84 of 97 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Heymann's work is simply not credible, October 10, 2009
This review is from: Bobby and Jackie: A Love Story (Hardcover)
My in-depth review of all of Heymann's work appears here: [...]. I strongly encourage you to read the whole thing. Otherwise, here's a quick summary of just this book.
Heymann's book is simply not credible. First of all - and let's clear this up before we begin - he is NOT a Pulitzer Prize "nominee." That term is reserved for people the Pulitzer Prize committee selected as finalists. Heymann was simply an entrant - meaning, his publisher submitted his book in the HOPE of getting a nomination. I verified this both by talking to his current editor and by talking to the Pulitzer Prize committee.
Suffice it to say if you believe what's in the book, stay away from real estate brokers, as you are clearly at a disadvantage. He provides footnotes for items that are not new, and doesn't footnote his more astonishing claims. Heymann relies heavily on his purported interview with a guy who died several years before Heymann started writing about the Kennedys. And some of the more sensational claims for that interview are, surprise, not in his earlier books on the Kennedys. Did he only just rediscover things you truly couldn't forget on first hearing?
All the people who he has making extraordinary claims regarding an affair between Jackie and Bobby are dead. How convenient. If that's not what they said, they are no longer alive and able to sue.
Now perhaps Heymann is being fed bad information by his researchers. He credits a number of them for this book. Maybe Heymann is the gullible dupe. But his researchers didn't list him as a three-time Pulitzer Prize nominee when he wasn't. That was Heymann's doing. I suspect most other "mistakes" are his alone, as well.
I've tried to use his other books for research before, but his footnoting wouldn't pass a History 101 course. He'll source the right book in some cases but the wrong page number, and when you finally find the relevant passage, you'll see he quoted this wrong. For that reason, I'm unable to use his books in any of my own research. It's not worth the time to try to figure out what he got right.
If you like novels and hate the Kennedys, then this may be the book for you. If you have a serious interest in history, however, this book will not help you. And woe to other authors who quote from his unsourced claims. They'll reveal themselves to be shoddy researchers in a field mined with plenty of disinformation already.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
49 of 59 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Tiresomely opportunistic (and somehow cheap), August 2, 2009
This review is from: Bobby and Jackie: A Love Story (Hardcover)
I too was curious when I bought the book, and am ashamed of myself for giving way to my curiosity,particularly since my purchase has increased this author's income. He has made a living off this family, and has done so by purveying sleazy reading material to the greedy public, of which I now have, to my shame, become an too-willing member. The book is no more than a rehash of rumors, innuendo and cheap gossip, and I found myself grieving for Mrs. Kennedy's daughter, nearly the last surviving member of a family who has had to suffer through too much of this tabloid trash as it is. There's nothing new here, save for a titillating title and a lot of speculative gossip, some of which may or may not be true. And, my God, at this juncture, who cares? The principals are, for the most part, dead, and seemingly are still not allowed to rest in peace. Whatever comfort any of them found in one another's presence is surely a matter for gratitude, and not this cheap, tawdry speculation which adds nothing to anyone's life and can only wound the living. I am ashamed of myself for succumbing to the temptation to buy this book, and I found it to be Heymann's usual trash.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
70 of 87 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Jackie and Bobby: Tragedy United Them, July 21, 2009
This review is from: Bobby and Jackie: A Love Story (Hardcover)
I read through this book quickly and although there've been some doubts by various Kennedy apologists and people who STILL hate to believe that celebrities and politicians are HUMAN, it seems clear that Jackie and Bobby were extremely close and loved each other. What exactly they did behind closed doors is perhaps not essential to the tragic tale of the Kennedy family but I certainly found it interesting to explore the possibility that these two, who survived the death of a man they loved dearly, came together briefly. It was a love with serious limitations since one of the lovers was married and had a large family. It was also short-lived since Bobby died not long after his brother, making this tale even sadder. But in reality, Jackie needed someone to confide in and be with and why would anyone find it so hard to believe that she might rely on her late husband's beloved brother? This has happened over and over in history and literature.
The book was well written and a quick read. I couldn't put it down. Jackie was a woman like no other, although she was human, too. What a story!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No