From School Library Journal
Grade 1-4–Jacobs's attempt to tell a story that incorporates a year of Jewish holidays is not completely successful. For Ruthie's seventh birthday, her grandmother gives her a candlestick and a box of candles containing one for every Shabbat and celebration. And so begins this tale of a year in the girl's life as a new neighbor becomes friends with, and ultimately marries, her grandma, and Ruthie goes from resenting him to wanting him to be a part of their family. The story is pleasant, the girl's feelings and character development are believably depicted, and the cast is likable. The writing is serviceable, although the dialogue is quite effective. Unfortunately, Jacobs seems to be trying too hard to encompass the holidays, allowing them to take away from the plot. The realistic watercolor illustrations are static, with a greeting-card style that is overly sweet in places, although there are a few good insets, especially the one of Ruthie working in the garden. This book could be a useful introduction in libraries searching for Jewish stories for early elementary grades, or for stories introducing the Jewish holidays. Others can consider it an additional purchase, or pass entirely.
–Amy Lilien-Harper, The Ferguson Library, Stamford, CT Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Gr. 2-4. As Ruthie goes through her seventh year, celebrating Shabbat and other Jewish holidays by lighting candles from the box given to her by Grandma Gussie, her world changes. First, she meets Mr. Adler, a new neighbor, who begins spending time with her beloved grandmother. Soon she is jealous; then she is angry. But finally, as Passover gives way to Shavot, Yom Kippur to Sukkot, and then Hanukkah, Ruthie begins to appreciate the kind, old man, who helps her ride a bike, takes her fishing, and is wise enough to let her find her own way to accept him. The art is colorful, if a little stiff; the chapter organization seems slightly odd in the picture-book format; and although Jacobs works in information about various holidays, kids will definitely need to refer to the glossary. It's the sweet, sensitive story of common emotions that carries the book; children will be comforted to see how even feelings as strong as jealousy and anger can sometimes change to love.
Stephanie ZvirinCopyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved