Most Helpful Customer Reviews
10 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
entertaining yet strange historical horror novel, November 26, 2002
In France, six year old Herculine watches her mother die a horrible weird death leaving the child to fend for herself. Herculine arrives at the "stone", the holy house at C--- where the nuns take her in as the only scholarship student praying she one day will see God like they do. Years later, unable to resist, Herculine commits sins that require severe punishment as fears of evil and witchcraft are whispered among the residents of C----. While being incarcerated, four demons visit Herculine. The demon priest Father Louis, the damned Madeleine, the demonic Asmodei, and the evil witch Sebastiana come to open her mind to the full realm of pleasure. Herculine escapes with her rescuers to set on a quest to learn why she is the chosen. Her mission is filled with erotic dark magic and death as a revolution fueled by otherworldly madness leads to mass insanity and murder. Though well written in a weird meandering way filled with surprising shockers, BOOK OF SHADOWS is not for everyone as the story line contains graphic scenes of cruelty, abuse, and terror. The story line takes the traditional elements of a gothic novel (innocent vulnerable female, dark menacing males and a remote foreboding abode), but turns them upside down with a spin away from the genre due to the self-discovery of the dark side by the heroine. Herculine, who narrates the tale, keeps the center from imploding into a sea of uncontrollable weirdness so that the audience has an entertaining yet strange historical horror novel. Harriet Klausner
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A wonderfully written, historical gothic fiction novel, July 3, 2004
This review is from: The Book of Shadows (Mass Market Paperback)
Most books on Witchcraft today (be they fiction or non) tend to stick to either the actual Wiccan/Pagan religions, or rely on the most characteristic 'Hollywood Witch'- the beautiful woman with a broomstick who flies, is instantly powerful, etc. This book surprised me in many ways- most of all the main character's...interesting state. That and the authors' identification of a 'true Witch' by a certain mark in the eyes. This book is written with a very historical idea of Witches in mind- the wild sex of a Sabbat (which Reese terms an esbat, but I'm not complaining, fiction has a certain amount of allowance for poetic changes), the accompaniment of an incubus and succubus, the shape changing familiar, and most of all, the superstitions and spells/charms that were passed between the sisters were all of historical note. =) Take this from a modern day, real Witch- this is an excellent fictional read, and may educate you into France's, and some of Witchcraft's more bloody side of history. My hat's off to James Reese. I want a sequel, now, please....
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
6 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
I really, really wanted to like it, Mr. Reese ..., January 24, 2007
This review is from: The Book of Shadows (Mass Market Paperback)
It's interesting how a few reviewers have mentioned that they stopped at page 400. I stopped at 398, just a few pages after the "Greek Supper" section.
Every book has good points and bad points. I just wish that this one had more good points.
Good points: Character description - I had a very good idea of what each character looked like. Suspense scenes (when they managed to appear) - the scene with Herculine hiding in the lesser library while attempting to escape had me right there with her, cheering her on.
Bad points: Rambling narrative - far too many words to describe too little plot. This was the main problem. This book could have been condensed into at least half its size. Did we really need to know the endless, inane details of how Madeleine and Father Louis wound up as ghosts? Tangential characters - did we really need to know about the grandfather of Sebastiana's servant? Did we really need to know about the deformed Sabine? Sebastiana's B.O.S. - Good heavens, she's as wordy as Herculine (if not more!).
The other thing that bothered me (and I have no idea as to why the author did this) was the whole naming of cities and places as C__________ or Q _________ or X __________ or D___________. It's like someone spilled a few pieces of alphabet soup onto a map of France.
And yes, some Wiccan readers have gotten upset about the depiction of witches in the book (I'm Wiccan myself), but you have to bear in mind that this is fiction and he's not depicting Wiccans.
The bottom line is that this story had a LOT of potential. I liked Herculine, but her verbose description almost killed me. I really wanted to learn more about Asmodei - Lestat-like? Yeah, you could say that. Sexy? Very. Smarmy? Absolutely! - all the makings of an interesting character. I liked the setting of the book. But it just didn't all gel together.
The worst part is, I got this book and the next two in the series as gifts, which made me want to like this book even more. Sorry, Mr. Reese, but I have to give this one a thumbs-down.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|