Most Helpful Customer Reviews
32 of 32 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Bookseller's dream!, May 23, 2007
Imagine the possibility of finding a new play by William Shakespeare! During restoration work on a 16th century book enticing letters are found that hint at the existence of an unknown play by Shakespeare. Obviously a major coup and soon after the discovery everybody seems to after this unknown manuscript, including a bunch of Russian mobsters and some Jewish gangsters.
The novel is made up of three story lines that converge as the story develops. Richard Bracegirdle, the letter writer from the 16th century; Jake Mishkin an Intellectual Property Lawyer; and Albert Crosetti an aspiring filmmaker making a living working for an antiquarian bookshop. The author uses the written word eloquently to bring three distinct characters to life in such a way that you get absolutely and completely absorbed in the narrative. The novel does not totally focus on the thrill of the chase to find the illusive manuscript, but incorporates the (dysfunctional) lives and loves of the main characters to give a rounded whole.
This is a literary detective story, where you will find it difficult to anticipate where the narrative will take you next, with the only way forward to turn the pages quickly to the next and the next. I think the novel holds something for everyone, even if you don't know anything about Shakespeare or books. I have to admit that this book is one of the best I have read so far this year and will definitely anticipate the next book of this author.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
23 of 23 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Two thumbs up!, September 30, 2007
Having read Gruber's first two books Tropic of Night and Valley of Bones I wasn't sure I was ready for a third. The first two having left me a bit nonplussed. Don't get me wrong, I enjoy books and movies that take a detour around reality but those two books made a right angle turn somewhere and I'm not sure I'm over them yet!
TBoAAS is a whole other beast. Slow moving, tedious at times, it none-the-less hooked me and drew me in until I could not walk away. I felt that that the first 2/3's of the book moved at a glacial pace. Which is great if you want to fully involve youself in the characters and the plot. At some point, which I can't precisely pin down, the pace picked up and hauled me, open-mouthed, to the final pages.
Honestly, who would have thought combining a self-absorbed, womanizing lawyer (a heavy lifter, literally, to boot) with a dreamy young man who believes life is literally determined by the movies and setting them on what may or may not be a wild goose chase for an unknown Shakespearean manuscript could prove to be so entertaining?
As a mark of how well done the book is, I shed a few tears at the end, not because it was sad but because the story was over. To date only two other writers have affected me that way.
You don't have to be a literary, artsy type to get into this story, btw. You DO need to persevere long enough to let the story get hold of you. Then you're stuck. Happily so, I might add.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
167 of 195 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Disliked enough to drive me to write my first review, March 19, 2008
In all the years that I've been buying books on Amazon I have never taken the time to write a book review. Lazy? Yes. Selfish? Probably. But this novel irked me enough that I had to finally post words online. Let me say that I am a book a week reader with a wide variety of tastes. Only about once or twice a year do I put a book aside unfinished. And Book of Air and Shadows gets that dubious distinction for 2008.
The main reason? Jake is unbearable to read. I'm all for an anti-hero. In fact I kind of dig them. But Jake is so smarmy and proud of his bedroom conquests that I couldn't help wondering if the author was perhaps giving us insight into his own frustrated sexual fantasies.
So okay. Jake likes sex. Cool. Go for it guy. But when 75% of what he has to say is about bedding women it's not exactly helping propel the story forward.
My frustration was compounded by the fact that the other narrators were more interesting and actually had something to say...storywise. Each time I turned the page and saw it was a Jake chapter I groaned outloud. Finally I had to just give up the fight.
There it is. My first ever review. Sure hope it helps someone else out there in Amazon-land.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|