31 of 35 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
McMurtry gets better and better, November 28, 2000
I've been a reader of McMurtry's novels for years--I've always enjoyed his storytelling, but what I've seen over the years is a paring down of the details in his stories so that narrative and description of place are becoming displaced by the voice of the protagonists--who are not omnicient, but simply tell the story of themselves in circumstances over which they have no control.
Boone's Lick is a beautiful, simple novel. No--it's not Lonesome Dove and Lonesome Dove fans should not judge Boone's Lick based on their love of only one of McMurtry's novels.
McMurtry went through a dry period which included junk like the sequel to Terms of Endearment (I can't even remember the title of the book, it was so substandard), but I have been moved by both Duane's Dead, and now, Boone's Lick.
Readers who expect a great narrative will be disappointed by this novel. But those who expect subtle character development through the voice of a simple, gentle character to tell a story of the old west will be pleased. I'd advise any reader to be patient, and continue on--by the last 75 pages, I was unable to put the book down and wept at the end.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
23 of 27 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
An enjoyable read, November 14, 2000
No one writes a better Western Novel than Larry McMurtry. While this book does not match Lonesome Dove, it shows that he still has what it takes when it comes to a story about the old West. He can take simple situations and weave an interesting story with characters you can't help but fully visualize in your mind. My main complaint is that the story was too short. I think he could have gone deeper into the lives of many of the family members. Nonetheless, when you finish this book you'll have met a really unusual bunch of people. If you like McMurtry, I'm sure you'll enjoy this one.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
9 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Light entertainment from a master., April 1, 2005
There is no question this is a slight novel. With McMurtry's western novels, we usually get epic sweep, grand accomplishments, tragedy, massacre's, etc. etc. They are usually fabulously entertaining books, with the LONESOME DOVE saga and the BERRYBENDER CHRONICLES being the best examples. But they are not easy reads. They pull at the heart, make us grimace with pain, etc.
BOONE'S LICK is like an antedote for these books. Many of its themes are similar...the men who are ignorant of "civilized life," the elderly Native Americans who assist the whites, the end of the buffalo, the hardships and bad-luck of traveling across the west, etc. But there is a lightness of tone (and far less tragedy) then McMurtry's other books. It is not a towering achievement, by any stretch, but I found it to be fun, fast reading and still enlightening.
It basically tells the story of one woman's trip across dangerous country to confront her frequently absent, no-good husband. In tow she brings her two teenage sons, a teenage daughter, a baby, her husband's brother (who has always loved her), her sister and her elderly father...along with a bunch of mules. They pick up some other companions along the way too.
The first half of the book mostly establishes the characters and their amusing relationships in the town of Boone's Lick, Missouri. (A younger Wild Bill Hickock is an important character in this part of the book). When they suddenly hit the road (all but the mother VERY reluctantly), we follow them more or less across the Oregon Trail. Although some misfortune befalls them, the body count is low for McMurtry. There are amusing misunderstandings, befuddlements, and such, but little to be sad about.
I'm perplexed by the reviewers here who say the book is boring. It's very fast paced...just not very deep. But it paints an authentic feeling, and has some characters that, while they won't stay with you forever like Gus and Call from LONESOME DOVE, are certainly worth getting to know. I recommend the book for fans of McMurtry's style, but who don't want to plunge into a full-blown epic. It's also a book that I think younger readers might enjoy...very little of the usual sex and extremely graphic violence.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No