Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
49 of 53 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Fantastic read, absurd amount of information, October 27, 2009
I need to preface this by saying that I've been reading Bill Simmons for over 8 years now, before the fame, before the podcasts and almost frightening fan following.I've seen him mature from the old Boston Sports Guy to this all-media presence now, and in the process, his writing has greatly improved. The culmination of such an improvement is this wonderful book, "The Book of Basketball".
I managed to get an early copy of this book, and spent the next 48 hours plowing through it as fast as I could. It's very clear that Simmons put everything he had into the book. There aren't a lot of loose words around. Even the genitalia jokes are well-constructed. Yes, it's pretty good.
The basis of this book is determining who mattered in the NBA. Which teams, players, coaches, etc. played the biggest role in getting us to where we are today, in shaping our perception of what it takes to win in the NBA, and how we remember different players and events. It's very interesting to see him go back into the 60s and 70s and try to write about Walton, Russell, and Chamberlain and how they were perceived then, and try to get to see what forces created and changed that perception. This is ultimately what the book is all about. It reads almost like a history of the NBA, in a very easy-to-read style.
My personal favorites are his ABA pieces. Not nearly enough has been written about this crazy league, and Simmons did a very good job looking at just how things broke down, at what could have been, and how the ABA led to many fundamental changes in the NBA itself.
Finally, this is definitely a book for the NBA junkie. It's comic style and easy-to-read writing style does make it accessible to those with only mild-to-intermediate interest in the NBA, but at its core, it's for the junkies who want to fill up with as much NBA knowledge as possible. It's a great book, and for its price (as of October 27, 2009), a great deal.
|
|
|
30 of 33 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
buy the dead tree edition instead of the Kindle edition, October 28, 2009
(10/28) Still working my way through it, but here are my impressions so far:
(1) Buy the dead tree version even if you have a Kindle. Simmons buries an absurd amount of information in the footnotes, a lot more than just citations. They're set up as endnotes at the end of each chapter, which is awkward for Kindle users. The footnotes are almost like one of those extra audio tracks in a DVD where the director provides running commentary on a film; for better or worse, you're missing out on a lot if you skip the footnotes. Why he thought this was a good way to write a book is beyond me. But you're going to want to read the footnotes.
(2) if you bet "under 1.5" as the first chapter in which an NBA moment is compared to a scene in Shawshank Redemption, you covered.
(3) if this book had an MPAA rating, it would be rated R. He says things that he could never get away with in his ESPN columns. For example, he refers to going off birth control as "pulling the goalie" and calls the Hawks' selection of Marvin Williams in the 2005 draft (instead of Chris Paul or Deron Williams) "an Aretha Franklin sized mistake."
(4) I've probably read half a dozen different "Wilt or Russell?" articles over the years, and Simmons' handling of the debate is probably the best one.
Will update in coming days.
Update (11/3): Man Reads Entire Book of Basketball -- And Lives!
If the Bill James Historical Baseball Abstract is the '86 Celtics of sports history books -- a timeless classic that could succeed in any era -- then TBOB is the '79 Sonics: a championship team but not one that will be remembered forever, and one that could probably only have won a championship in its own time. Why does TBOB fall short of the absolute pinnacle? Is it because of the salty language? (No; recall that James' entry on Don Mattingly in the Abstract is "100% ballplayer, 0% bulls&%$.") Is it because Simmons can barely contain his disdain for players like Kareem and Laimbeer? (Again, no; James can barely contain his disdain for Rogers Hornsby, Dick Allen, Maury Wills, etc.) Is it the fact that the book contains some post-consumer content (e.g. the entry on Pete Maravich is basically lifted directly from an [...] column he wrote about Pistol a few years back?) Again, James recycled old material for the Abstract, so that's not it. Ultimately it's the endless barrage of throwaway pop culture references that is going to make this book feel dated quickly (people might still remember Teen Wolf or Rocky IV in ten years, but is anybody going to care about Keeping Up With the Kardashians in 2019?)
All told, this book has freakish athleticism, jumpability, length, and tremendous upside.
|
|
|
25 of 28 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Informative, hilarious and completely original, October 28, 2009
I am a definite basketball and NBA junkie and love the columns by ESPN writer Bill Simmons, so when I found out his new book on the topic of basketball was coming out this fall, I had to put in a preorder this summer to get my copy. Released the same day as the beginning of the NBA season, I finished it in two days and want to read through it again just to make sure I didn't miss anything.
This book is jam packed, with over 700 pages of material. Simmons is first and foremost a fan, so he writes in a tone that isn't objective, but from a fan's perspective, specifically a Boston Celtics fan. That includes obvious biases and jabs at the Los Angeles Lakers and some of their specific players, but Simmons doesn't let his hatred of the purple and gold overtake the book. He does, however, keep an informal tone throughout the book that makes it easy to read and understand for any fan, even if you don't completely agree with Bill's opinion. I never get the feeling of superiority or confusion that I do with some sports books. Reading this book is like sitting at the bar with one of you buddies, drinking beers and debating if Michael Jordan is really the greatest player of all time.
Though the size of the book might seem daunting, if you are an NBA fan you'll have no problem breezing through it with ease. Simmons runs the gauntlet of topics, ranging from his opinion on who was better in the Wilt vs. Russell debate, to what team really was the best NBA team in history to the origins of the Clippers curse to the Patrick Ewing theory, the referee scandals and his "feud" with Isiah Thomas. One topic I really enjoyed learning more about was the ABA. I've read many sports books and basketball books in general and none have ever really talked about the ABA. Simmons compares and contrasts the ABA with the NBA and it's really interesting and informative.
Of course, the book is hilarious and quite funny. Formerly a television comedy writer, Simmons never gets too serious or melodramatic with any of the topics. He includes many footnotes, which really act as humorous sidebars on different topics. At times, I did feel these went a tad overboard, but it wasn't to the point where it took away from the book or annoyed me too much.
If you're a sports fan, an NBA fan, or a Simmons fan, you will love this book. It's a book for the fans written by a fan himself.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|