It's been said that "love is a many splendored thing." Actually, from what I can recall, I think that's even been sung. In any event, love serves many roles in our respective lives. It gives us direction and inspiration. It forces us to think about who we are and what we want from another. It gives us the fuel to get up and face another day, and it prompts us to try to be a better person. However, the flip side to the coin is that love often times leaves us challenged. It presents obstacles we're not entirely certain of surmounting. When not cared for, it can leave us scarred, forever altered - even a shell of the person we were before we found it - forever distant, and forever tossed about on a sea of indifference. It's our greatest pain and our fondest reward for a life truly lived and fully explored.
That's precisely what makes it a many splendored thing.
BONSAI is the story of a struggling young author, told through his experiences in his present day and the life-changing love affair he endured eight years previous. A younger Julio (played by Diego Noguera) meets and falls head-over-heels for Emilia (Natalia Galgani), a classmate with some deep-rooted issues surrounding commitment. However, the present day Julio - struggling to find employment - opts to craft a romantic novel all of his own, and he uses his own reflections of his days with Emilia to do so. He reads the completed passages to present day girlfriend and neighbor, Blanca (Trinidad Gonzalez), though he covers it all up by lying to her, suggesting that he's ghostwriting a novel for an established author and that the romance is not his. However, a chance encounter with an old friend presents Julio with a unique challenge: Emilia is back in the country, living in the city. Will he see her again now that his fire has been rekindled, or should he leave those `demons' in his past?
The film is an adaptation of a novel of the same name, and writer/director Cristian Jimenez has done a respectable job turning it into a film. (From what I understand, the novel is a slim 90 pages.) The peoples, places, and events all seem real - perhaps a bit too real and/or droll at times as Julio and Emilia's relationship grows out of a series of casual events; however, that may be the intended appeal. There's an undeniable earthiness to all of it - the shooting locations certainly all resemble very average looking accommodations, so much so that they could be the antithesis of big budget Hollywood romances - and that's saying a lot for a story predicated on caring for trees.
Also, Jimenez approaches the subject matter with the same openness that author Alejandro Zambra puts in the novel, disclosing the fate of his principle characters right up front. The audience learns Julio and Emilia's fate in the opening scenes, leaving only a desire to learn how they get to their respective places as the motivating force for finishing the film. However, I'll admit that I struggled a bit with the flashback device. At first, I suspected that they weren't flashbacks, per se, that the narrator was telling the story of a novel only. As the layers are peeled away, it becomes clear that Julio has lived the novel, but the steps he goes to keep Blanca believing otherwise get very curious and given no legitimate explanation. Is he ashamed of how things ended with Emilia? Was he disgraced? Did he commit some grievous error? His motivation remains elusive - or if it was clearly stated then I completely missed it - and Emilia's eventual dismissal of him as her suitor is equally troubling. Did she secretly fall in love with someone else? Or did she simply grow weary of his companionship?
The subtle truth here is that there may be no definitive answer needed. The prime thrust of the story remains the metaphor - caring for a Bonsai tree is much like the care needed for a relationship. The drawback I would have stylistically is that I find no evidence to believe that had Julio behaved any differently then he would've produced any different outcome. (Again, if it was disclosed deliberately, I missed it.) Rather, Emilia seems to be a lost soul at times - one who gravitates between quiet moments lying in bed, snuggled up to her partner, or taking long, hot showers by herself. The implication is that she's lapsed into a deep, deep bout of depression, though the source remains absent.
Still, it's an interesting narrative, one with some deadpan moments of inescapable humor that elevate the story and push the viewer to stay involved. If the pacing had been tightened up a bit or either lead had been a bit more relatable, then BONSAI probably would've been a hit with audiences. As it is, it serves mostly as an art-house romance flick - think of (500) DAYS OF SUMMER without all of the obvious less-literate humor, and you get the drift.
BONSAI is a co-production of Rizoma Films and Ukbar Filmes, along with producing participation from Jirafa and Rouge International. DVD distribution is being handled through Strand Releasing. The film looks and sounds solid - there were a few sequences where sound was recorded very softly, so I had to amp up the volume a bit to understand some light dialogue. Additionally, the flick has garnered some great attention from the film festival circuit, including prizes from the Havana Film Festival and the Miami International Film Festival, as well as serving as the Official Selection for the Cannes, Telluride, Toronto International, Chicago International, Seattle International, San Francisco International, and San Sebastian International Film Festivals. The screener I was provided had no special features to speak of; something (anything!) would have been nice, but, alas, it wasn't meant to be.
RECOMMENDED. BONSAI isn't perfect. It's pacing leaves more than a bit to be desired. And there's never an easy answer provided for why some of these characters behave the way they do. Still, the film is underscored by a functional metaphor (the care of plants likened to the attention required of any relationship), and the low-key humor hits enough laughs to make it a passable enjoyment. Will it change your world? Probably not. Is it an acceptable way to spend a few hours studying romance and the human condition? That's a `budding' insight, if I ever heard one.
In the interests of fairness, I'm pleased to disclose that the good folks at Strand Releasing provided me with a DVD screener of BONSAI for the expressed purposes of completing this review.