From Publishers Weekly
Simon, whose first foray into children's books was Amy and the Dancing Bear , here offers a holiday tale that she invented for her children when they were small. As a writer, Simon displays a developing feel for language, but the plot, which revolves around a boy named Ben and his suddenly mute sister, Miranda, is uneven, and the tone frequently becomes maudlin. Asked by his grandfather to ring the bells in the church steeple one Christmas Eve, Ben gets the bright idea to fetch Santa early by ringing the midnight bells at 11 o'clock. When Ben begs Santa for help with his sister's handicap, Santa suggests the lad wake the town in the morning with a symphony of bells. Ben does so, Miranda speaks again and readers are left completely mystified as to the cause of her ailment and its sudden cure. Datz's illustrations, though colorful and meticulously executed, are two-dimensional. It's a well-meaning book, but hardly the stuff of which classics are made. All ages.
Copyright 1990 Reed Business Information, Inc.
Review
"Beautifully illustrated, very attractive page presentation with clear, bold printing ... sympathetic story that appealed to boys and girls ... has a message that all children can appreciate ... The children repeatedly asked for it during the Christmas season." Somerset County Council Children's Books Review "The illustrations by Margot Datz are exquisite." Daily Express
--This text refers to an alternate
Hardcover
edition.