32 of 35 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Fussell is at it again, September 22, 2003
By A Customer
I suspect there is little middle ground for those who read Fussell and his work will resonate truly with some and will provoke accusations of being a pessimistic, bitter old man by others. If in reading about WWII you are looking for an unsparing impression of life in the American infantry after the Normandy invasion, something unsanitized by Zanuck, Spielberg, the History Channel or even Stephen Ambrose, this will fit the bill.
My own father served in the Hurtgen Forest area and in the Bulge as one of the "Boy Crusaders" Fussell writes about. It's uncanny to me how the attitude of the two are alike. There is no sentimentalizing, no attempts to varnish the time with nobility. It was what it was.
Reading Fussell hasn't helped me appreciate the magnitude of my father's (or Fussell's) experience. But it has helped me understand the anger that is till part of my dad, even now, sixty years on.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
46 of 53 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Food for Powder, December 24, 2003
By Bill Marsano. This book comes along just in time: Already I've been getting invitations from French tourism folks inviting me to learn all about their plans for next year's 60th anniversary of D-Day. (Do they actually give a damn any more, or are they just trying to revive their critically wounded tourist trade?) Think of it--sixty years. Soon enough there'll be no one left alive to tell the tale, and then the whole shebang--World War II from front to back--will be deeded over to Ken Burns for a series of sincere and oh-so-tasteful documentaries for his caramel-centered fans to lap up on PBS.
It's probably all that "good war" and "greatest generation" stuff that drove Fussell to write this book; he doesn't have much truck with gooey backward glances, and that will probably make some readers mad. Well, you don't come to Fussell--author of, among other things, "Thank God for the Atom Bomb, and Other Essays"--for good times. You come to Fussell for the hard stuff.
And here it is his contention that behind and beneath all that "greatest generation" nonsense was the Boys' Crusade--that last year of the war in Europe when too many things went wrong too often. The generals who'd convinced themselves that this war would not be a war of attrition--i.e., human slaughter--like the last one found they'd guessed wrong. Casualties were horrifyingly high and so huge numbers of children--kids 17-19 years--old were flung into combat. And they were, with the help of the generals, ill-trained, ill-clothed and ill-equipped.
They were also faceless ciphers. As Fussell points out, the US Army's policy was to break up training units by sending individual replacements up to the line piecemeal--one at a time--so they often arrived as strangers among strangers, often addressed merely as "Soldier" because no one knew their names. The result was too many instances of cowardice--both under fire and behind the lines--too many self-inflicted wounds to escape combat. Too many disgraces of every kind because the Army's system, Fussell says, destroyed the most important factor in the fighting morale of the "poor bloody infantry"--the shame and fear of turning chicken in front of your comrades. Many of these boys--and Fussell is properly insistent on the word boys--funked because they had no comradeship to value.
This is not in the least a personal journal. Fussell was serriously wounded as a young second lieutenant; he was also decorated. But he wisely leaves himself out of this narrative. There's no special pleading here, no showing of the wounds on Crispin's Day. Instead this is a passionate but straightforward report on what that last year was like for the poor bloody infantry--those foot soldiers, those dogfaces, those 14 percent of the troops who took more than 70 percent of the casualties.
And yet there were those who stood the gaff, who survived "carnage up to and including bodies literally torn to pieces, of intestines hung on trees like Christ,mas festoons," and managed not to dishonor themselves. They weren't heroes, Fussell says, just men who earned the Combat Infantryman's Badge, which was the only honor they respected. In a brief but moving passage, he explains why: It said they'd been there, been through it, and toughed it out.
This is a very short book. It's only 160 or so pages of text and they are small, paperback-sized pages. Nevertheless this book is an object lesson in writing that hits home like a blow to the solar plexus, that can double you over in pain and shock. I don't know a professional writer who wouldn't be proud to have written it.--Bill Marsano is a writer and editor with a long-time interest in military writing.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
20 of 22 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
nothing new but beautifully written, October 29, 2003
By A Customer
I have read all of Fussell's work on World War 2, and enjoyed much of it. But I detect a bitterness beneath the elegant prose - honest and refreshing when compared to the likes of Ambrose etc. - but annoying when it leads to generalizations and statements that just don't stand up if one does proper research.
There was nothing new in this book - much of it has been far better presented in other books - but as an exquisite, bitter-sweet appetizer, it deserves a star in any Michelin World War 2 guide. Had another writer, say someone who is unknown, written this, it would probably not have been published. Nevertheless, if all you've ever read is ultra-jingoist Ambrose and the strangely PC and weepy Bradley, then this will get your juices flowing. I then suggest reading the first person accounts of veterans that have rightly become classics. There are many, all of them far more revealing than Fussell because they are less academically and stylistcially self-conscious. Try The Medic, A Screaming Eagle, Company Commander, If I Survive. Then Fussell sounds like a whinger, however beautiful his prose style.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
