Customer Reviews

Bone-Pedlar Hb

5 star:		(1)
4 star:		(1)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

Hamilton is a refreshing change to overrated authors of the historical fiction genre such as Elizabeth Chadwick, Candace Robb and Ellis Peters.

The goodies are believable because they have their flaws and the baddies are believable because you understand what they are up to. I also loved the humour which actually helps the thrill and suspense have more impact in the other parts of the novel.

Hamilton understands that you can't take modern characters and stick them in medieval setting and call it a medieval novel. She actually gives them a medieval outlook as well and pays attention to her minor characters as well.

The good news is that there is a follow up already published and more planned.

Sylvian Hamilton writes some of the best opening lines ever: 'In the crypt of the abbey church at Hallowdene, the monks were boiling their bishop...' She certainly doesn't whitewash the life of that period, but tells a wonderful, captivating story with strong characters. Although I felt this book a bit less strong the book three, The Gleemaiden-forgiven as it is the first book after all, it was still wonderful. I have become a huge fan of Ms. Hamilton, can't wait to read the second and for her to write the fourth. This series has become a definite favorite of mine. (Later note: Ms. Hamilton passed away in February 2005. Her 4th book remained unfinished.)

Hamilton has given us a good first effort with this novel; however, the reviewer who claims that her work is better than the "overrated" Ellis Peters and Candace Robb needs to read the book again...it doesn't come close to the work of either of these prolific, excellent authors!