Most Helpful Customer Reviews
9 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Addams Familyesque World, March 6, 2008
I just finished reading this book today and it is so good that I had to write this review. The first thing I liked about this novel is the worldbuilding, which reminds me of the Addams Family. There's a similar gothic creepiness and dark humor. Imagine if the whole world were like the Addams Family! This parallel Earth, has perpetually dark skies, multiple sentient species in addition to humans, and "necroflux," which is a form of energy produced by the "dead."
In the story, cop Donal, uncovers a sinister conspiracy which among other things, murders artistic people for their vivid "bone dreams." They also want to deprive non-human sentients of their civil rites, which is reminescent of the X-men series. There are multiple twists and turns, including a major one for Donal. I can hardly wait for the sequal were Donal adjusts to his new "status."
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Deliciously Dark, May 31, 2007
John Meaney's latest book "Bone Song" is on one hand a departure from his Nulpeiron Sequence novels while at the same time highlighting Meaney's greatest literary gift: the ability to create new and original worlds.
Donal Connor is a cop in the classic noir sense; he lives in a world where humans and supernatural creatures coexist and often times work side by side. Although the book is people by interesting three dimensional characters, the real "character" of the book is the city of Tristopolis; a gothic city (picture London coupled with Paris with no daylight). The world in which Tristopolis is situated is literally powered by the dead. Computers replaced by sentient spirits and magic; werewolf security systems not to mention a sexy boss/partner that also happens to be a zombie.
After a series of brutal murders of famous artists, Donal is given the mission of protecting a glamorous Diva who is possibly next on the list and the fun begins there. Although the novel is incredibly dark, Meaney takes that darkness and plays with it, creating interesting shades of grey.
It seems these days that the science fiction book market is filled to saturation with vampire slaying, Dominatrix type novels aimed at readers that previously had subscriptions to the "romance paperback of the month Club". If this is your cup of tea, then take a pass on Bone Song. However, if you're interested in something truly different, Bone Song might be your latest page turner. Definitely worth the read.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Very disappointing second half, but great first half and worldbuilding, March 30, 2009
This review is from: Bone Song (Mass Market Paperback)
2.5, maybe. I haven't been so disappointed in a book since I don't know when, chiefly because it has such incredible worldbuilding and because the first half of the book absolutely blew me away. I was completely enmeshed in the world and the characters and couldn't wait to get back to it each time I put it down.
About halfway through, though, it seemed to have a schizophrenic breakdown. The previously tight and compelling POVs (split between two main characters) mushroomed into multiple, shallow head-hopping POVs which seriously diluted the flow of the story and the characterizations. That would have been bearable (because the worldbuilding remained amazing and compelling, the plotting intricate), but then the characterizations and plot went to hell as well. People started falling in love instantaneously for no apparent reason; others launched on paths of boneheaded revenge for really cooked up motives that had more to do with authorial convenience then true motivations. Even the characters, late in the book, admitted they were stupid. Plot points were thrown in for no good reason except that, again, the author needed to get someone from point A to point B and show off more worldbuilding; the main character turned into a Maury Stu-type character that could do no wrong and was the best of the best, easily victorious in any contest; and absolutely no care was given to the emotional underpinnings of the story. Things happened, we were supposed to care, but they were so paint-by-number, handled so woodenly and shallowly, that I found myself not caring at all.
But that worldbuilding! Wow. I kept reading long after I would have put most books down because the depth and originality of this world dominated by death, the macabre, and the dead was truly breathtaking. If you love books with dazzling settings and don't care overmuch if the characters have no more depth than a video game and the plotting bears more resemblance to a software program, you'll probably enjoy this book more than I did. I think if the first half of this book hadn't had everything going so damned well, I wouldn't have been as severely disappointed. As is, I'm not sure I'll bother reading any more in this series.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|