61 of 69 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Useful work, but full of assumptions and errors, April 29, 2005
This review is from: The Book of Solomon's Magick (Paperback)
Let me start by saying, I suspect this will not be a popular review. For some reason the Goetia is one of these subjects that fosters a "fan boy" vibration for any author that writes on the subject. Anyone who produces a book on this material will have no end of reviews stating "This is the real thing!", "Best book of its kind!" and similar phrases of praise, completely devoid of specific or helpful information about the book's content. Never the less, this book makes some glaring errors, and what sort of magickian would I be if I didn't point them out to the novice?
First some of the attributions require the author to change the order of the entities involved. That is to say, the author actually over-rules Solomon, and "corrects" the order in which the spirits are laid out. Since they don't fall in line with his own beliefs, they MUST be out of order. Obviously!
Further, the author follows in the mistakes of Crowley, The Golden Dawn, The Aurum Solis, and Samuel Mathers in attempting to create attributions for the primary 72 djinn of Solomon's work, that have some flavor of symmetry. (please note that almost all of these sources disagree with each other, as well as the author of this book, as I will show later.)
The fact is, Solomon gave the proper attributions by way of their office, and the metal that their seal would be made of. Anyone with even a passing knowledge of the Western Tradition would be able to pick this out, but I will explain in detail, for the benefit of the novice reader.
Let's have a brief look at how Solomon laid these spirits out, and what his intentions were:
*** Spirits associated with the Sun are called KINGS. There are 9 of these in the text.
Bael, Paimon, Beleth, Purson, Asmoday, Viné, Balam, Zagan, and Belial. Their seals are to be made of gold.
*** Spirits associated with Venus are called DUKES. There are 23 of these, and it should be noted that the more feminine spirits fall here without any jury-rigging required by the Magickian. Agares, Valefor, Barbatos, Gusion, Eligos, Zepar, Bathim, Sallos, Aim, Buné, Berith, Astaroth, Focalor, Vepar, Vual, Crocell, Alloces, Murmur, Gremory, Vapula, Haures, Amdusias, Dantalion. Their seals are to be made of copper.
*** The spirits of Jupiter are called PRINCES AND PRELATES. There are seven spirits in this category.
Vassago, Sitri, Ipos, Gäap, Stolas, Orobas, Seere. These spirits should have their seals engraven on tin.
*** Spirits of the Moon are called MARQUISES of which there are 15.
Samigina, Amon, Leraje, Naberius, Ronové, Forneus, Marchosias, Phenex, Sabnock, Shax, Orias, Andras, Andrealphus, Cimeies, Decarabia. Following the same planetary metal scheme, these spirits are to have their seals imprinted upon sliver.
*** Spirits associated with Mercury are known as PRESIDENTS. There are 14 of these.
Marbas, Buer, Botis, Marax, Glasya-Labolas, Foras, Gäap, Malphas, Häagenti, Caim, Ose, Amy, Zagan, Valac.
*** Then there are a number of spirits associated with BOTH the Moon and Venus. These spirits are called EARLS, or COUNTS. There are nine of these spirits. (Again there is a feminine vibe here. Andromeda for example was the sacrificed daughter of Cassiopeia in Mythology)
Botis, Marax, Glasya-Labolas, Ronové, Furfur, Halphas, Räum, Viné, Bifrons, Andromalius.
*** Spirits of Saturn, oddly, there is only one. He is called a KNIGHT. His name is Furcas and obviously his seal is made of lead.
Saturn is a "malefic" planet, and has only a single representative. Notice that Mars, which would have a seal made of iron, is completely absent from the list. Mars being the other "malefic" celestial wanderer, this would seem to confirm that there is SOME method to Solomon's list, and that this is not just some scribe's mistake.
Now the REASON Saturn and Mars are under such a tight reign in the List of 72 is one of the Secret Lectures of the K.O.R. and rather than break my oath, I will simply point you in the right direction. For a clue to that mystery, I direct you to review the "Secret Seal of Solomon" as found in the Goetia. After a little meditation, I promise you an "Ah ha!"
Make sure you read how Solomon, himself used this seal. The answer is there in plain sight.
The desire to have a balanced number of Goetic Spirits assigned to elements, planets or the zodiac is natural, and I understand it completely. Unfortunately that isn't how they were laid out, and in fact there is much internal evidence that they are in the correct format, as delivered.
These 72 entities were generally accepted as androgynous. Being neither male or female, but one will note that most of the Dukes are the ones with female qualities, and indeed, the duke's sigils are to be imprinted on copper, the metal of Venus. (Astoroth, is a corruption of Astarte, once worshipped AS Venus!) One can see how I come to the conclusion that they are already sorted properly as to their sponsor planet.
However, there is contention among different occult schools just what any Goetic spirit's attributions should be, and I will briefly give some samples of the varying attributions, using Dantalion as the example spirit:
*** The Golden Dawn & Priscilla Schwei place Dantalion at 20-24 degrees of Pisces. His dates of power would be March 11-15. Planetary association is Mars. His element is water. The proper scent is Honeysuckle. Tarot card affinity is the ten of cups. Candle color for spells: purple.
*** Crowley puts Dantalion in the second decan of Pisces by night. The 777 key scale is 29. Planetary attribution is Venus. His element would be water.
*** Aurum Solis places Dantalion in the third quinance of Cancer. (Note Crowley places the djinn at decanates, and fills them with day spirits, then starts over with an equal number of night spirits. The Aurum Solis simply plots them out on the quinance model, doing away with assigning day and night stations. Also it should be mentioned that the A.S. rather than starting in Ares, starts the attribution in Leo, as was the habit of Mathers. That is all fine and well, if we can be sure Solomon was a student of Mathers. **chuckle**)
Why do all of these respected authorities disagree with each other, and more importantly the author of this book? Because they are all trying to force their own view onto the structure of the Goetia's curriculum, instead of being humble enough to accept the wisdom as it is given. There is a logic to dividing a list of 72 names by 12, and sorting them into neat little cosmic piles. However sometime 72 is just a number.
My personal opinion is that only the planetary attributions are indeed proper. This is how the original text of the Goetia seems to lay them out, and I see little use for attributing them to any of the tarot cards as we know them, or worse yet, to Chinese tri-grams of the I-Ching!
This is an interesting work of speculative Goetia. The Ceremonial procedures are dead on, and you will find them quite effective, however if you are picking this up on the author's claim of having "Corrected" the Goetia, you will led very far astray.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No