy was and what he stood for. And he succeeds in large measure by using archival footage of Kennedy, rather than casting an actor in the role, which allows the viewer to experience Kennedy as he really was, to hear the compassion in his voice and see it in his eyes. Listening to Kennedy deliver a speech is moving and powerful; and for those too young to remember, or for those who were not around at the time, it affords the opportunity of knowing what it was like to hear words that really meant something, coming from a politician who really cared and knew how to convey the truth of his convictions with such eloquent determination.
What a marked contrast to the empty rhetoric and falsehoods espoused by the inarticulate, semiliterate demagogue currently in power.
As the film points out, Kennedy came from privilege, and he knew it; and he felt obliged (in his own words) to give something back. He said it and he meant it. Bobby Kennedy had a vision of how truly great this country could be, and wanted to do something about it. Unfortunately for all of us, Fate intervened.
The individual stories of the many characters in the film are interesting and well presented, but on their own they are not that important, nor were they meant to be. The drama that plays out among them as that dire moment we all know is coming approaches is the drama of all of our lives; they are Everyman and Everywoman, and they are there to set the stage and lend emotional ballast to the story. And under the care and guidance of Estevez it works, as it enables the viewer to identify and relate to what is happening, and what is about to happen.
The all-star cast includes Anthony Hopkins, Helen Hunt, Demi Moore, Harry Belafonte, Laurence Fishburne, Ashton Kutcher, Lindsay Lohan, Freddy Rodriguez, Elijah Wood, David Krumholtz, Heather Graham, Joshua Jackson, Sharon Stone, William H. Macy, Martin Sheen, Shia LaBeouf, Nick Cannon, Brian Geraghty and Emilio Estevez.
In this film, Estevez does not place Bobby Kennedy on a pedestal; he does not portray him as a fallen god. What he does is capture the spirit of a time and a man who carried the hope of a nation in his dreams. Estevez proffers no conspiracy theories and no fingers are pointed in this film. "Bobby" is simply what it was meant to be: A glimpse into what could have been and never was. And it makes you long for a leader you can trust, someone you can truly believe in; for a country that stands tall and is not undermined by ersatz "patriotism." This film makes you long for the restoration of the real America.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|
DVD ~ Shia LaBeouf
DVD ~ Sirhan Sirhan
DVD ~ Robert F. Kennedy
DVD ~ Patrick Dempsey
DVD ~ Robert Downey Jr.
